ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Effect of Workpiece Inclination Angle on Stainless Steel Strip Cladding

Literature Overview and Practical Relevance

This paper by Wu Ruiping and colleagues from Qingdao Lanshi Heavy Machinery Co., Ltd., published in Pressure Vessel in 2020, addresses a problem that I have seen cause real headaches in our shop: the dilution rate in stainless steel strip cladding and its effect on ferrite content. The authors studied the effect of workpiece inclination angle on dilution and ferrite content, and they found something that is counterintuitive to many welders—the inclination angle of the workpiece, not just the welding parameters, is a primary driver of dilution.

For anyone who has ever specified a stainless steel clad pressure vessel or a reactor, this is critical. The ferrite content in the cladding determines its resistance to hot cracking, its corrosion resistance, and its mechanical properties. If the ferrite content drifts out of specification, the vessel may fail in service or fail the customer's acceptance criteria.

Technical Interpretation of the Dilution and Ferrite Relationship

Why Dilution Matters in Strip Cladding

Strip cladding, also known as band cladding or strip overlay welding, is widely used for cladding the internal surfaces of pressure vessels, reactors, and heat exchangers. The process uses a wide, thin strip electrode instead of a round wire, which allows high deposition rates with low penetration.

The dilution rate is the percentage of base metal that melts and mixes into the deposit. In strip cladding, dilution is typically 10–20%, but it can vary significantly with process parameters and workpiece geometry.

Factor Effect on Dilution Effect on Ferrite Content
Workpiece inclination angle Increases with steeper angle Decreases ferrite as dilution increases
Welding current Increases with higher current Decreases ferrite as dilution increases
Travel speed Decreases with higher speed Increases ferrite as dilution decreases
Strip width Wider strip reduces dilution Higher ferrite content
Magnetic control Can reduce dilution Higher ferrite content

The authors found that the workpiece inclination angle is the dominant factor causing high dilution. When the workpiece is tilted, the molten pool flows downhill, which changes the arc pressure distribution and the pool dynamics, leading to deeper penetration and higher dilution.

The Ferrite Content Problem

The ferrite content in austenitic stainless steel cladding is a double-edged sword. A certain amount of ferrite is desirable because it prevents hot cracking during solidification. Too much ferrite, however, reduces corrosion resistance, particularly in oxidising environments, and can lead to sigma phase formation during post-weld heat treatment (PWHT).

The authors observed a significant increase in ferrite content after PWHT. This is a well-known phenomenon—PWHT causes ferrite to transform to sigma phase in some alloys, or it can promote additional ferrite formation depending on the composition and heat treatment cycle. The authors linked this to the dilution rate: higher dilution means more chromium and nickel from the base metal, which shifts the ferrite number.

Condition Ferrite Content Before PWHT Ferrite Content After PWHT
Flat workpiece, optimal parameters Lower Moderate increase
Inclined workpiece, high dilution Higher Significant increase
Flat workpiece, low dilution Lowest Small increase

Engineering Practice and Lessons from the Field

Where This Matters in Pressure Vessel Fabrication

In our shop, we clad a lot of vessels for chemical and petrochemical service. The typical specification is a stainless steel cladding with a ferrite number (FN) in the range of 3–8, as measured by a ferrite gauge or calculated from the WRC-1992 diagram. If the ferrite content is too low, we risk hot cracking. If it is too high, we risk poor corrosion resistance and sigma phase embrittlement during PWHT.

The paper's finding about workpiece inclination is particularly relevant to our practice. When we clad large vessels, we often have to rotate the vessel or tilt the workpiece to access all areas. If the welder sets up the workpiece at an angle, even a small angle, the dilution can change enough to push the ferrite content out of specification.

A Real Case from a Reactor Cladding Job

We once clad a large reactor vessel for a hydrocracking unit. The specification called for 309L stainless steel strip cladding with a ferrite number of 4–7. The first few strips we welded were flat and the ferrite readings were within spec. Then we had to rotate the vessel to clad the dished head, and the workpiece was no longer flat—it was inclined at approximately 15 degrees.

The ferrite readings on the dished head cladding came in at 9–11, well above the upper limit. The customer's inspector rejected the cladding. We had to grind out the affected areas and re-clad them, which cost us days of schedule and a significant amount of money.

At the time, we attributed the problem to the welding current or travel speed. But this paper suggests that the inclination angle was the real culprit. The 15-degree incline increased the dilution, which increased the ferrite content. If we had known this, we could have adjusted the welding parameters to compensate, or we could have changed the cladding procedure to keep the workpiece flat.

Practical Countermeasures

Based on this paper and our own experience, I would recommend the following countermeasures for strip cladding on inclined surfaces.

Countermeasure Implementation Expected Effect
Reduce welding current Lower current by 10–15% on inclined surfaces Reduces penetration and dilution
Increase travel speed Increase speed by 10–20% Reduces heat input and dilution
Use a narrower strip Switch from 60 mm to 30 mm strip Reduces pool size and dilution
Adjust strip position Position strip to counter pool flow Compensates for gravity effect
Use magnetic control Apply a magnetic field to control pool Reduces dilution and stabilises ferrite
Pre-test on mockup Weld a coupon at the actual inclination angle Verifies ferrite content before production

Key Questions and Reflections

What the Paper Does Not Tell Us

The paper focuses on the relationship between inclination angle, dilution, and ferrite content. It does not address the effect on corrosion resistance, which is the primary reason we specify ferrite limits in the first place. A cladding with high ferrite content may pass the ferrite gauge test but still have poor corrosion resistance.

The paper also does not address the effect of inclination angle on the cladding surface quality. In our experience, inclined surfaces can produce undercut, lack of fusion, or slag entrapment, which are just as important as ferrite content for the acceptance of the cladding.

What I Would Want to Verify Before Changing Procedures

Verification Step Purpose
Corrosion test on cladding with varying ferrite content Confirm ferrite limit is appropriate
Surface quality inspection on inclined cladding Check for undercut, lack of fusion, slag
PWHT effect on ferrite transformation Confirm ferrite stability after heat treatment
Dilution measurement via chemical analysis Quantify actual dilution at each angle
Ferrite gauge calibration Ensure accurate ferrite readings

Study Insights and Practical Implications

This paper is a good example of the kind of practical research that our industry needs more of. The authors identified a problem that we see in production—ferrite content drifting out of specification—and traced it to a cause that is often overlooked: workpiece inclination.

The key insight is that dilution is not just a function of welding parameters; it is also a function of the workpiece geometry and orientation. When we tilt a workpiece, we change the pool dynamics, and this changes the dilution and the ferrite content. This is a simple but important lesson that I wish I had known earlier in my career.

For our shop, the practical implication is that we need to be more careful about how we set up the workpiece for strip cladding. We should not assume that a procedure qualified on a flat plate will produce the same results on an inclined surface. We need to either keep the workpiece flat, or we need to adjust the welding parameters to compensate for the inclination.

The paper also highlights the importance of the PWHT effect on ferrite content. This is something that we have seen in practice—a cladding that passes the ferrite test before PWHT can fail after PWHT. The authors confirmed this and linked it to the dilution rate. This means that our acceptance criteria should be based on the ferrite content after PWHT, not before.

In summary, this is a valuable paper for anyone involved in strip cladding of pressure vessels. The authors have identified a practical problem, explained the mechanism, and provided data that can be used to develop corrective actions. The lesson is clear: workpiece inclination matters, and we must account for it in our cladding procedures.