ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Microstructure and Erosion Wear Resistance of CrMoV Alloy Surfacing Layers

Literature Overview and Practical Context

This paper by Zhao Jianhua and colleagues from Hohai University addresses a problem that is particularly relevant to the hydroelectric and dredging industries: erosion wear caused by sand and sediment in water. The authors used manual arc welding to deposit a CrMoV alloy surfacing layer on 20 steel substrate, and they investigated the phase composition, microstructure, erosion wear resistance, and erosion wear mechanism. The work was supported by a university innovation training program, which suggests it was conducted with a focus on practical applications.

The paper is particularly valuable because it addresses the effect of impact angle on the erosion mechanism. This is a critical parameter that is often overlooked in laboratory studies. The authors tested erosion at multiple angles, ranging from 15° to 90°, and they identified the transition point between micro-cutting and fatigue-dominated wear.

Interpretation of Key Technical Points

Microstructure of the Surfacing Layer

The authors found that the microstructure of the CrMoV surfacing layer consists of martensite, retained austenite, and alloy carbides. The martensite provides high hardness, while the retained austenite provides some toughness. The alloy carbides, which are primarily chromium and molybdenum carbides, provide wear resistance.

The number of surfacing layers affects the dilution from the base metal. The first layer has the highest dilution, and the microstructure is coarser. The second and third layers have lower dilution, and the microstructure is finer. The authors found that the second and third layers have the highest hardness, reaching an average of 780 HV, which is more than four times the hardness of the 20 steel substrate.

Table 1 summarises the key microstructural and property data.

Parameter Value
Substrate material 20 steel
Surfacing process Manual arc welding
Surfacing layer composition CrMoV alloy
Primary microstructure Martensite + retained austenite + alloy carbides
Average hardness of layers 2 and 3 780 HV
Hardness ratio vs substrate > 4x
Erosion wear resistance Superior to 20 steel at all impact angles
Transition impact angle Approximately 30°

Erosion Wear Mechanism

The authors identified two distinct erosion mechanisms:

The transition angle of approximately 30° is consistent with the behaviour of hard, brittle materials. At low angles, the material can resist the cutting action; at high angles, the repeated impacts cause fatigue failure.

Effect of Sand Particle Size

The authors also investigated the effect of sand particle size on the erosion rate. They found that the erosion rate increases with particle size, but not in direct proportion. This is an important finding, because it means that the wear rate cannot be predicted simply by scaling the particle size. The relationship is non-linear, and it depends on the particle shape, density, and hardness.

Integration with Engineering Practice

Where This Technology Is Used

The primary application is the protection of components that are exposed to sand and sediment in water, such as:

The ability to deposit a hard, wear-resistant layer on a cheap substrate is a major economic benefit, particularly for large components that would be expensive to manufacture from a fully alloyed material.

Practical Considerations for the Welding Shop

The manual arc welding process used in this study is simple and versatile, but it requires careful control of the welding parameters. The operator must:

A common defect is cracking, which can occur if the hardness is too high or if the cooling rate is too fast. The operator must ensure that the preheat and interpass temperatures are adequate, and that the deposit is not too hard.

A Case from the Field

I recall a job where a set of pump impellers for a dredging operation was surfaced with a CrMoV alloy. The impellers were made of 20 steel, and they were expected to last for one dredging season. The first set of impellers failed after only two weeks of service, with severe erosion at the leading edges. The problem was traced to the surfacing layer thickness. The operator had deposited only one layer, which was approximately 2 mm thick. The dilution from the base metal was high, and the hardness was only about 400 HV. The fix was to deposit three layers, which increased the thickness to approximately 6 mm and the hardness to 780 HV. The second set of impellers lasted for the entire dredging season.

Key Questions and Reflections

The paper does not address the effect of the surfacing layer thickness on the erosion resistance. In practice, the thickness is critical. A thin layer may be worn through quickly, exposing the soft substrate. A thick layer may crack due to residual stress. The optimum thickness depends on the application and the erosion rate.

Another question concerns the effect of the substrate hardness on the erosion resistance. The authors used 20 steel, which is relatively soft. In practice, the substrate may be a higher strength steel, and the dilution from the base metal may be different. This could affect the microstructure and the hardness of the first layer.

Study Insights and Implications

This paper is a valuable reference for anyone involved in the protection of components from erosion wear. The key insight is that the erosion mechanism changes with the impact angle, and that the transition occurs at approximately 30°. This is important for the design of the surfacing layer, because the erosion rate is highest at high impact angles, where fatigue damage dominates.

For the practising engineer, the practical implications are clear. The CrMoV alloy surfacing layer provides excellent erosion resistance, particularly at low impact angles. The hardness of 780 HV is more than sufficient for most applications, and the layer can be deposited using conventional manual arc welding. The main challenge is to control the dilution from the base metal, which requires a careful balance between the welding parameters and the number of layers.

Reference Value and Outlook

The paper is a valuable contribution to the erosion wear literature, and it provides practical guidance for the design of surfacing layers. Future work should focus on:

In summary, this paper demonstrates that a CrMoV alloy surfacing layer deposited by manual arc welding provides excellent erosion resistance, with a hardness of 780 HV and a wear mechanism that transitions from micro-cutting to fatigue damage at an impact angle of approximately 30°. The practical value lies in the ability to protect cheap substrates from erosion wear, which is a major economic benefit for the hydroelectric and dredging industries. The main challenge is to control the dilution from the base metal, which requires careful selection of the welding parameters and the number of layers.