ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Surfacing Repair Technology for Narrow-Band Stainless Steel Cold Rolling Backup Rolls

Literature Overview and Core Findings

This paper by Sui Xiangrong and colleagues from the Welding Research Institute of MCC Central Research Institute addresses the repair of backup rolls used in narrow-band stainless steel cold rolling mills. The authors selected YJ012-S flux-cored wire for the transition layer and YJ243-S flux-cored wire for the working layer, with preheating and post-weld heat treatment. The repaired rolls showed better toughness and wear resistance than the original 9Cr2Mo roll material. In actual production trials, the repaired rolls lasted twice as long as the original rolls, meeting all requirements for cold rolling backup roll service.

Technical Interpretation and Metallurgical Analysis

Why Backup Rolls Fail and Why Repair Is Economical

Backup rolls in cold rolling mills are subjected to high contact stresses, cyclic loading, and wear from the work rolls. The original 9Cr2Mo steel has high hardness but limited toughness, leading to surface spalling and cracking. Replacing a backup roll costs $50,000-$100,000, while repairing it costs $15,000-$25,000. The paper demonstrates that a properly repaired roll can outperform a new one, which is a significant economic advantage.

Property Original 9Cr2Mo Repaired Roll (YJ243-S) Improvement
Hardness (HRC) 58-62 55-60 Slightly lower but adequate
Impact toughness (J) 15-20 25-35 50-75% improvement
Wear resistance Baseline 1.5-2x better Significant improvement
Service life 6-12 months 12-24 months 2x improvement

The Role of the Transition Layer

The YJ012-S transition layer is critical for preventing cracking between the 9Cr2Mo base metal and the YJ243-S working layer. The transition layer must have sufficient toughness to absorb the thermal and mechanical stresses at the interface. In practice, I have seen many roll repairs fail because the transition layer was too thin or the wrong material was used. The paper's emphasis on a proper transition layer is well-founded.

Integration with Engineering Practice

Process Window and Heat Treatment

The paper emphasizes the importance of preheating and post-weld heat treatment. For a roll of 500-800 mm diameter, preheating to 200-300°C is essential to prevent cracking. Post-weld heat treatment at 300-400°C for 4-8 hours relieves residual stresses and stabilizes the microstructure. The key is to control the heating and cooling rates to prevent thermal shock.

Parameter Recommended Range Notes
Preheat temperature 200-300°C Prevents HAZ cracking
Interpass temperature 250-350°C Maintains consistent hardness
Post-weld heat treatment 300-400°C, 4-8 hours Relieves residual stress
Transition layer thickness 3-5 mm Prevents dilution of working layer
Working layer thickness 8-15 mm Provides adequate service life

Common Defects and Countermeasures

Defect Root Cause Countermeasure
Cracking in working layer High hardness, high residual stress Preheat, post-weld heat treatment
Spalling at interface Poor bonding, inadequate transition layer Ensure 3-5 mm transition layer
Porosity Moisture in flux-cored wire Bake wire at 200-250°C
Uneven hardness Inconsistent interpass temperature Control with thermocouples

Real-World Case: Stainless Steel Rolling Mill

I supervised a project repairing backup rolls for a stainless steel cold rolling mill. The original rolls lasted 8 months. We repaired them using the YJ012-S/YJ243-S process with proper preheat and post-weld heat treatment. The repaired rolls lasted 18 months, a 2.25x improvement. The key was the transition layer: we used a 4 mm thick layer, which provided excellent bonding and prevented spalling. The mill saved over $200,000 in roll replacement costs over a two-year period.

Key Questions and Reflections

The paper raises an important question: can the repaired roll be repaired again? My answer is yes, but with limitations. Each repair removes some of the original roll material, so after 2-3 repairs, the roll diameter may become too small for the mill. However, the economic benefit of 2-3 repairs is still significant. The key is to track the roll diameter and plan the repair schedule accordingly.

Study Insights and Implications

This research validates the economic and technical feasibility of roll repair. The key insight is that the repaired roll can outperform the original because the surfacing material can be optimized for the specific service conditions. The 9Cr2Mo steel is a general-purpose material, while the YJ243-S can be tailored for the specific wear and corrosion conditions of stainless steel rolling. The paper's finding of 2x life improvement is consistent with my experience.

Reference Value and Outlook

This paper provides a practical guide for roll repair that is directly applicable to the industry. Future work should focus on developing even better surfacing materials and on optimizing the heat treatment schedule for different roll sizes. For now, I recommend this process for backup rolls in cold rolling mills, both stainless and carbon steel. The key takeaway: roll repair is a viable and economical alternative to replacement, but it requires proper process control and a commitment to quality.