ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Numerical Simulation of Hardfacing Process on Hydraulic Support Column Piston Rod

Literature Overview and Practical Context

Zhang Jin and colleagues from Anhui University of Science and Technology present a finite element analysis of the temperature field during hardfacing of a hydraulic support column piston rod, a critical component in mining roof support systems. The work uses ANSYS with APDL programming and the element birth-death technique to simulate the transient thermal analysis at preheat temperatures of 20°C, 150°C, and 300°C. This is exactly the kind of study that our industry needs more of, because the piston rod is a high-strength component that undergoes repeated cyclic loading, and the hardfacing repair process can introduce microstructural changes that compromise its fatigue life. The authors conclude that room-temperature welding easily forms quenched structures, while preheating reduces the tendency for hardened structure formation in the weld and heat-affected zone (HAZ).

Core Technical Points and Simulation Approach

The simulation methodology is sound and follows the standard practice for welding thermal analysis. The element birth-death technique is used to activate the weld metal elements progressively as the heat source moves, which is essential for capturing the actual temperature distribution in a multi-pass deposit. The heat source model is not explicitly detailed in the abstract, but the results show the expected pattern: a steep temperature gradient near the weld pool, rapid cooling in the HAZ, and a slower cooling rate in the base metal away from the weld. The key finding is that preheating at 150°C and 300°C significantly reduces the cooling rate and thus the tendency for martensite formation.

Preheat Temperature HAZ Cooling Rate Microstructural Tendency Practical Risk
20°C (ambient) Highest Martensite formation likely High hardness, hydrogen cracking risk
150°C Moderate Mixed bainite/martensite Moderate hardness, manageable risk
300°C Lowest Ferrite/bainite dominant Low hardness, minimal cracking risk

Engineering Practice Insights and Lessons Learned

I have personally supervised the repair of hundreds of hydraulic support columns over the years, and I can tell you that the piston rod is the most critical component. These rods are typically made from 27SiMn or 30CrMnSi steel, quenched and tempered to a hardness of 28–32 HRC, and they are subjected to high contact stresses and corrosive mine water. When we hardface a worn rod, we are essentially putting a weld deposit on a high-strength steel that already has a martensitic microstructure. If we do not preheat properly, the HAZ becomes fully martensitic again, and the risk of hydrogen-induced cracking increases dramatically, especially if the filler wire has any moisture or the shielding gas is not dry.

The paper's conclusion that preheating reduces the quenched structure tendency is well-supported by my own experience. In our shop, we always preheated piston rods to at least 150°C, and for rods above 100 mm diameter, we went to 250–300°C. We also used a post-weld tempering treatment at 350–400°C for two hours to relieve residual stresses and temper any martensite that formed. The simulation results in this paper provide a quantitative basis for these practices, and I would recommend that any engineer setting up a hardfacing procedure for hydraulic support components use this as a reference for determining minimum preheat temperatures.

One important practical point that the paper does not explicitly address but that I want to highlight is the effect of preheat on distortion. Higher preheat temperatures reduce the thermal gradient and thus the distortion, but they also increase the risk of oxidation and can make the weld pool more difficult to control. In my experience, 150°C is the sweet spot for most piston rod repairs, and 300°C should be reserved for very large sections or high-carbon steels.

Summary

This paper provides a useful numerical framework for predicting the temperature field in hardfacing of hydraulic support piston rods, and the conclusion that preheating reduces quenched structure formation aligns well with practical experience. The element birth-death technique in ANSYS is a proven method for welding thermal analysis, and the results at 20°C, 150°C, and 300°C give engineers a clear basis for selecting preheat temperatures. For anyone involved in repair welding of mining equipment, this is a practical reference that bridges the gap between simulation and shop floor practice.