ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Microstructure Evolution and Properties of Inconel 625 Cladding on X90 Steel at Different Solution Treatment Temperatures

Literature Overview and Core Intent

The paper by Wang Dan and colleagues at Southwest Petroleum University, published in Metal Heat Treatment (2018, Vol. 43, No. 7, pp. 73-78), investigates the microstructure evolution and mechanical properties of Inconel 625 cladding on X90 steel after solution treatment at different temperatures. The authors used hot-wire TIG welding to deposit Inconel 625 (ENiGrMo-3) filler wire on X90 steel, and then subjected the samples to solution treatment at 850°C and 910°C for 2 hours followed by water cooling. Using optical microscopy, impact testing, microhardness testing, SEM, and EDS analysis, they studied the microstructure evolution and mechanical properties of the cladding layer at different solution treatment temperatures. The results show that the microstructure from the fusion line to the top of the cladding layer is the same before and after solution treatment: planar crystals, cellular crystals, dendritic crystals, equiaxed crystals, and transverse structure at the top. However, the fusion zone is more uniform after solution treatment. After solution treatment at 910°C, significant diffusion of Ni and Cr alloying elements occurs. The hardness and impact properties of the sample after solution treatment at 850°C are better than those of the as-clad sample and the sample after solution treatment at 910°C. The hardness near the fusion line on the substrate side is 77.4 HV1 higher than before solution treatment, and the impact absorption energy is 19.40 J higher than after solution treatment at 910°C.

Why Inconel 625 Cladding on X90 Steel

X90 steel is a high-strength pipeline steel used for high-pressure gas transmission pipelines. It has a yield strength of at least 620 MPa and a tensile strength of at least 700 MPa. However, X90 steel has limited corrosion resistance, and when transporting sour gas or corrosive media, it requires a corrosion-resistant cladding. Inconel 625 is a nickel-based superalloy with excellent corrosion resistance and high-temperature strength. It has a typical composition of 58% Ni, 21.5% Cr, 9% Mo, 3.5% Nb, and 0.4% Ti. The combination of X90 steel and Inconel 625 cladding provides the strength of the pipeline steel and the corrosion resistance of the nickel-based alloy. This is a common approach for high-pressure sour service pipelines.

Material Yield Strength (MPa) Tensile Strength (MPa) Corrosion Resistance Application
X90 Steel ≥620 ≥700 Limited Pipeline structural material
Inconel 625 400-500 800-900 Excellent Corrosion-resistant cladding
X90 + Inconel 625 Cladding ≥620 ≥700 Excellent Sour service pipeline

Microstructure Evolution During Solution Treatment

The authors' microstructural analysis reveals the detailed evolution of the cladding layer during solution treatment. The microstructure from the fusion line to the top of the cladding layer is the same before and after solution treatment: planar crystals at the fusion line, cellular crystals, dendritic crystals, equiaxed crystals, and transverse structure at the top. This is a typical solidification structure for a nickel-based alloy cladding layer. The planar crystals at the fusion line indicate that the solidification started with a planar growth front, which is typical of a low-temperature gradient and high-solidification rate. The cellular and dendritic crystals indicate that the solidification front became unstable and developed into cellular and dendritic growth. The equiaxed crystals at the top indicate that the solidification rate was high enough to promote nucleation ahead of the solidification front. The transverse structure at the top is a result of the arc plasma and the surface tension of the molten pool.

Region Microstructure Before Solution Treatment Microstructure After Solution Treatment
Fusion line Planar crystals Planar crystals, more uniform
Near fusion line Cellular crystals Cellular crystals, more uniform
Middle of cladding Dendritic crystals Dendritic crystals, more uniform
Upper cladding Equiaxed crystals Equiaxed crystals, more uniform
Top of cladding Transverse structure Transverse structure, more uniform

Effect of Solution Treatment Temperature on Mechanical Properties

The authors found that the solution treatment temperature has a significant effect on the mechanical properties of the cladding layer. After solution treatment at 850°C, the hardness and impact properties are better than those of the as-clad sample and the sample after solution treatment at 910°C. The hardness near the fusion line on the substrate side is 77.4 HV1 higher than before solution treatment, and the impact absorption energy is 19.40 J higher than after solution treatment at 910°C. This indicates that the 850°C solution treatment is the optimal temperature for this cladding system. The 910°C solution treatment causes significant diffusion of Ni and Cr alloying elements, which leads to the formation of a wider diffusion zone and a reduction in the hardness and impact properties. The 850°C solution treatment, on the other hand, provides sufficient diffusion to homogenise the microstructure without causing excessive dilution of the alloying elements.

Condition Hardness Near Fusion Line (HV1) Impact Absorption Energy (J) Microstructure Uniformity
As-clad Baseline Baseline Less uniform
After 850°C solution treatment +77.4 HV1 +19.40 J vs. 910°C More uniform
After 910°C solution treatment Lower than 850°C Lower than 850°C More uniform, but excessive diffusion

Practical Lessons from Pipeline Manufacturing

From my experience in pipeline manufacturing, the solution treatment of cladded pipes is a critical step that is often overlooked. The cladding layer is deposited in a non-equilibrium state, and it contains residual stress and a non-uniform microstructure. The solution treatment relieves the residual stress and homogenises the microstructure, but it must be carefully controlled. Too high a temperature causes excessive diffusion of alloying elements and a reduction in the corrosion resistance and mechanical properties. Too low a temperature does not provide sufficient homogenisation. The authors' finding that 850°C is the optimal temperature for Inconel 625 cladding on X90 steel is valuable, but it must be verified for each specific application. The solution treatment time is also important: 2 hours is a reasonable starting point, but it may need to be adjusted depending on the thickness of the cladding layer and the pipe diameter.

Study Insights and Implications for the Pipe and Fitting Industry

For the pipe and fitting industry, this work has direct relevance to the manufacture of bimetallic pipes and fittings for sour service applications. The solution treatment of cladded pipes is a critical step in the manufacturing process, and the optimal temperature must be determined for each specific combination of base metal and cladding material. The authors' work provides a good scientific basis for the process, but the practical application requires a thorough understanding of the metallurgical principles and the process parameters. The key takeaways are: control the solution treatment temperature to balance homogenisation and diffusion, verify the mechanical properties with hardness and impact testing, and inspect the microstructure to ensure that the fusion zone is uniform and free of defects.

Concluding Remarks

This paper is a valuable contribution to the field of bimetallic pipe manufacturing. The authors have systematically studied the effect of solution treatment temperature on the microstructure and mechanical properties of Inconel 625 cladding on X90 steel. The finding that 850°C is the optimal solution treatment temperature is particularly valuable, as it provides a practical guideline for the manufacturing process. The microstructural analysis provides a clear explanation of the mechanisms involved: the solution treatment homogenises the microstructure and relieves residual stress, but excessive temperature causes diffusion of alloying elements and a reduction in properties. For the pipe and fitting industry, this work offers a practical route to producing high-quality bimetallic pipes for sour service applications. The key is to control the solution treatment temperature carefully and to verify the results with mechanical testing and microstructural analysis.