Multi-Field Coupled Numerical Simulation of Submerged Arc Hardfacing of Rolls
Literature Overview and Core Findings
This paper by Li Chang, Huang Qingchun, Chen Xinxue, Liu Zhaotai and Han Xing, published in China Surface Engineering in 2021, addresses a critical issue in the repair of mill rolls by submerged arc hardfacing: the lack of understanding of the melt pool flow and its effect on the temperature field, stress field and the quality of the hardfaced layer. The authors developed a thermal-elastic-plastic and fluid dynamics (CFD) multi-field coupled model to simulate the temperature field, stress field and flow field during roll hardfacing. They analysed the effects of surface tension, electromagnetic force and buoyancy on the melt pool flow and morphology, and they performed metallurgical characterisation of the hardfaced layer. The key findings are that the melt pool flow is driven by a combination of surface tension, electromagnetic force and buoyancy, and that the flow pattern has a significant effect on the melt pool morphology and the quality of the hardfaced layer. The results have practical significance for predicting the multi-physical field changes during submerged arc hardfacing, understanding the melt pool flow evolution mechanism, and effectively preventing hardfacing cracking.
Interpretation of Technical Points
The Importance of Melt Pool Flow in Hardfacing
The melt pool flow is a critical factor in determining the quality of a hardfaced layer. It affects the heat transfer, the mass transfer, the shape of the melt pool, and the distribution of the alloying elements. In submerged arc welding, the arc is submerged in a flux, which creates a complex environment with a high temperature and a high pressure. The electromagnetic force, which is generated by the interaction of the welding current with the magnetic field, drives the flow in the melt pool. The surface tension, which is a function of the temperature and the composition, drives the flow through the Marangoni effect. The buoyancy, which is a function of the density difference, drives the flow through natural convection.
The paper shows that the melt pool flow is not a simple circulation, but a complex pattern that depends on the relative magnitudes of the surface tension, electromagnetic force and buoyancy. The flow pattern affects the shape of the melt pool, which in turn affects the cooling rate and the microstructure of the hardfaced layer. A turbulent flow can cause the entrainment of flux or gas, leading to defects such as porosity and slag inclusions.
The Multi-Field Coupling
The paper uses a multi-field coupling approach, which is more realistic than the single-field approaches that have been used in previous studies. The coupling between the thermal, mechanical and fluid fields is essential because they are interdependent. The temperature field affects the stress field through thermal expansion, and it affects the flow field through the temperature dependence of the material properties. The flow field affects the temperature field through convection, and it affects the stress field through the pressure and the velocity. The stress field affects the flow field through the deformation of the melt pool.
The multi-field coupling approach is computationally intensive, but it provides a more accurate prediction of the hardfacing process. The paper shows that the multi-field model can predict the temperature field, stress field and flow field with a reasonable accuracy, and that the results are consistent with the metallurgical characterisation.
The Effect of Surface Tension, Electromagnetic Force and Buoyancy
The paper analyses the effects of surface tension, electromagnetic force and buoyancy on the melt pool flow and morphology. The surface tension drives the flow from the centre of the melt pool to the edges, creating a Marangoni flow. The electromagnetic force drives the flow in a direction that depends on the current path and the magnetic field. The buoyancy drives the flow upwards in the centre and downwards at the edges, creating a natural convection flow.
The relative magnitudes of these forces determine the flow pattern. In the submerged arc hardfacing of rolls, the electromagnetic force is typically the dominant force, because the welding current is high and the magnetic field is strong. The surface tension is also important, because the temperature gradient in the melt pool is steep. The buoyancy is less important, but it can become significant if the melt pool is large.
Integration with Engineering Practice
Practical Implications for Roll Hardfacing
The findings of this paper have direct implications for the repair of mill rolls by submerged arc hardfacing. The quality of the hardfaced layer depends on the melt pool flow, which is determined by the welding parameters. The fabricator must therefore control the welding parameters to achieve the desired melt pool flow and hence the desired quality.
In my experience, the most common problem in roll hardfacing is cracking, which is caused by the high residual stresses that develop during the process. The paper shows that the residual stresses are influenced by the temperature field, which is influenced by the melt pool flow. By understanding the melt pool flow, the fabricator can optimise the welding parameters to reduce the residual stresses and prevent cracking.
The Role of Welding Parameters
The welding parameters, such as the welding current, voltage, travel speed, and the flux composition, have a significant effect on the melt pool flow. A higher welding current increases the electromagnetic force, which drives a stronger flow. A higher voltage increases the heat input, which increases the size of the melt pool. A higher travel speed decreases the heat input per unit length, which decreases the size of the melt pool.
The fabricator must therefore control the welding parameters to achieve the desired melt pool flow and hence the desired quality. The paper provides a tool for predicting the effect of the welding parameters on the melt pool flow, which can be used to optimise the welding parameters.
Defect Analysis and Countermeasures
The main defects in roll hardfacing are cracking, porosity and slag inclusions. The following countermeasures are recommended:
- Use a preheat and interpass temperature to reduce the residual stresses.
- Control the heat input to achieve the desired melt pool flow and microstructure.
- Use a flux with a good shielding effect to prevent the entrainment of gas.
- Use a welding procedure that ensures a good fusion between the hardfaced layer and the base metal.
- Use a post-weld heat treatment to reduce the residual stresses.
- Use NDT techniques to detect cracks, porosity and slag inclusions.
Key Questions and Reflections
What Is the Optimal Melt Pool Flow Pattern?
The paper shows that the melt pool flow pattern has a significant effect on the quality of the hardfaced layer. However, it does not provide a definitive answer to the question of what is the optimal flow pattern. This is because the optimal flow pattern depends on the specific application. For example, a flow pattern that promotes the mixing of the alloying elements may be beneficial, but a flow pattern that causes the entrainment of flux or gas may be detrimental.
How Accurate Is the Model?
The paper does not provide a detailed validation of the model. The authors compared the predicted temperature field with the metallurgical characterisation, but they did not provide a quantitative comparison. This is a limitation of the study. The fabricator must therefore validate the model with their own experiments before using it for process optimisation.
What Are the Limitations of the Study?
The study is limited to a specific roll hardfacing process and a specific set of welding parameters. The findings may not be directly applicable to other processes or parameters. In addition, the model does not consider the effect of the flux on the melt pool flow, which is a significant simplification.
Study Insights and Implications
The Importance of Multi-Field Coupling in Welding Simulation
This paper reinforces the importance of multi-field coupling in welding simulation. The temperature field, stress field and flow field are interdependent, and they must be solved together to obtain an accurate prediction. This is a significant advancement over the single-field approaches that have been used in the past.
The Need for Validation
The paper highlights the need for validation of welding simulation models. The model must be validated with experiments before it can be used for process optimisation. This is a critical step that is often overlooked.
The Value of Simulation in Process Optimisation
This paper demonstrates the value of simulation in process optimisation. By using a multi-field coupled model, the fabricator can predict the effect of the welding parameters on the melt pool flow and the quality of the hardfaced layer. This can reduce the number of trials and the cost of process development.
Conclusion
The paper by Li Chang et al. provides a comprehensive understanding of the multi-field coupled behaviour during submerged arc hardfacing of rolls. The key findings are that the melt pool flow is driven by a combination of surface tension, electromagnetic force and buoyancy, and that the flow pattern has a significant effect on the melt pool morphology and the quality of the hardfaced layer. The results have practical significance for predicting the multi-physical field changes during submerged arc hardfacing, understanding the melt pool flow evolution mechanism, and effectively preventing hardfacing cracking. The paper also highlights the importance of multi-field coupling in welding simulation and the need for validation of simulation models. For the industry veteran, this paper is a reminder that the quality of a hardfaced layer is not simply a function of the welding parameters, but is determined by the complex interaction of the thermal, mechanical and fluid fields, and that a multi-field coupled approach is essential for understanding and optimising the process.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd