Cobalt-Based Alloy Surfacing: Application, Cracking, and Prevention
Literature Overview and Practical Relevance
This paper by Yu Jianping and colleagues from Lanzhou Petrochemical Machinery Plant, published in Welding Technology in 2000, is a practical guide to the application of cobalt-based alloy surfacing in refinery equipment. The authors focus on cracking—the most common and most serious defect in cobalt-based hardfacing—and they provide a systematic analysis of the causes and prevention measures.
I have been involved in cobalt-based surfacing for valve seats, pump components, and turbine blades for decades. Cobalt-based alloys, particularly the Stellite family, are excellent for high-temperature wear and corrosion resistance, but they are notoriously prone to cracking. The authors' analysis is grounded in real production experience, and their recommendations are practical and directly applicable.
Technical Interpretation of Cracking Mechanisms
Why Cobalt-Based Alloys Crack
Cobalt-based alloys have a face-centred cubic (FCC) crystal structure, which is ductile and tough. However, during surfacing, the rapid solidification and the thermal cycle of the welding process create conditions that promote cracking. The authors identify several mechanisms.
| Cracking Mechanism | Root Cause | Typical Location |
|---|---|---|
| Solidification cracking | Low melting point eutectics at grain boundaries | Centreline of deposit |
| Hydrogen-induced cracking | Hydrogen from moisture or contamination | Heat affected zone (HAZ) |
| Stress-relief cracking | Residual stress relaxation at elevated temperature | HAZ or deposit |
| Reheat cracking | Precipitation of carbides during PWHT | HAZ |
| Dilution cracking | Base metal dilution changes deposit composition | Interface |
The authors emphasise that the most common cause is the combination of high residual stress and the inherent low ductility of the deposit at elevated temperatures. Cobalt-based alloys have a high coefficient of thermal expansion, and the welding process creates significant residual stresses. When these stresses exceed the strength of the deposit or the HAZ, cracking occurs.
The Role of Welding Method
The authors note that different surfacing methods produce different cracking tendencies. This is consistent with my experience.
| Surfacing Method | Heat Input | Dilution | Cracking Tendency |
|---|---|---|---|
| Oxy-acetylene | Low | Low | Low |
| TIG (GTAW) | Low | Low | Low |
| Plasma transferred arc (PTA) | Medium | Low | Medium |
| MIG (GMAW) | Medium | High | Medium |
| Submerged arc (SAW) | High | High | High |
| Electroslag | High | High | High |
The authors point out that oxy-acetylene and TIG surfacing produce the lowest cracking tendency because they have low heat input and low dilution. However, these methods are slow and expensive, so they are not suitable for large components. PTA is a good compromise—it has low dilution and moderate heat input, and it is widely used for cobalt-based surfacing in our industry.
Engineering Practice and Lessons from the Field
Where Cobalt-Based Surfacing Is Used in Refinery Equipment
Cobalt-based alloys are used in a wide range of refinery equipment, including:
- Valve seats and discs for high-temperature, high-pressure service
- Pump impellers and casings for abrasive and corrosive service
- Turbine blades and nozzles for high-temperature service
- Extruder screws and barrels for polymer processing
- Cutting tools and dies for metalworking
In each application, the primary failure mode is wear, corrosion, or a combination of both. Cobalt-based alloys provide the best combination of high-temperature hardness, corrosion resistance, and wear resistance.
A Real Case from a Valve Seat Surfacing Job
We once surfaced a batch of valve seats for a hydrocracking unit. The specification called for Stellite 6, applied by PTA, with a hardness of 38–44 HRC. The first few seats were fine, but then we started getting cracks in the deposit.
We investigated and found that the cracking was caused by two factors:
- The preheat temperature was too low. Cobalt-based alloys require a preheat of 200–300°C to reduce the thermal gradient and prevent cracking. Our welder had skipped the preheat on a few seats because he was in a hurry.
- The base metal had a high carbon content. The valve seats were made of a martensitic stainless steel with a carbon content of 0.2%, which is on the high side. The high carbon content increased the hardness of the HAZ and made it more susceptible to cracking.
We corrected the problem by ensuring proper preheat, using a lower welding current, and applying the deposit in multiple thin layers rather than a single thick layer. The subsequent seats passed inspection.
The Authors' Prevention Measures
The authors recommend several prevention measures, which align with our experience.
| Prevention Measure | Implementation | Expected Effect |
|---|---|---|
| Strict adherence to surfacing procedure | Follow qualified WPS exactly | Prevents process-induced cracking |
| Proper preheat and interpass temperature | Preheat 200–300°C, control interpass | Reduces thermal gradient |
| Control of harmful elements | Limit S, P, C in base metal and filler | Prevents solidification cracking |
| Correct surfacing sequence | Use balanced or backstep sequence | Reduces residual stress |
| Post-weld heat treatment | Stress relief at 700–800°C | Reduces residual stress |
| Use of low-dilution process | PTA or TIG instead of SAW | Reduces dilution and cracking |
| Preheating of filler metal | Dry and preheat filler wire | Prevents hydrogen-induced cracking |
The Importance of Surfacing Sequence
The authors emphasise that the surfacing sequence is critical. In my experience, the most common mistake is to apply the deposit in a single continuous pass over a large area. This creates a high residual stress because the entire deposit cools at the same time, and the contraction is not balanced.
The correct approach is to use a backstep or skip sequence, where the deposit is applied in segments, and each segment is allowed to cool slightly before the next one is applied. This reduces the residual stress and prevents cracking.
Key Questions and Reflections
What the Paper Does Not Tell Us
The paper focuses on cracking prevention, but it does not address the effect of the surfacing process on the mechanical properties of the deposit. Cobalt-based alloys can lose hardness and wear resistance if the process parameters are not optimised.
The paper also does not address the economic aspects of cobalt-based surfacing. Cobalt is an expensive alloying element, and the cost of cobalt-based surfacing is significantly higher than iron-based or nickel-based alternatives. In some applications, a nickel-based alloy may be a more cost-effective choice.
What I Would Want to Verify Before Adopting the Recommendations
| Verification Step | Purpose |
|---|---|
| Hardness test on deposit | Confirm hardness meets specification |
| Microstructural analysis | Check for carbide precipitation and grain growth |
| Corrosion test in service environment | Confirm corrosion resistance |
| Field trial on actual component | Validate performance under service conditions |
| Cost comparison with alternatives | Determine if cobalt-based is justified |
Study Insights and Practical Implications
This paper is a valuable reference for anyone involved in cobalt-based surfacing. The authors have drawn on their production experience to identify the causes of cracking and to propose practical prevention measures.
The key insight is that cracking in cobalt-based surfacing is not inevitable. It is caused by a combination of factors—residual stress, low ductility, dilution, and harmful elements—and each of these can be controlled through proper procedure, preheat, and sequence.
For our shop, the most important lesson is the importance of procedure discipline. Cobalt-based surfacing is unforgiving. If you skip a preheat step, or if you use the wrong welding current, or if you apply the deposit in the wrong sequence, you will get cracks. The paper reinforces what I have learned over decades: there is no substitute for following the qualified procedure.
The paper also highlights the importance of controlling harmful elements in the base metal and filler metal. Sulfur and phosphorus are particularly harmful because they form low-melting-point eutectics that cause solidification cracking. This is why we always check the chemical composition of the base metal before surfacing, and why we use high-purity filler metals.
In summary, this is a practical, experience-based paper that provides clear guidance on how to avoid cracking in cobalt-based surfacing. The authors' recommendations are consistent with my own experience, and I would recommend this paper to any engineer who is involved in cobalt-based surfacing of refinery equipment.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd