ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Aluminium Bronze Powder Plasma Surfacing: Hardness and Microstructure under Magnetic Field

Literature Overview and Core Findings

This paper from Hot Working Technology (Vol. 40, No. 7, 2011) comes from the Shenyang University of Technology group led by Liu Zhengjun, who has published extensively on plasma surfacing with magnetic field control. The work addresses a question that is close to my heart because I have specified aluminium bronze surfacing for marine and boiler applications: how do you get a consistent, high-quality deposit on a steel substrate without porosity and with the right hardness? The authors used reverse-polarity weak plasma arc surfacing to deposit aluminium bronze powder onto 20g boiler steel, both without a magnetic field and with an external transverse alternating magnetic field. They then measured hardness and examined the microstructure.

The results are interesting because they show a non-monotonic relationship between welding current and hardness. Without a magnetic field, the hardness of the deposit changed in a small-large-small-large pattern as the welding current increased. At 100 A the hardness reached a maximum of 214.7 HV, while at 110 A it dropped to a minimum of 163.7 HV. With an external magnetic field applied, at a welding current of 100 A, the hardness reached a maximum of 245.9 HV when the magnetic field current was 0.5 A. At 100 A welding current, the deposit microstructure consisted of dense alpha-Cu and a network structure of alpha plus gamma-2, which was identified as the better structural condition.

Interpretation of Technical Points

The Non-Monotonic Hardness Behaviour

The small-large-small-large pattern of hardness versus welding current is not what you would naively expect. In most surfacing processes, increasing current increases heat input, which coarsens the grain structure and reduces hardness. But in plasma surfacing with powder feed, the relationship is complicated by the powder deposition efficiency and the cooling rate. At low current, the powder may not fully melt, leading to porosity and low hardness. As current increases, the powder melts more completely, the deposit becomes denser, and hardness rises. But at some point, the increased heat input coarsens the microstructure and the hardness drops again. Then, at even higher current, the increased dilution from the substrate may introduce alloying elements that raise the hardness once more. The 100 A optimum in this study represents the sweet spot where the powder is fully melted, the deposit is dense, and the grain structure is fine enough to give good hardness.

The Effect of the Magnetic Field

The application of an external transverse alternating magnetic field is a technique I have seen used in the former Soviet Union and in Chinese research, but it is rarely used in Western practice. The principle is that the magnetic field induces electromagnetic stirring in the molten pool, which breaks up the columnar grain structure, promotes equiaxed grain formation, and helps degas the deposit. The measured hardness increase from 214.7 HV to 245.9 HV at 100 A welding current and 0.5 A magnetic field current is a 14.5 percent improvement, which is significant for a surfacing application. The magnetic field current of 0.5 A is very low, which suggests that the stirring effect saturates quickly. I would want to know what happens at higher magnetic field currents, because the paper only reports the maximum at 0.5 A.

The Alpha-Cu Plus Gamma-2 Microstructure

The identification of dense alpha-Cu with a network of alpha plus gamma-2 as the better structural condition is a useful practical finding. Aluminium bronze deposits on steel are prone to porosity because of the difference in melting points and thermal conductivity between copper and steel. The alpha phase is the ductile copper-rich solid solution, and the gamma-2 phase is the hard, brittle intermetallic compound that provides wear resistance. The network morphology is important: a continuous network of alpha plus gamma-2 along the alpha grain boundaries gives a composite-like structure with good wear resistance and acceptable toughness. If the gamma-2 phase forms as coarse, isolated particles, the wear resistance is lower and the deposit is more prone to spalling.

Integration with Engineering Practice

Where Aluminium Bronze Surfacing Is Used

I have specified aluminium bronze surfacing for several applications: ship propeller shafts where the bronze provides corrosion resistance and a low-friction surface, boiler components where the bronze provides resistance to high-temperature oxidation, and bearing housings where the bronze provides a self-lubricating surface. The 20g boiler steel substrate in this paper is a classic application: you want the strength and low cost of carbon steel, but you need the surface properties of aluminium bronze on the outside.

The Porosity Problem and How Magnetic Field Helps

The biggest practical problem with aluminium bronze surfacing on steel is porosity. The copper alloy has a much higher thermal conductivity than steel, so the molten pool cools rapidly from the bottom, trapping gas bubbles that do not have time to escape. The result is a deposit with scattered porosity that fails pressure testing or leaks in service. The electromagnetic stirring induced by the magnetic field is a proven countermeasure because it agitates the molten pool, helping gas bubbles rise to the surface and escape. The hardness improvement from 214.7 HV to 245.9 HV is partly due to the denser deposit and partly due to the refined grain structure.

Lessons from the Shop Floor

I recall a job where we were surfacing a large boiler feed pump shaft with aluminium bronze. The first attempt used gas tungsten arc welding (GTAW) with a bronze filler rod, and we had porosity throughout the deposit. We tried increasing the shielding gas flow, we tried preheating the shaft, we tried reducing the travel speed, and none of it worked. The porosity was caused by the rapid cooling of the molten pool on the steel substrate. We eventually solved it by switching to plasma transfer arc surfacing with powder feed, which gave a more controlled heat input and a slower cooling rate. The magnetic field technique described in this paper would have been even better, because it would have actively stirred the pool rather than relying on the thermal cycle alone.

Quality Control Considerations

When you are inspecting an aluminium bronze surfaced component, you need to be aware that conventional ultrasonic testing is difficult because of the acoustic impedance mismatch between copper and steel. The interface between the bronze deposit and the steel substrate reflects the ultrasonic beam strongly, making it hard to distinguish between a good bond and a lack-of-fusion defect. I have found that eddy current testing is more effective for detecting surface and near-surface defects in the bronze layer, and that a simple dye penetrant test will catch porosity that breaks the surface. For internal porosity, radiography is the most reliable method, but it is expensive and requires access to both sides of the component.

Key Questions and Reflections

The paper does not report the wear resistance of the deposits, only the hardness. For a bearing or a wear surface, hardness is a useful proxy, but it is not the whole story. I would want to see wear test data, particularly under lubricated conditions, before I specified this process for a bearing application. The friction coefficient of aluminium bronze against steel is an important parameter that is not captured by a hardness measurement.

Another question is the effect of the magnetic field on the dilution of the deposit. Plasma surfacing typically has lower dilution than arc surfacing, but the magnetic stirring might increase the mixing of the substrate into the deposit, which would change the composition and properties. The paper does not report dilution measurements, which is a gap in the data.

Study Insights and Implications

This paper is a useful contribution because it demonstrates a practical method for improving the hardness and microstructure of aluminium bronze plasma surfacing. The magnetic field technique is simple to implement on an existing plasma surfacing system: you just add a coil around the torch or below the workpiece and connect it to a low-current power supply. The 0.5 A magnetic field current that gave the best result is easy to achieve with standard equipment.

The practical implication for my own work is that I will now consider adding magnetic field control to any plasma surfacing job where I need to improve deposit quality. The cost is low, the implementation is straightforward, and the benefit in terms of hardness and density is significant. The finding that the magnetic field current has an optimum at 0.5 A is useful because it tells me not to overdo it: too much stirring can actually cause turbulence and porosity, so the parameter needs to be controlled carefully.

Reference Value and Outlook

The reference value of this paper lies in its demonstration of the magnetic field effect on aluminium bronze surfacing, which is a relatively niche application but one where the improvement is meaningful. The hardness data provide a useful baseline for process qualification, and the microstructural observations give a clear target for the deposit structure. The next step in this research line should be to investigate the wear behaviour of the deposits under different magnetic field parameters and to measure the dilution and porosity levels quantitatively.

For the practising engineer, the takeaway is that aluminium bronze plasma surfacing is a viable process for putting a corrosion-resistant, wear-resistant surface on steel components, and that magnetic field control is a simple, low-cost method for improving deposit quality. The optimum parameters identified in this paper, 100 A welding current and 0.5 A magnetic field current, are a good starting point for process development, but you should always verify the results on your own equipment because the exact optimum will depend on your torch design, powder feed rate, and substrate geometry.