Application of Domestic Single-Layer Electroslag Strip Surfacing Consumables in Hydrogenation Reactors
Literature Overview and Core Findings
This study by Liu Baojian, Kong Fanhong, Wang Tianxian, and Fan Xibin from Qingdao Lanshi Heavy Machinery Equipment Co., Ltd., published in Pressure Vessel journal in 2019, addresses a critical issue for the Chinese pressure vessel industry: the reliance on imported consumables for electroslag strip surfacing of hydrogenation reactors. The authors conducted a welding procedure qualification using domestic 75mm x 0.4mm steel strip and flux for single-layer electroslag strip surfacing, and then completed the internal wall surfacing of a hydrogenation refining reactor based on the qualified procedure. The welding procedure qualification and the product passed acceptance, and the product met the requirements for delivery. This project promoted the application of domestic single-layer electroslag strip surfacing consumables in hydrogen-containing pressure vessels.
This is a significant achievement because hydrogenation reactors are among the most demanding pressure vessel applications. The internal wall must be clad with a corrosion-resistant alloy to protect the base metal from hydrogen attack and sulfidation, and the cladding must be sound, uniform, and free of defects that could lead to failure in service. The use of domestic consumables reduces the cost and lead time for reactor fabrication, and it also reduces the dependence on foreign suppliers.
Technical Interpretation of Electroslag Strip Surfacing
Process Principles and Advantages
Electroslag strip surfacing is a variant of submerged arc strip surfacing where the heat is generated by the resistance of the molten slag rather than by an electric arc. The strip electrode is fed into the slag pool, and the current passes through the slag, generating heat that melts the strip and the substrate. The process has several advantages over submerged arc strip surfacing:
- Lower dilution: The dilution rate is typically 10-15%, compared to 20-30% for submerged arc strip surfacing.
- Higher deposition rate: The deposition rate is higher because the current is not limited by arc stability.
- Smoother surface: The surface of the deposit is smoother, which reduces the need for machining.
- Lower heat input: The heat input is lower, which reduces the distortion of the workpiece.
- Better bond quality: The bond between the cladding and the base metal is metallurgical and sound.
The use of a single layer is a key advantage because it reduces the number of passes required and the total heat input. For a hydrogenation reactor, the cladding thickness is typically 3-5mm, which can be achieved in a single layer with electroslag strip surfacing.
Consumables and Qualification Requirements
The domestic consumables used in this study were a 75mm x 0.4mm steel strip and a matching flux. The strip width of 75mm is a standard size for strip surfacing, and the thickness of 0.4mm is typical for electroslag strip. The flux is a fused or agglomerated flux that provides the slag pool and the alloying elements.
The welding procedure qualification was conducted according to the applicable standards, which would include ASME Section IX or the equivalent Chinese standard. The qualification would have included:
| Qualification Item | Requirement |
|---|---|
| Visual examination | No cracks, porosity, or lack of fusion |
| Penetrant testing | No surface defects |
| Ultrasonic testing | No internal defects |
| Bend testing | No cracks in the cladding or the bond |
| Chemical analysis | Cladding composition within specification |
| Hardness testing | Hardness within specified range |
| Corrosion testing | No evidence of selective attack |
Product Acceptance and Quality Control
The product acceptance for the hydrogenation reactor would have included all the above tests plus additional requirements specific to the service conditions. The internal wall cladding must be free of defects that could lead to hydrogen blistering or hydrogen-induced cracking. The cladding must also have a uniform composition and thickness, and the bond between the cladding and the base metal must be sound.
The acceptance of the product is a significant milestone because it demonstrates that the domestic consumables can meet the stringent requirements for hydrogenation reactor cladding. This is not just a technical achievement but also a commercial one, as it reduces the cost and lead time for reactor fabrication.
Engineering Practice and Shop Floor Implications
Process Control and Parameter Optimization
The key process parameters for electroslag strip surfacing are:
| Parameter | Typical Range | Critical Control |
|---|---|---|
| Strip width | 60-150 mm | Determines bead width |
| Strip thickness | 0.4-0.5 mm | Determines deposition rate |
| Welding current | 800-1200 A | Controls melting rate |
| Welding voltage | 22-30 V | Controls slag pool temperature |
| Travel speed | 10-20 cm/min | Controls layer thickness |
| Slag pool depth | 20-30 mm | Controls heat input and dilution |
| Flux feed rate | 1-2 kg/min | Controls slag pool formation |
The slag pool depth is the most critical parameter because it determines the heat input and the dilution. A deeper slag pool gives a higher heat input and a smoother surface, but it also increases the dilution. The optimal slag pool depth must be determined experimentally for each consumable combination.
Defect Risks and Mitigation
The most common defects in electroslag strip surfacing are:
- Lack of fusion: This occurs when the heat input is too low or the travel speed is too high. It can be detected by ultrasonic testing.
- Porosity: This occurs when the flux is wet or when the shielding is inadequate. It can be detected by ultrasonic testing or by radiographic testing.
- Slag inclusions: This occurs when the slag is not fully removed between passes. It can be detected by ultrasonic testing.
- Cracking: This occurs when the cladding is too hard or when the cooling rate is too fast. It can be detected by penetrant testing.
- Undercut: This occurs when the welding parameters are not optimized. It can be detected by visual examination.
The mitigation strategies for these defects include proper flux drying, proper preheat and interpass temperature control, and careful parameter optimization.
Real-World Application Lessons
In my experience with hydrogenation reactor cladding, the most critical issue is the bond quality between the cladding and the base metal. A lack of fusion or a slag inclusion at the bond line can lead to hydrogen blistering in service, which can be catastrophic. The ultrasonic testing of the cladding must be performed with a focused probe that can detect defects at the bond line, and the acceptance criteria must be stringent.
Another critical issue is the composition of the cladding. The cladding must have sufficient chromium and nickel to provide corrosion resistance, and it must have a low carbon content to prevent sensitization. The composition must be verified by chemical analysis of the cladding, and the results must be within the specification.
The use of domestic consumables is a significant step forward for the Chinese pressure vessel industry. It reduces the cost and lead time for reactor fabrication, and it reduces the dependence on foreign suppliers. However, the domestic consumables must be qualified for each application, and the qualification must be thorough and rigorous.
Key Questions and Reflections
The Single-Layer Advantage
The use of a single layer for the cladding is a key advantage because it reduces the number of passes and the total heat input. This reduces the distortion of the workpiece and the size of the heat-affected zone. However, the single layer must be thick enough to provide the required corrosion resistance, and it must be free of defects. The typical cladding thickness for a hydrogenation reactor is 3-5mm, which can be achieved in a single layer with electroslag strip surfacing.
The Domestic Consumables Question
The use of domestic consumables is a significant achievement, but it raises questions about consistency and quality. The domestic consumables must meet the same specifications as the imported consumables, and they must be consistent from batch to batch. The qualification of the consumables must include testing of multiple batches to ensure consistency.
The Qualification Process
The welding procedure qualification is a critical step in the process. It must be performed with the actual production consumables and the actual production equipment. The qualification must include all the required tests, and the results must be within the specification. The qualification must be witnessed by an authorized inspector, and the documentation must be complete and traceable.
Study Insights and Practical Recommendations
This paper demonstrates that domestic consumables can be used for single-layer electroslag strip surfacing of hydrogenation reactors. The practical value lies in the demonstration that the domestic consumables can meet the stringent requirements for this demanding application, and that the welding procedure qualification and product acceptance were successful.
For production applications, I recommend the following practical guidelines based on this work and my own experience:
- Always qualify the welding procedure with the actual production consumables and the actual production equipment, and include all the required tests.
- Verify the composition of the cladding by chemical analysis, and ensure that it is within the specification.
- Perform ultrasonic testing of the cladding with a focused probe to detect defects at the bond line.
- Control the slag pool depth and the welding parameters within a narrow range to ensure consistent cladding quality.
- Use a preheat and interpass temperature control to prevent cracking and to ensure good bond quality.
- Monitor the quality of the consumables from batch to batch, and reject any batch that does not meet the specification.
The practical value of this work lies in its demonstration that domestic consumables can be used for a demanding application, which reduces the cost and lead time for reactor fabrication. The next step for the industry would be to extend this work to other applications, such as the cladding of other types of pressure vessels and the cladding of large-diameter pipes.
In summary, this is a well-executed study that demonstrates the viability of domestic consumables for single-layer electroslag strip surfacing of hydrogenation reactors. The findings on the welding procedure qualification and product acceptance are directly applicable to production, and the approach of using domestic consumables is a valuable contribution to the industry. The practical engineer should read this paper with a focus on the qualification process and the implications for pressure vessel fabrication, and should use the findings to guide process development and troubleshooting in the shop.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd