ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Effect of Process Parameters on the Limit Inclination Angle in Surfacing Deposition: A Veteran's Study Note

Literature Overview and Background

This paper, published in Journal of Shenyang University of Technology in 2012, investigates the influence of process parameters on the limit inclination angle in MIG surfacing deposition. The study uses a single-pass multi-layer deposition approach to understand how the welding current, wire feed speed, and deposition speed affect the maximum angle at which the weld can be deposited without the molten pool flowing away. This is a critical issue in additive manufacturing and repair surfacing, where the deposition is often done on inclined or curved surfaces. As a veteran in the pipe and fitting industry, I have encountered this problem in the repair of large valves, pump casings, and pipe fittings, where the weld must be deposited on a surface that is not horizontal. The limit inclination angle is the maximum angle at which the weld pool remains stable and the deposited metal stays in place.

Influence of Process Parameters on Limit Inclination Angle

The paper's key finding is that the limit inclination angle is primarily determined by the welding current, which in turn affects the size and shape of the weld pool and the droplet transfer mode. The paper distinguishes between two directions: along the weld path and perpendicular to the weld path. The following table summarizes the key findings:

Parameter Effect on Limit Inclination Angle (Along Weld Path) Effect on Limit Inclination Angle (Perpendicular to Weld Path)
Welding Current Determines the angle; higher current reduces the angle Determines the angle; higher current reduces the angle
Wire Feed Speed No significant effect Angle decreases with increasing wire feed speed
Deposition Speed No significant effect Angle increases then decreases; maximum at 18-21 mm/s

The limit inclination angle along the weld path is consistently 45°, regardless of the wire feed speed or deposition speed. This is a fascinating result. It suggests that the weld pool is stable up to 45° when the deposition is in the direction of the weld path. This is because the droplet transfer and the surface tension forces are balanced in this direction. In contrast, the limit inclination angle perpendicular to the weld path is more complex. It decreases with increasing wire feed speed, which increases the welding current and the size of the weld pool. A larger weld pool is more susceptible to gravity, so it is less stable on an inclined surface. The angle increases with deposition speed up to a maximum of 50° at 18-21 mm/s, then decreases. This is because a faster deposition speed reduces the heat input per unit length, resulting in a smaller weld pool, which is more stable. However, if the deposition speed is too high, the weld pool may not have enough time to wet the surface, leading to lack of fusion.

Droplet Transfer and Force Balance

The paper provides a detailed analysis of the force balance on the droplet and the weld pool. The limit inclination angle is determined by the balance between the gravitational force, the surface tension force, and the electromagnetic force (Lorentz force) generated by the welding current. When the welding current is high, the electromagnetic force is stronger, which can help stabilize the weld pool. However, a higher current also increases the weld pool size, making it more susceptible to gravity. The paper explains that the effect of the welding current on the limit inclination angle is primarily through its influence on the droplet transfer mode. At low currents, the droplet transfer is globular, and the droplet is large and heavy, which reduces the stability of the weld pool. At higher currents, the transfer becomes spray, and the droplets are small and light, which improves stability. However, the increased heat input at higher currents also enlarges the weld pool, which reduces stability. The net effect is a complex relationship that the paper explores in detail.

Practical Implications for Surfacing and Additive Manufacturing

The paper's findings have direct relevance to the repair and additive manufacturing of pipe fittings and other components. In my experience, the repair of worn surfaces on large pipe fittings, such as elbows and tees, often requires deposition on inclined surfaces. If the inclination angle exceeds the limit, the weld metal will flow away, leading to a defective deposit. The paper's finding that the limit inclination angle along the weld path is 45° is a useful guideline. However, the perpendicular direction is more restrictive, and the maximum angle of 50° at a deposition speed of 18-21 mm/s is an important process window.

For practical application, I would recommend the following:

In one project I was involved in, we were repairing a large cast steel valve body that had a worn seat surface. The surface was inclined at approximately 30°, which was within the limit for the along-weld-path direction. However, we had to be careful with the perpendicular direction, as the weld was being deposited in a circular pattern. We found that by using a pulsed current and a deposition speed of 20 mm/s, we could achieve a stable deposit. The paper's findings would have been very useful in that project.

Summary

This study provides a thorough analysis of the effect of process parameters on the limit inclination angle in MIG surfacing deposition. The key finding is that the limit inclination angle along the weld path is consistently 45°, while the perpendicular direction is more complex and depends on the welding current and deposition speed. The maximum angle of 50° at a deposition speed of 18-21 mm/s is an important process window for practical applications. The paper's analysis of the droplet transfer and force balance provides a solid theoretical foundation for understanding the process. For engineers involved in repair surfacing or additive manufacturing, this paper is a valuable reference for selecting process parameters that ensure a stable and defect-free deposit on inclined surfaces. The findings are directly applicable to the repair of pipe fittings, valves, and other components where surfacing is required.