Plasma Arc Surfacing for Wear Strengthening of Roadheader Conical Picks
Literature Overview and Practical Context
Zhang Ning and colleagues from Xuzhou University of Technology and China University of Mining and Technology present an experimental study on plasma arc surfacing of roadheader conical picks using Fe30 powder. The paper addresses a critical problem in the mining industry: the premature failure of conical picks, which are the most consumable and easily damaged components on roadheaders. The authors note that the pick body accounts for half of the total failure, and that the failure modes include abrasive wear of the pick body, blunting of the pick tip due to insufficient hardness, and premature loss of the carbide tip. The solution proposed is to apply a plasma arc surfacing layer on the pick body after induction brazing of the carbide tip, with the goal of improving the wear resistance of the pick body and extending the service life.
Core Technical Points and Process Analysis
The plasma arc surfacing process uses Fe30 powder, which is a high-chromium iron-based alloy powder typically containing 30% chromium and significant amounts of carbon and other alloying elements. The plasma arc provides a high-energy density heat source that melts the powder and the substrate surface, creating a metallurgical bond with minimal dilution. The paper analyzes the microstructure, surface morphology, and mechanical properties of the surfacing layer, and the key finding is that the surfacing treatment improves the wear resistance of the pick body and prevents premature loss of the carbide tip. The process is applied to the brazed joint between the carbide tip and the pick body, which is a critical area where failure often occurs due to insufficient bond strength and wear of the surrounding steel.
| Failure Mode | Root Cause | Plasma Surfacing Solution |
|---|---|---|
| Pick body abrasive wear | Insufficient surface hardness | Hardfacing layer with high wear resistance |
| Tip blunting | Low hardness at the tip | Improved hardness and wear resistance |
| Carbide tip loss | Weak brazed joint, wear of surrounding steel | Strengthened joint area, reduced wear |
| Overall pick failure | Combination of above | Extended service life |
Engineering Practice Insights and Lessons Learned
This paper addresses a problem that I have seen in every mining operation I have ever visited: the premature failure of cutting picks. The cost of pick replacement is not just the cost of the picks themselves, but also the downtime of the roadheader and the labor cost of replacement. In underground coal mines, a roadheader can consume hundreds of picks per month, and any improvement in pick life has a direct and significant impact on production efficiency.
The use of plasma arc surfacing is a smart choice for this application because it provides a high-quality, low-dilution deposit that can be applied precisely to the areas that need protection. The Fe30 powder is a well-established hardfacing alloy that produces a deposit with high hardness and good wear resistance, and the plasma arc process allows for precise control of the deposit thickness and shape. The key insight from the paper is that the surfacing treatment should be applied to the brazed joint area, not just the tip, because the failure often occurs at the interface between the carbide tip and the pick body.
From my own experience, I can tell you that the most common mistake in pick repair is to apply a hardfacing layer that is too hard and too thick. This creates a brittle layer that cracks and spalls under impact loading, and the spalled fragments accelerate wear on the pick body. The Fe30 alloy, with its high chromium content and moderate hardness, provides a good balance of wear resistance and toughness. I would also recommend that the surfacing layer be applied in a pattern that follows the contour of the pick, with a thickness of 1–2 mm, to avoid creating stress concentrations.
One practical issue that the paper does not address but that I want to mention is the effect of the plasma arc on the carbide tip. The plasma arc has a very high energy density, and if it is applied too close to the carbide tip, it can cause thermal damage and reduce the bond strength of the brazed joint. In practice, the surfacing should be applied at least 5 mm away from the carbide tip, and the heat input should be controlled to minimize the thermal effect on the brazed joint.
Summary
This paper presents a practical solution to the problem of premature pick failure on roadheaders by using plasma arc surfacing with Fe30 powder. The process improves the wear resistance of the pick body and prevents premature loss of the carbide tip, which are the two main failure modes. For engineers involved in mining equipment maintenance, this is a valuable reference that demonstrates the effectiveness of plasma arc surfacing for extending the service life of cutting tools and reducing the cost of replacement.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd