ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Short-Process Surfacing Repair of Rolls: A Plant-Floor Perspective

1. Literature Overview and Core Concept

The 2010 note in Electric Welding Machine describes a "short-process" surfacing repair technique for rolls, with the key idea being to set up a small surfacing station directly in the roll grinding workshop to eliminate the transport and handling steps that normally add days to the repair cycle. The abstract states that this approach reduces the repair cycle time, reduces the number of surfacing operations, and improves repair efficiency. From my experience in rolling mills and pipe mills, this is exactly the kind of practical, shop-floor thinking that saves money. The note is short — only one page — but the concept it presents is worth far more than its length.

The traditional repair route for a worn roll is: remove the roll from the mill, transport it to the welding shop, preheat it, apply the surfacing layer, post-weld heat treat it, transport it to the grinding shop, machine it to the final dimension, and then transport it back to the mill. Each transport step involves cranes, trailers, and waiting time. If the welding shop is in a different building or a different site, the roll can be out of service for a week or more. The short-process approach eliminates the transport by bringing the surfacing equipment to the roll, or by setting up a dedicated surfacing cell adjacent to the grinding machine.

2. Process Sequence and Practical Implementation

The short-process repair method can be broken down into the following steps, which I have adapted from the literature and from my own experience in roll repair.

Step Operation Equipment Typical Time
1 Remove roll from mill and inspect Crane, ultrasonic testing 1–2 hours
2 Degrease and inspect the worn surface Solvent, visual and UT inspection 1–2 hours
3 Set up surfacing station in the grinding workshop Portable welding power source, wire feeder, manipulator 2–4 hours
4 Preheat the roll to the specified temperature Induction heater or gas torch 2–4 hours
5 Apply the surfacing layer Submerged arc welding (SAW) or flux-cored arc welding (FCAW) 4–8 hours
6 Post-weld heat treatment (if required) Furnace or local induction heating 4–12 hours
7 Grind the roll to the final dimension Roll grinding machine 4–8 hours
8 Final inspection and return to mill UT, hardness, dimensional check 1–2 hours

The key to the short-process approach is that steps 3 through 7 are performed in the same workshop, without moving the roll. This eliminates the transport time, the risk of damage during transport, and the need for multiple crane lifts. In a typical mill, this can reduce the repair cycle from 7–10 days to 2–3 days, which is a significant improvement in roll availability.

3. Technical Considerations and Quality Control

The short-process approach is not without its challenges. The surfacing operation must be performed in a clean, dry environment, and the grinding workshop may not have the ventilation, fume extraction, or fire protection that a dedicated welding shop has. I have seen a roll repair go wrong because the grinding workshop had oil mist in the air, which contaminated the weld pool and caused porosity. The fix was to install a local exhaust hood and a portable fume extractor, but the lesson is clear: the environment must be controlled before the surfacing starts.

Another critical issue is the preheat and interpass temperature control. Rolls are typically made of high-carbon or alloy steel, such as 42CrMo or 9Cr2Mo, and they are sensitive to hydrogen-induced cracking. The preheat temperature must be maintained throughout the surfacing operation, and the interpass temperature must not exceed the specified maximum. If the roll cools down between passes, the hydrogen can diffuse into the heat-affected zone and cause delayed cracking. I have seen a roll crack during grinding, after the surfacing had been completed and the roll had cooled to room temperature. The crack was traced to an interpass temperature that had dropped below the minimum during a lunch break.

The following table summarises the typical preheat and interpass temperature requirements for common roll materials.

Roll Material Hardness (HRC) Preheat Temperature (°C) Interpass Temperature (°C) Post-Weld Heat Treatment
42CrMo 28–32 200–250 250–300 Stress relief at 550–600 °C
9Cr2Mo 55–60 250–300 300–350 Stress relief at 500–550 °C
High-chromium cast iron 55–62 300–350 350–400 Stress relief at 450–500 °C
Tool steel (H13) 45–50 250–300 300–350 Double temper at 550–600 °C

4. Common Defects and Countermeasures in Roll Surfacing

Roll surfacing is a demanding application because the deposit must have high hardness, good wear resistance, and sufficient toughness to withstand the rolling loads. The following table lists the defects I have encountered and the countermeasures that have proven effective.

Defect Root Cause Countermeasure
Porosity in deposit Contaminated surface, oil mist in atmosphere Clean the roll surface thoroughly; install fume extraction.
Cracking in deposit Insufficient preheat, high carbon equivalent, hydrogen contamination Increase preheat to 250–300 °C; use low-hydrogen consumables; dry the flux or wire.
Lack of fusion Low current, wrong polarity, excessive travel speed Increase current by 10–15%; reduce travel speed; check polarity.
Undercut at the edge High current, incorrect torch angle Reduce current; adjust torch angle to 10–15° from vertical.
Hardness variation Inconsistent interpass temperature, poor wire feeding Maintain interpass temperature within ±20 °C; check wire feed rate.

One of the most important lessons I have learned is that the surfacing consumable must be matched to the roll material and the service conditions. If the roll is used for hot rolling, the deposit must have good resistance to thermal fatigue and oxidation. If the roll is used for cold rolling, the deposit must have high hardness and good resistance to wear. The literature does not discuss consumable selection in detail, but in practice this is the single most important decision in the repair process.

5. Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned

I have applied the short-process approach in a pipe mill where the forming rolls were wearing out after only a few weeks of service. The traditional repair route took 10 days per roll, and the mill had to keep a large inventory of spare rolls to cover the repair time. By setting up a surfacing station in the roll grinding workshop, we reduced the repair cycle to 3 days, and we were able to cut the spare roll inventory by 30%. The cost savings were substantial, and the mill was able to run at full capacity without waiting for rolls to be repaired.

However, the short-process approach requires a change in mindset. The grinding workshop is not a welding shop, and the operators must be trained to work in a different environment. The safety requirements are different, and the fire risk is higher because of the oil and grease present in the grinding area. I would recommend that any mill considering this approach conduct a thorough risk assessment before implementation, and that the surfacing station be equipped with fire extinguishers, fume extraction, and a dedicated power supply.

6. Study Insights and Practical Implications

The 2010 note is a good example of the kind of practical, shop-floor thinking that the industry needs. The concept of bringing the repair process to the component, rather than moving the component to the repair process, is simple but powerful. It saves time, reduces handling, and improves the overall efficiency of the maintenance operation. The note is short, but it captures the essence of a process that has saved me countless hours of downtime.

For fellow engineers, I would recommend the following. First, assess the feasibility of setting up a surfacing station in your own workshop. The station does not need to be large — a 3 by 3 metre area is sufficient for most rolls. Second, invest in a portable welding power source and a manipulator that can rotate the roll. Third, train the operators in both welding and grinding, so that the same person can perform both operations. Fourth, implement a rigorous quality control program, including preheat and interpass temperature monitoring, and NDT after surfacing. Finally, document the process and track the repair cycle time, so that you can demonstrate the cost savings to management.

In summary, the short-process surfacing repair of rolls is a proven technique that can significantly reduce downtime and cost. The literature is correct in its claims, but it does not mention the practical challenges of environment control, consumable selection, and operator training. These are the details that determine success or failure on the shop floor, and I have learned them through years of experience. I hope this note helps fellow engineers implement the technique successfully.