ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Numerical Simulation of Preheating Effects on Cooling Temperature Field and Stress Field in Medium-High Carbon Steel Hardfacing

1. Literature Overview and Core Findings

This study by Zang Xinliang and colleagues from Yanshan University investigates the effect of preheating on the cooling temperature field and stress field in hardfacing of 60CrMnMo steel. The team measured the temperature field and residual stress field of hardfaced specimens without preheating, developed a two-dimensional finite element model, and validated the model against experimental data. They then used the model to simulate the effect of 200°C preheating on the temperature field and stress field at different times during cooling, with particular attention to stress changes during martensitic transformation.

The core findings are as follows:

Parameter Observation
Base material 60CrMnMo medium-high carbon steel
Simulation method Two-dimensional finite element model
Model validation Simulated results agree well with measured results
Preheating temperature 200°C
Temperature distribution More uniform with preheating; center cools rapidly after 30 s
Maximum tensile stress Located in the heat-affected zone, not the hardfacing zone
Martensitic transformation Causes sharp increase in tensile stress in the HAZ
Preheating effect Reduces maximum tensile stress in the HAZ, reducing cracking tendency

2. Metallurgical Interpretation and Technical Points

This paper addresses a critical issue in hardfacing of medium-high carbon steels: the risk of cracking due to thermal stresses and martensitic transformation. The 60CrMnMo steel is a typical medium-high carbon steel used in applications such as rolls, dies, and heavy machinery components. Hardfacing this steel presents significant challenges because the base material has high carbon content and is susceptible to cold cracking.

The finite element model provides a quantitative framework for understanding the temperature and stress evolution during hardfacing. The model validation against experimental data is particularly valuable, as it demonstrates that the simulation can reliably predict the actual behavior.

The key finding is that the maximum tensile stress occurs in the heat-affected zone (HAZ), not in the hardfacing layer itself. This is counterintuitive to many engineers who assume that the hardfacing layer, being the most recently deposited and hottest material, would have the highest stress. In reality, the HAZ experiences a complex combination of thermal expansion, contraction, and phase transformation that produces the highest tensile stress.

The martensitic transformation in the HAZ is a critical event. When the HAZ cools through the martensite start temperature, the transformation from austenite to martensite is accompanied by a volume expansion. This expansion creates additional tensile stress in the surrounding material. The authors show that this transformation-induced stress causes a sharp increase in the HAZ tensile stress, which can exceed the material's fracture strength and cause cracking.

Preheating at 200°C reduces the maximum tensile stress in the HAZ. This is because preheating reduces the temperature gradient between the hardfacing layer and the base material, resulting in a more uniform temperature distribution. This reduces the thermal stresses that develop during cooling. Preheating also reduces the cooling rate, which can affect the martensitic transformation kinetics and the resulting stress.

3. Engineering Practice Implications

In the steel pipe and pipe fitting industry, we frequently hardface medium-high carbon steel components such as forming rolls, mandrels, and dies. These components are often large and complex, and the hardfacing operation must be carefully controlled to avoid cracking.

The finding that the maximum tensile stress is in the HAZ, not the hardfacing layer, is directly relevant to hardfacing procedure development. It means that the HAZ is the critical zone for crack prevention, not the hardfacing layer itself. This has implications for preheating, interpass temperature control, and post-weld heat treatment.

The practical implication of the preheating effect is that 200°C preheating can significantly reduce the cracking tendency in hardfacing of 60CrMnMo steel. This is a relatively low preheating temperature, which is practical for shop floor operations. The key is to ensure that the preheating is applied uniformly and that the interpass temperature is maintained within the specified range.

4. Key Questions and Reflections

One question that this paper raises is whether the 200°C preheating temperature is optimal or whether higher or lower temperatures would be more effective. The authors only simulated 200°C, so the effect of other preheating temperatures is not explored. In practice, the optimal preheating temperature will depend on the base material composition, the hardfacing alloy, and the component geometry.

Another reflection concerns the effect of preheating on the hardfacing layer itself. The authors focus on the HAZ, but the hardfacing layer also experiences thermal stresses. Preheating may reduce the cooling rate of the hardfacing layer, which could affect its microstructure and properties. This is an area that deserves further investigation.

5. Study Insights and Practical Recommendations

This literature study provides valuable guidance for hardfacing of medium-high carbon steels:

  1. The maximum tensile stress occurs in the HAZ, not the hardfacing layer.
  2. Martensitic transformation in the HAZ causes a sharp increase in tensile stress.
  3. Preheating at 200°C reduces the maximum HAZ tensile stress and reduces cracking tendency.
  4. Finite element simulation is a valuable tool for optimizing hardfacing procedures.

For the shop floor, this means that hardfacing procedures for medium-high carbon steels should include preheating to reduce the HAZ tensile stress and prevent cracking. The preheating temperature should be determined based on the base material composition and the hardfacing alloy, and it should be verified through trial welding and inspection.

The practical outcome is a more reliable hardfacing process for medium-high carbon steel components. By understanding the stress distribution and the effect of preheating, we can develop procedures that minimize the risk of cracking and produce high-quality hardfaced components. I would recommend that any hardfacing procedure for medium-high carbon steel include a preheating requirement and a verification method for HAZ cracking.