Annealing Temperature Effects on Ni60/WC Plasma Surfacing Overlay on H13 Steel: A Die and Tooling Perspective
The Application: H13 Dies and Ni60/WC Composite Overlay
H13 steel is the workhorse of hot work die steel. It is used for die casting dies, forging dies, and extrusion dies, and it is selected for its combination of hot hardness, toughness, and thermal fatigue resistance. However, H13 does not have exceptional wear resistance, and in service the die surface can wear rapidly, especially in applications with abrasive particles or high sliding velocities. The solution is to apply a wear-resistant overlay, and Ni60/WC is a common choice. The Ni60 alloy is a nickel-based hardfacing alloy with high hardness and good corrosion resistance, and the WC particles provide exceptional abrasive wear resistance. The composite overlay combines the toughness of the nickel matrix with the hardness of the WC particles.
The 2019 paper from Wuhan University of Technology, funded by the National Natural Science Foundation, studies the effect of annealing temperature on the microstructure and hardness of a Ni60/WC overlay applied by powder plasma surfacing on H13 steel. The paper is directly relevant to die repair, where the overlay is applied to a worn die surface and then heat treated to relieve stress and improve the bond.
The Process: Powder Plasma Surfacing and the HAZ Problem
Powder plasma surfacing uses a plasma arc to melt a powder feed, which is deposited onto the substrate. The process has a high deposition rate and a relatively low dilution, which is important for a composite overlay because the WC particles must not dissolve into the matrix. The problem is that the plasma arc produces a significant heat input, which creates a large HAZ in the H13 substrate. The HAZ in H13 is a serious concern because H13 is air-hardening. When the HAZ cools rapidly after welding, it transforms to martensite, which is hard and brittle. The martensitic HAZ has poor toughness and is susceptible to cracking, especially when the overlay is thick and the residual stress is high.
The authors studied the effect of annealing temperature on the HAZ and the overlay. The as-welded condition has a HAZ composed of coarse lath martensite and plate martensite with retained austenite. This is the worst possible condition for a die, because the martensite is brittle and the retained austenite can transform to martensite during service, causing dimensional instability. The annealing treatment is intended to temper the martensite and eliminate the retained austenite.
Annealing Temperature Effects: Microstructure and Hardness
| Annealing Temperature | HAZ Microstructure | Overlay Microstructure | Hardness Distribution |
|---|---|---|---|
| As-welded | Coarse lath + plate martensite, retained austenite | Dendritic, WC partially dissolved | Hard HAZ, sharp hardness drop |
| 600 °C | Lath ferrite, acicular ferrite, granular cementite | Dendritic, WC more uniform | Slight hardness decrease, HAZ softened |
| 800 °C | Equiaxed ferrite, granular cementite | Refined dendritic, WC uniformly distributed | Uniform hardness, gradient transition |
The 600 °C annealing reduces the hardness slightly and softens the HAZ, but the microstructure is still not fully recrystallised. The 800 °C annealing is the key result: the HAZ transforms to equiaxed ferrite and granular cementite, which is a soft and tough microstructure, and the overlay has a refined dendritic structure with uniformly distributed WC particles. The hardness distribution becomes uniform, with a gradient transition from the substrate to the overlay, which improves the bond and eliminates the sharp hardness drop that causes cracking.
The practical implication is significant. The as-welded condition has a hardness profile that drops sharply at the HAZ, which creates a stress concentration and a potential crack path. The 800 °C annealing eliminates this sharp drop and creates a gradual transition, which distributes the stress over a wider area and prevents crack initiation. The authors also note that the 800 °C annealing eliminates the crack sensitivity of the overlay, which means the overlay can be machined and put into service without the risk of cracking.
Practical Implications for Die Repair and Tooling
For a die repair shop, this paper is a direct instruction manual. When a die is surfaced with Ni60/WC, the as-welded condition is not suitable for service. The HAZ is martensitic, the hardness profile is discontinuous, and the overlay has a high crack sensitivity. The die must be annealed before it is put back into service, and the annealing temperature should be around 800 °C. I have seen shops skip the annealing step and put a repaired die straight into service, only to have it crack within the first week. The crack usually initiates at the HAZ, where the hardness drop creates a stress concentration, and propagates through the overlay and into the base metal.
The 800 °C annealing also improves the WC distribution. In the as-welded condition, the WC particles are partially dissolved and clustered, which reduces the wear resistance. After 800 °C annealing, the WC particles are more uniformly distributed, which improves the wear resistance and the overall performance of the die. The annealing temperature is critical. Too low a temperature and the HAZ is not fully softened. Too high a temperature and the H13 substrate may over-temper and lose its hot hardness. The 800 °C window is the sweet spot, and the paper provides the microstructural evidence to support it.
Reflections and Study Insights
The paper's contribution is the identification of 800 °C as the optimal annealing temperature for a Ni60/WC overlay on H13 steel. The practical lesson is that the heat treatment is not an optional step — it is an integral part of the repair process. I would specify a post-weld annealing at 800 °C for every Ni60/WC overlay on H13, with a holding time of one to two hours and a controlled cooling rate to avoid re-hardening. I would also verify the hardness profile after annealing to confirm that the HAZ has been softened and the transition is gradual. The cost of the annealing is a few hours of furnace time, and the benefit is a die that lasts the full campaign instead of failing after a week. The paper is a valuable reference for any shop that repairs H13 dies, and I would keep a copy in the heat treatment department as a standard operating procedure. The metallurgy is clear, the process is proven, and the economic benefit is substantial. The only thing left is to make sure the shop floor follows the procedure.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd