TP347 Single-Layer Surfacing Technology and Performance Evaluation for Hydrogen Service
The Challenge of Cladding Pressure Vessels for Hydrogen Service
In the refining and petrochemical industry, hydroprocessing reactors and other pressure vessels operating in high-temperature, high-pressure hydrogen environments require corrosion-resistant cladding on the internal surfaces. The standard approach has been to use austenitic stainless steel cladding, with TP347 being a common choice due to its resistance to high-temperature hydrogen attack and its stability at elevated temperatures. However, the traditional two-layer cladding process is time-consuming and expensive. This paper by Li Xiaowei and colleagues investigates the feasibility of a single-layer cladding approach using an electroslag welding process, which has inherently lower dilution than other processes.
The authors used 15CrMoR steel as the base material and two different TP347 welding strips as the cladding material. They prepared single-layer cladding samples using the electroslag process and then evaluated the mechanical properties, hardness, chemical composition, ferrite content, intergranular corrosion resistance, and resistance to hydrogen disbonding. The results show that the single-layer cladding can meet the standard requirements for most properties, but the resistance to hydrogen disbonding is highly dependent on the cooling rate and the specific welding strip used.
Key Findings and Their Implications
The following table summarizes the key results from the study.
| Item | Result / Finding |
|---|---|
| Base material | 15CrMoR steel |
| Cladding material | Two types of TP347 welding strip (A and H) |
| Cladding process | Electroslag welding (low dilution) |
| Mechanical properties | Meet standard requirements |
| Hardness | Within acceptable range |
| Chemical composition | Meets standard requirements |
| Ferrite content | Within acceptable range |
| Intergranular corrosion resistance | Good for both strips |
| Hydrogen disbonding (slow cooling) | No disbonding for either strip |
| Hydrogen disbonding (fast cooling) | Disbonding occurred for both strips |
| Electrolytic hydrogen charging | Strip A disbonded; Strip H did not disbond |
The most significant finding is the difference in hydrogen disbonding resistance between the two welding strips. Under electrolytic hydrogen charging, which is a more severe test than the high-temperature high-pressure test, the sample made with strip A experienced disbonding, while the sample made with strip H did not. This indicates that the chemical composition or microstructure of the strip, or perhaps the welding parameters used, has a significant effect on the resistance to hydrogen-induced disbonding.
Understanding Hydrogen Disbonding in Clad Vessels
Hydrogen disbonding is a critical failure mode in clad pressure vessels operating in hydrogen service. When hydrogen diffuses into the steel at high temperature and high pressure, it accumulates at the interface between the cladding and the base metal. During cooling or depressurization, the hydrogen can cause the cladding to separate from the base metal, a phenomenon known as disbonding. This is particularly dangerous because it can lead to the loss of corrosion protection and, ultimately, to vessel failure.
The authors found that the cooling rate after the hydrogen exposure test has a significant effect on disbonding. At a lower cooling rate, neither sample disbonded, but at a higher cooling rate, both samples disbonded. This is consistent with the mechanism of hydrogen disbonding: faster cooling traps more hydrogen in the interface region, increasing the pressure and the likelihood of disbonding.
The difference between the two strips under electrolytic hydrogen charging is more intriguing. The fact that strip H did not disbond while strip A did suggests that the chemical composition of the deposit plays a role. In particular, the presence of certain alloying elements, such as molybdenum or niobium, can affect the hydrogen solubility and diffusivity in the deposit. This is an area that warrants further investigation.
Practical Considerations for Single-Layer Cladding
The use of a single-layer cladding process offers significant economic benefits, including reduced welding time, lower filler metal consumption, and reduced distortion. However, the critical concern is whether the single-layer deposit can provide the same level of corrosion protection and hydrogen disbonding resistance as a two-layer deposit. This paper provides valuable data to support the feasibility of the single-layer approach, but it also highlights the need for careful process qualification.
From a practical standpoint, the following factors should be considered:
- Dilution control: The electroslag process has lower dilution than other processes, which is beneficial for single-layer cladding. However, the dilution must be carefully controlled to ensure that the deposit chemistry meets the specification.
- Welding strip selection: The choice of welding strip has a significant effect on the properties of the deposit, particularly the hydrogen disbonding resistance. This paper demonstrates that two strips with the same nominal composition can perform differently, which underscores the importance of qualifying the specific strip material.
- Post-weld heat treatment: The cooling rate after welding and after any hydrogen exposure is critical. In practice, the cooling rate is often controlled by the post-weld heat treatment schedule, and this must be optimized to minimize the risk of disbonding.
- Non-destructive testing: After cladding, the deposit should be inspected using ultrasonic testing or other suitable methods to detect any lack of fusion or disbonding at the interface.
Lessons from the Field
I have been involved in the fabrication of hydroprocessing reactors and have seen the consequences of inadequate cladding quality. In one case, a reactor was found to have disbonding at the cladding interface during a routine inspection, and the vessel had to be taken out of service for repair. The cost of the repair, including the lost production, was substantial. This paper reinforces the importance of selecting the right welding strip and controlling the process parameters to ensure adequate hydrogen disbonding resistance.
The finding that the cooling rate is critical is particularly important. In practice, the cooling rate after the post-weld heat treatment must be carefully controlled to avoid trapping hydrogen at the interface. This is often overlooked in favor of meeting the mechanical property requirements, but it can have a significant impact on the long-term integrity of the vessel.
Summary and Outlook
This study demonstrates that single-layer TP347 cladding on 15CrMoR steel, produced by the electroslag welding process, can meet the standard requirements for mechanical properties, hardness, chemical composition, ferrite content, and intergranular corrosion resistance. However, the resistance to hydrogen disbonding is highly dependent on the specific welding strip and the cooling rate. The choice of welding strip is critical, and the process must be qualified to ensure that the deposit has adequate resistance to hydrogen-induced disbonding. For the fabrication of pressure vessels for hydrogen service, single-layer cladding offers significant economic benefits, but it requires a higher level of process control and quality assurance than conventional two-layer cladding. The key is to select the right materials, control the cooling rate, and conduct thorough non-destructive testing to ensure the integrity of the cladding interface.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd