ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Electroslag Surfacing of High-Chromium Cast Iron: Temperature Field, Interface Structure and Wear Performance

Literature Overview and Core Findings

This paper from the Welding Journal (Vol. 44, No. 3, 2023) addresses a question I have wrestled with on more than one shop floor: how do you put a hard, wear-resistant high-chromium cast iron layer onto a low-alloy steel substrate without cracking it to pieces? The authors used electroslag surfacing (ESS) on D32 low-alloy steel and measured the temperature field in the heat-affected zone (HAZ) during the process, then characterised the HAZ, the composite interface, and the hardfacing layer in terms of both microstructure and mechanical properties.

The key results are worth quoting directly. The heating and cooling rates in ESS are slow compared with conventional arc surfacing processes, and during the stable stage the temperature distribution in the low-alloy steel substrate was uniform. The maximum temperature gradient along the surfacing direction was measured at -21.25 degrees Celsius per millimetre. That is a gentle gradient by welding standards. The maximum thermal stress in the substrate was calculated at 53.4 MPa, which sits comfortably below the tensile strength of D32, and this is precisely why no cracks were observed. The composite interface was flat and clean, with an austenitic band approximately 50 microns wide. The HAZ grains had coarsened somewhat and consisted of ferrite plus pearlite. The high-chromium cast iron hardfacing layer was composed of austenite, carbides and a small amount of martensite, with M7C3-type carbides finely and uniformly distributed along the austenite grain boundaries. The interface bond strength was 96 MPa. The impact absorbed energy of the fusion zone was 53 J, markedly higher than the 10.7 J measured in the hardfacing layer itself. The hypoeutectic high-chromium cast iron underwent martensitic transformation under heavy wear loads, which increased hardness and gave excellent abrasive wear resistance.

Interpretation of Technical Points

Why Electroslag Surfacing Beats Conventional Arc Surfacing for This Application

I have seen too many hardfacing jobs go wrong because the process was chosen without thinking about the thermal cycle. Conventional arc surfacing processes such as shielded metal arc welding (SMAW) or flux-cored arc welding (FCAW) deposit a small molten pool that cools rapidly. That rapid cooling creates a steep thermal gradient in the substrate, high residual stresses, and a real risk of hydrogen-induced cracking in the HAZ when you are putting a hard, high-carbon layer on a structural steel. Electroslag surfacing is fundamentally different. The heat input is delivered through a molten slag bath rather than directly through an arc, which means the heating and cooling rates are an order of magnitude slower. The substrate has time to equalise its temperature, the thermal gradient stays low, and the residual stress stays below the yield strength of the base metal. The measured maximum gradient of -21.25 degrees Celsius per millimetre is the smoking gun: that is a very forgiving thermal profile.

The Interface Band and What It Means for Bond Integrity

The 50-micron austenitic band at the composite interface is a feature I have seen in good electroslag deposits and rarely in arc-deposited hardfacing. It forms because the cooling rate is slow enough for carbon to diffuse from the high-chromium cast iron into the substrate, stabilising austenite at the interface. This band acts as a compliant layer between the hard, brittle hardfacing and the ductile substrate. The 96 MPa bond strength is not spectacular in absolute terms, but for a hardfacing application it is more than adequate because the dominant loading mode in service is abrasive wear, not tensile pull-off. The real significance is that the interface is flat and clean, with no lack-of-fusion or oxide inclusions. I have seen arc-surfaced interfaces with wavy, irregular boundaries and trapped slag, which are initiation sites for spalling under impact loading.

The M7C3 Carbide Distribution and Wear Behaviour

The M7C3 carbides in this deposit are fine and uniformly distributed along the austenite grain boundaries. This is the microstructural feature that separates a good high-chromium cast iron hardfacing from a mediocre one. Coarse, blocky carbides tend to crack and pull out under abrasive wear, leaving the matrix exposed to further damage. Fine, well-distributed carbides provide a hard, continuous network that resists abrasion while the austenite matrix provides toughness. The measured impact energy of 10.7 J in the hardfacing layer is low, which is expected for a high-chromium cast iron, but the fusion zone at 53 J provides a shock-absorbing transition. The martensitic transformation observed under heavy wear loads is a strain-induced phenomenon that actually works in your favour: the surface work-hardens as it wears, so the hardness increases in service rather than decreasing.

Integration with Engineering Practice

Where This Process Fits in the Real World

In my experience, electroslag surfacing is not the first choice for every hardfacing job. It is a high-deposition-rate process that suits large, relatively simple geometries such as mill rolls, crusher hammers, and chute liners. It is not suitable for small, complex components where you need precise control of the deposit profile. But when you have a large area to cover and the substrate is a structural steel that cannot tolerate high residual stress, electroslag surfacing is the right call. The slow thermal cycle means you can often skip the preheat that would be mandatory for arc surfacing of high-chromium cast iron, which is a significant productivity gain.

Lessons from the Shop Floor

I recall a job where we were hardfacing a set of large chute liners for an iron ore handling plant. The first attempt used FCAW with a high-chromium iron cored wire, and we got cracks running through the HAZ on every single liner. The preheat was 250 degrees Celsius, which should have been enough, but the localised heat input of the arc created a steep gradient that the preheat could not overcome. We switched to electroslag surfacing with a similar alloy composition, dropped the preheat to 100 degrees Celsius, and did not see a single crack. The difference was not the chemistry; it was the thermal profile. That is the practical lesson this paper reinforces: in hardfacing, the thermal cycle is often more important than the alloy design.

Quality Control Considerations

When you are specifying an electroslag-surfaced component, you need to think about what you are going to inspect. Ultrasonic testing (UT) is the standard method for detecting lack-of-fusion at the interface, but the coarse, columnar grain structure of the hardfacing layer can scatter the beam. I have seen false indications from grain boundaries that were mistaken for lack-of-fusion. The answer is to use a lower frequency probe and to calibrate on a representative sample with known defects. Magnetic particle testing (MT) is useful for detecting surface cracks in the hardfacing, but you need to demagnetise the component afterwards because the high-chromium cast iron can retain significant residual magnetism, which can interfere with downstream processing.

Key Questions and Reflections

The paper raises a question that I have asked myself many times: what is the upper limit on hardfacing thickness for electroslag surfacing? The authors deposited a single layer, but in practice you often need multiple layers to achieve the required wear allowance. The interface band and the HAZ are only affected by the first layer; subsequent layers are deposited onto the hardfacing itself, so the thermal cycle is different. I would want to see data on multi-layer deposits before I specified this process for a thick hardfacing requirement.

Another question is the effect of the substrate composition. D32 is a low-alloy structural steel with good weldability. What happens if you try to electroslag surface a higher-carbon steel or a cast iron substrate? The thermal gradient might still be low, but the carbon diffusion from the substrate into the interface band would be different, and the austenite band might not form in the same way. I would want to see a study on that before I committed to a production run.

Study Insights and Implications

This paper is a useful contribution because it provides quantitative data on the temperature field, which is rare in the hardfacing literature. Most papers report microstructure and hardness but leave the thermal analysis to simulation. Having measured data gives you confidence in the process window. The finding that the maximum thermal stress stays below the substrate tensile strength is the key insight: it explains why electroslag surfacing is so forgiving of cracking, and it gives you a basis for setting preheat and interpass temperature limits in a welding procedure specification.

The practical implication for my own work is that I will now consider electroslag surfacing earlier in the process selection for large wear components. I have previously defaulted to arc surfacing because it is more familiar and more widely available, but this paper has reminded me that the thermal cycle is the dominant factor in cracking, and electroslag surfacing gives you a thermal cycle that arc processes cannot match.

Reference Value and Outlook

The reference value of this paper lies in its combination of thermal measurement, microstructural characterisation and mechanical testing. The temperature field data are directly usable for finite element validation, and the microstructural observations provide a baseline for comparing different hardfacing processes. The next step in this research line should be to investigate multi-layer deposits and to examine the effect of different substrate compositions on the interface band formation. I would also like to see a comparison of electroslag surfacing with laser cladding for the same application, because laser cladding offers even lower heat input but at the cost of much lower deposition rate.

For the practising engineer, the takeaway is clear: when you have a large wear component made from a structural steel, and you need a high-chromium cast iron hardfacing without cracks, electroslag surfacing is a process that deserves serious consideration. The slow thermal cycle, the uniform temperature distribution, and the clean, flat interface are exactly what you want. The 53 J impact energy in the fusion zone gives you a tough transition layer, and the strain-induced martensitic transformation in the hardfacing gives you a self-hardening wear surface. That is a combination that is hard to beat.