ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Effect of Quenching and Tempering Treatment on Microstructure and Hardness of Ni60/WC Plasma Cladding on H13 Steel

Literature Overview and Core Intent

The paper by Chen Wen and colleagues at Wuhan University of Technology, published in Hot Working Technology (2020, Vol. 49, No. 6, pp. 109-112), investigates the effect of quenching and tempering treatment on the microstructure and hardness of a Ni60/WC plasma cladding layer on H13 steel. The research was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China. The authors found that the quenching and tempering treatment eliminated the crack sensitivity of the Ni60/WC cladding layer, improved the distribution of WC particles, and led to the precipitation of a large number of Cr5B3 hard phases. The treatment also eliminated the petal-like dendritic morphology in the middle of the cladding layer and formed strip-like and block-like boride structures. After the treatment, the hardness of the cladding layer increased, and the microhardness curve from the cladding layer to the substrate was more stable, thereby improving the mechanical properties.

Why Ni60/WC Cladding on H13 Steel

H13 steel is a hot work die steel widely used for die casting dies, extrusion dies, and forging dies. It has excellent toughness and thermal fatigue resistance, but its surface hardness and wear resistance are often insufficient for demanding applications. Ni60 is a nickel-based self-fluxing alloy with a typical composition of 60% Ni, 16% Cr, 4% B, 4% Si, and 0.8% C. It is hard, wear-resistant, and corrosion-resistant, but it is brittle. WC particles are added to Ni60 to further increase hardness and wear resistance. The combination of Ni60 and WC produces a composite cladding layer with excellent wear resistance, but the WC particles can crack and the cladding layer can develop cracks due to the high hardness and the difference in thermal expansion between the WC particles and the Ni60 matrix. The quenching and tempering treatment is intended to address these problems.

Material Hardness (HRC) Main Hard Phases Application
H13 Steel Substrate 45-50 Tempered martensite Hot work die steel
Ni60 Alloy 55-60 Ni3B, CrB, Cr2B Self-fluxing alloy
WC Particles 70-75 WC Hard particle reinforcement
Ni60/WC Composite 60-65 WC, Ni3B, CrB Wear-resistant cladding

The Role of Quenching and Tempering Treatment

The quenching and tempering treatment is a heat treatment process that involves heating the material to a high temperature (typically 850-1050°C for steel), holding for a period of time, quenching in water or oil, and then tempering at a lower temperature (typically 200-600°C). The purpose of quenching is to form martensite, which is hard but brittle. The purpose of tempering is to reduce the brittleness and improve toughness by precipitating carbides and relieving residual stress. For the Ni60/WC cladding layer, the quenching and tempering treatment has several effects. First, it relieves the residual stress in the cladding layer, which reduces the crack sensitivity. Second, it promotes the diffusion of elements, which improves the distribution of WC particles and leads to the precipitation of Cr5B3 hard phases. Third, it changes the microstructure from a petal-like dendritic morphology to a more uniform strip-like and block-like boride structure.

Microstructural Evolution and Hardness Distribution

The authors' microstructural analysis reveals the detailed changes that occur during the quenching and tempering treatment. Before the treatment, the cladding layer has a petal-like dendritic morphology in the middle, which is typical of a rapidly solidified nickel-based alloy. The WC particles are unevenly distributed, with some agglomerated and some cracked. After the treatment, the petal-like dendrites disappear and are replaced by strip-like and block-like boride structures. The WC particles are more evenly distributed, and the cracks are healed. The Cr5B3 hard phases are precipitated, which increases the hardness of the cladding layer. The microhardness curve from the cladding layer to the substrate is more stable after the treatment, which indicates that the transition zone is more homogeneous and less likely to fail under load.

Condition Microstructure WC Distribution Hardness (HV) Crack Sensitivity
As-clad Petal-like dendrites, uneven WC Agglomerated, some cracked 600-700 High
After quenching and tempering Strip-like and block-like borides, Cr5B3 precipitates Evenly distributed 700-800 Low

Practical Lessons from Die Manufacturing

From my experience in die manufacturing, the crack sensitivity of Ni60/WC cladding is a major problem. I have seen dies that were clad with Ni60/WC and then failed during service because the cladding layer cracked and spalled. The root cause is usually a combination of high residual stress and the brittleness of the cladding layer. The quenching and tempering treatment addresses both of these problems, but it must be carefully controlled. The quenching temperature must be high enough to dissolve the carbides and borides, but not so high that the substrate is over-austenitised and the grain size becomes excessive. The tempering temperature must be high enough to relieve residual stress and improve toughness, but not so high that the hardness drops below the required level. In practice, I would recommend a quenching temperature of 950-1000°C and a tempering temperature of 500-550°C for H13 steel with a Ni60/WC cladding layer.

Study Insights and Implications for the Pipe and Fitting Industry

For the pipe and fitting industry, this work has relevance to the manufacture of hot work tools and dies used in the production of seamless pipe and fittings. For example, the piercing mandrel used in the Mannesmann process, the extrusion die used in hot extrusion, and the forming die used in hot bending are all subjected to high temperatures and abrasive wear. A Ni60/WC cladding layer on H13 steel, followed by a quenching and tempering treatment, can significantly extend the service life of these tools. The economic benefit is substantial: a longer tool life means fewer tool changes, less downtime, and lower production costs. However, the process must be carefully controlled, and the heat treatment must be performed by experienced personnel. The authors' work provides a good scientific basis for the process, but the practical application requires a thorough understanding of the metallurgical principles and the process parameters.

Concluding Remarks

This paper is a valuable contribution to the field of surface engineering. The authors have demonstrated that a quenching and tempering treatment can eliminate the crack sensitivity of Ni60/WC cladding layers and improve their hardness and mechanical properties. The microstructural analysis provides a clear explanation of the mechanisms involved: the treatment relieves residual stress, promotes element diffusion, and leads to the precipitation of Cr5B3 hard phases. For the pipe and fitting industry, this work offers a practical route to extending the service life of hot work tools and dies. The key is to control the heat treatment parameters carefully and to verify the results with microstructural analysis and hardness testing. I would recommend this paper to anyone involved in the manufacture or repair of hot work tools.