ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Development of Surfacing Electrodes for Hot Shearing Blades

Literature Overview and Core Intent

This paper from Yanshan University addresses a specific but critical industrial problem: the wear and failure of hot shearing blades used in continuous casting machines. The authors have developed a surfacing electrode that incorporates rare earth oxides, and they have demonstrated that the repaired blades outperform the original 3Cr2W8V solid blades by a factor of three to eight times in service life.

The significance of this work cannot be overstated. Hot shearing blades are a consumable component in continuous casting, and their failure directly impacts production. The original blades are made from 3Cr2W8V, a hot work tool steel that is expensive and difficult to replace. The ability to repair these blades with a surfacing electrode that extends their life by up to eight times is a major economic benefit.

The key technical innovation is the use of rare earth oxides. The authors have found that these oxides modify the inclusions in the deposited metal, refine the primary crystallization structure, and improve the hot plasticity of the weld metal. This is a classic example of microalloying and inclusion engineering.

Technical Interpretation and Process Points

The mechanism by which rare earth oxides improve the properties of the surfacing layer is well understood in metallurgical terms. Rare earth elements have a strong affinity for oxygen and sulfur, and they form stable oxides and sulfides that serve as nucleation sites for the primary crystals. This refines the grain structure and reduces the tendency for columnar grain growth.

The modification of inclusions is also critical. In a conventional surfacing deposit, the inclusions are often large and angular, and they act as stress concentrators that can initiate cracks. The rare earth oxides modify these inclusions into small, spherical particles that are less harmful.

The improvement in hot plasticity is particularly important for hot shearing blades. These blades operate at elevated temperatures, and they are subjected to repeated impact and thermal cycling. A material with poor hot plasticity will crack and spall, leading to premature failure. The rare earth oxides improve the hot plasticity by refining the grain structure and reducing the segregation of impurities to the grain boundaries.

The authors used a 3Cr2W8V base metal, which is a chromium-tungsten-vanadium hot work tool steel. This steel has good hot hardness and wear resistance, but it is susceptible to cracking during welding due to its high carbon content and low thermal conductivity. The surfacing electrode was designed to deposit a weld metal that is compatible with this base metal while providing superior properties.

Integration with Engineering Practice

In the pipe industry, we do not have hot shearing blades in the same sense as a continuous casting machine, but we have similar components. The most analogous are the cutting tools used in the pipe mill for cutting pipe to length, and the shear blades used in the plate mill for cutting steel plate. These components experience similar conditions: high temperature, abrasive wear, and impact loading.

The ability to repair these components rather than replace them is a significant cost saving. In my experience, the cost of a new shear blade can be substantial, and the downtime required to replace it can be even more costly. A surfacing repair that extends the life by three to eight times is a game-changer.

The use of rare earth oxides is a technique that I have seen in other applications, but this paper provides a clear demonstration of its effectiveness in surfacing. The key is to get the rare earth oxide addition right. Too little and you do not get the full benefit; too much and you risk the formation of harmful inclusions.

The practical challenge is in the application of the electrode. Surfacing a 3Cr2W8V blade requires careful preheat and interpass temperature control. The base metal is highly crack-sensitive, and if you do not maintain the proper temperature, you will get cracking. The authors do not discuss the welding procedure in detail, but I would expect that a preheat of 300-400°C and an interpass temperature of 350-450°C would be required.

Key Questions and Reflections

One question I would raise is the effect of the rare earth oxides on the weld metal's resistance to thermal fatigue. The paper focuses on wear resistance and hot plasticity, but in service, the blade also experiences thermal cycling. The rare earth oxides refine the grain structure, which should improve thermal fatigue resistance, but this is not explicitly tested.

Another practical concern is the reproducibility of the electrode. The rare earth oxides are added to the flux coating, and their distribution must be uniform to ensure consistent performance. If the oxides are not well mixed, some parts of the deposit will have better properties than others.

The paper also raises the question of whether the surfacing repair is cost-effective compared to the original blade. The authors state that the repaired blades have a life of three to eight times the original, but they do not provide a detailed cost analysis. In practice, the cost of the electrode, the labor, and the downtime must be weighed against the cost of a new blade.

Study Insights and Implications

The key insight from this paper is that rare earth oxides are a powerful tool for improving the properties of surfacing deposits. They refine the grain structure, modify inclusions, and improve hot plasticity. This is a technique that should be more widely adopted in the industry.

For the pipe industry, this has direct application to the repair of cutting tools and shear blades. The ability to extend the life of these components by several times is a significant economic benefit. It also reduces the need for spare parts inventory and reduces downtime.

The paper also highlights the importance of understanding the interaction between the surfacing deposit and the base metal. A surfacing electrode that works well on one base metal may not work on another. The properties of the base metal, particularly its carbon content and hardenability, have a significant effect on the performance of the surfacing deposit.

Reference Value and Outlook

This paper is a valuable reference for anyone involved in the repair of hot work tooling. The use of rare earth oxides is a proven technique, and this paper provides a clear demonstration of its effectiveness. The methodology is sound, and the results are compelling.

In the future, I expect to see more widespread use of rare earth oxides in surfacing applications. As the cost of raw materials continues to rise, the ability to extend the life of components through repair becomes increasingly important. The development of electrodes with rare earth oxides is a step in the right direction.

The paper also highlights the importance of continuous improvement. The original 3Cr2W8V blades were considered state-of-the-art, but the surfacing repair has made them obsolete. This is a reminder that we should always be looking for ways to improve the performance of our components, even when they are already performing adequately.