ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Analysis of Microstructure and Properties of Manual Arc Welding Cladding Metal

Literature Overview

This paper by Zhong Yu and colleagues from Xihua University investigates the microstructure and microhardness of cladding metal deposited using CHR172 electrode on 45 steel substrate with manual arc welding (SMAW). The authors analyse the heat-affected zone (HAZ) and the deposited metal under different welding conditions, discussing the effects of heat input and alloy elements on the microstructure and hardness of the cladding layer. The study is a classic example of how welding parameters and filler metal composition interact to determine the final properties of a hardfacing layer.

CHR172 is a chromium-based hardfacing electrode, and 45 steel is a common medium-carbon structural steel. The combination is typical of applications such as rolls, shafts and dies, where a hard, wear-resistant surface is required on a tough, machinable substrate. The paper's focus on the relationship between heat input, alloy content and microstructure is directly relevant to anyone specifying hardfacing for such components.

Technical Interpretation

The authors conclude that the microstructure and microhardness of the cladding layer depend not only on the heat input but also on the alloy composition of the electrode, the type of hard particles formed, the bonding between these particles and the matrix, and their distribution. This is a comprehensive view that goes beyond the simple "higher hardness is better" approach.

Factor Effect on Microstructure Effect on Hardness
Heat input Coarser grains, more dilution Decreases
Alloy content More hard phases Increases
Hard particle type Determines wear mechanism Variable
Particle-matrix bonding Critical for integrity Indirect

The discussion of hard particles is particularly important. In chromium-based hardfacing, the primary hard phases are typically chromium carbides, which can be either primary or eutectic. The size, shape and distribution of these carbides have a profound effect on wear resistance. If the carbides are large and blocky, they may crack or pull out under stress. If they are finely dispersed, they provide better wear resistance and toughness.

The paper also highlights the role of heat input in controlling the dilution of the base metal into the cladding. High heat input increases dilution, which reduces the alloy content of the cladding layer and can change the microstructure from the intended hypereutectic to a hypoeutectic composition. This is a critical point for hardfacing, where the alloy content must be maintained above a minimum to achieve the desired hardness and wear resistance.

Engineering Practice Insights

In my experience, the most common failure of hardfaced components is not wear but cracking or spalling, often caused by improper selection of heat input. The paper's finding that heat input affects both dilution and grain size is a reminder that the welding parameters must be chosen with the final microstructure in mind. A welder who simply turns up the current to increase deposition rate may inadvertently reduce the hardness and wear resistance of the cladding.

The practical application of this study is in the development of welding procedure specifications (WPS) for hardfacing. The WPS must specify not only the electrode and current but also the travel speed, which controls heat input. The paper provides a technical basis for setting these parameters to achieve a consistent microstructure and hardness.

Another practical point is the importance of preheat and interpass temperature. For 45 steel, which has a carbon content of around 0.45%, the risk of hydrogen-induced cracking in the HAZ is significant. The paper does not address this directly, but the discussion of the HAZ microstructure implies that the authors are aware of the potential for problems. In a real shop, preheat would be mandatory for this substrate, and the paper's findings should be considered within that context.

Key Takeaways

The study reinforces the principle that hardfacing is a metallurgical process, not just a mechanical one. The properties of the cladding layer are determined by the interplay of chemistry, thermal history and solidification, and the welding parameters are the primary control variables. The paper's emphasis on hard particle type and distribution is a valuable reminder that wear resistance is not solely a function of hardness.

For the engineer, the key takeaway is that the selection of a hardfacing electrode must be matched to the service conditions and the welding process. A high-alloy electrode may give high hardness, but if the heat input is too high, the dilution will reduce the alloy content and the hardness will drop. Conversely, a low-alloy electrode may be adequate if the heat input is carefully controlled to minimise dilution.

Conclusion

This paper provides a solid foundation for understanding the metallurgy of manual arc welding hardfacing. The authors have systematically analysed the effects of heat input and alloy content on microstructure and hardness, and their findings are directly applicable to production. For any shop involved in hardfacing of carbon steel components, this study offers practical guidance on parameter selection and highlights the importance of controlling the welding process to achieve the desired properties. The paper also serves as a reminder that the best hardfacing is one that is tailored to the specific wear mechanism and service environment.