ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

The Relationship Between Welding and Surfacing: A Veteran's Interpretation

1. Literature Overview and Core Concept

The 2017 note in Manufacturing Technology & Machine Tool addresses the fundamental relationship between welding and surfacing. The abstract states that welding is a joining process that uses heat from a flame, laser, or arc to melt the materials being connected, achieving atomic bonding between them. It also notes that welding has two functions: joining and surface creation. This is a subtle but important distinction. Welding is primarily a joining process, but the same physical principles can be used to create a surface layer on a component — this is what we call surfacing.

From my perspective, the distinction between welding and surfacing is not always clear to engineers who have not spent time on the shop floor. Welding is about making two components into one; surfacing is about adding material to a single component to improve its surface properties. The processes are similar — both use an arc, a filler material, and a molten pool — but the objectives are different. In welding, the goal is to achieve a sound joint with full penetration and minimal defects. In surfacing, the goal is to achieve a deposit with specific properties, such as hardness, wear resistance, or corrosion resistance, while maintaining the integrity of the substrate.

2. Technical Comparison of Welding and Surfacing

The following table compares the key technical aspects of welding and surfacing, based on my experience in both fields.

Aspect Welding Surfacing
Primary objective Join two or more components into a single structure. Add a layer of material to a single component to improve surface properties.
Heat input Usually high, to achieve full penetration and fusion. Usually lower, to minimise dilution and distortion of the substrate.
Filler material Selected to match the base metal composition and mechanical properties. Selected to achieve the desired surface properties, which may differ from the base metal.
Dilution High, typically 20–50% of the weld metal is base metal. Low, typically 5–20%, to preserve the properties of the deposit.
Defect tolerance Welds are often designed to be defect-free, with NDT required. Surfacing layers may tolerate small defects, but NDT is still required for critical applications.
Post-weld treatment Stress relief, PWHT, or NDT as required by code. Often requires grinding or machining to achieve the final dimension.
Typical applications Pipes, pressure vessels, structural steel, ship hulls. Rolls, mill liners, valve seats, hydrogenation reactor walls.

The key difference is dilution. In welding, dilution is generally acceptable because the weld metal is designed to be compatible with the base metal. In surfacing, dilution must be controlled carefully because it can change the composition of the deposit and degrade its properties. For example, if you are surfacing a low-alloy steel with a high-chromium stainless steel, a high dilution rate will increase the carbon content of the deposit, which can cause chromium carbide precipitation and reduce corrosion resistance. This is a classic problem in the repair of hydrogenation reactors, where the stainless steel overlay must be applied with low dilution to maintain its corrosion resistance.

3. Process Selection Criteria for Surfacing

The choice of surfacing process depends on several factors, including the size and shape of the component, the required deposit thickness, the desired properties, and the production volume. The following table summarises the main surfacing processes and their typical applications.

Process Deposit Thickness Dilution Rate Typical Applications
Submerged arc welding (SAW) 3–10 mm 10–30% Large rolls, pressure vessel cladding.
Flux-cored arc welding (FCAW) 2–6 mm 15–25% Rolls, shafts, wear plates.
Gas metal arc welding (GMAW) 1–4 mm 10–20% Smaller components, precision repairs.
Plasma transferred arc (PTA) 1–5 mm 5–10% Valve seats, turbine blades, precision parts.
Laser cladding 0.5–3 mm 2–5% Precision components, high-value parts.
Cold welding (electrical spark) 0.1–2 mm <5% Surface defect repair, precision components.

In my experience, the selection of the surfacing process is often driven by economics rather than by technical considerations. For a large roll that needs a 5 mm thick deposit, SAW is the most economical choice because it has a high deposition rate. For a small valve seat that needs a 1 mm thick deposit with minimal dilution, PTA or laser cladding is the better choice, even though the equipment cost is higher. The literature does not discuss this economic dimension, but it is crucial in practice.

4. Common Defects and Countermeasures in Surfacing

Surfacing is subject to many of the same defects as welding, but the consequences can be different. The following table lists the defects I have encountered in surfacing operations and the countermeasures that have worked for me.

Defect Root Cause Countermeasure
Cracking in deposit High hardness of the deposit, hydrogen contamination, insufficient preheat. Use low-hydrogen consumables; preheat the substrate; reduce the hardness of the deposit.
Porosity Contaminated surface, moisture in the flux or wire. Clean the surface thoroughly; dry the consumables; use shielding gas if required.
Lack of fusion Low current, high travel speed, incorrect torch angle. Increase current; reduce travel speed; adjust torch angle.
Excessive dilution High current, low travel speed, wrong polarity. Reduce current; increase travel speed; use a lower dilution process such as PTA.
Spalling or delamination Poor surface preparation, oxide layer not removed, high residual stress. Grit-blast the surface; preheat; use a buffer layer of ductile material.

One of the most important lessons I have learned is that the transition from welding to surfacing is not always smooth. An operator who is skilled in welding may not be skilled in surfacing, because the technique is different. In welding, you are trying to achieve full penetration; in surfacing, you are trying to achieve a uniform deposit with minimal dilution. The operator must understand the difference and adjust the parameters accordingly. I have seen many surfacing jobs fail because the operator used welding parameters that were too aggressive, resulting in excessive dilution and poor deposit properties.

5. Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned

In the steel pipe industry, surfacing is used extensively for the repair of forming rolls, the cladding of pressure vessel components, and the hardfacing of valve seats. One of the most critical applications is the cladding of hydrogenation reactors, where a stainless steel layer is applied to the inside of a low-alloy steel vessel to protect it from hydrogen attack and corrosion. This application requires careful control of dilution, because the carbon in the base metal can migrate into the stainless steel deposit and cause chromium carbide precipitation, which reduces corrosion resistance.

I have seen a hydrogenation reactor fail in service because the cladding had excessive dilution. The deposit was supposed to be 25% chromium, but the dilution rate was so high that the actual chromium content was only 18%. The reactor had to be taken out of service and re-clad, at a cost of several million dollars. The root cause was that the welding parameters were not properly qualified, and the operator had used a high current to increase the deposition rate. The lesson is clear: in surfacing, the deposition rate must never be prioritised over the deposit quality.

6. Study Insights and Practical Implications

The 2017 note is a useful introduction to the relationship between welding and surfacing, but it is too brief to provide the depth that engineers need. The key insight is that welding and surfacing are based on the same physical principles, but they have different objectives and require different parameter control. Engineers who understand this distinction are better equipped to select the right process, the right consumables, and the right parameters for a given application.

For fellow engineers, I would recommend the following. First, always qualify the surfacing procedure on a sample that is representative of the actual component, including the same base material, heat treatment condition, and surface finish. Second, measure the dilution rate and verify that it is within the specified range. Third, use NDT after surfacing, especially for critical applications such as pressure vessels and reactor cladding. Fourth, document the process thoroughly, including the parameters, the consumables, and the inspection results. Finally, never compromise the deposit quality for the sake of deposition rate. The cost of a failed surfacing job is far higher than the cost of a slower process.

In summary, welding and surfacing are closely related but distinct processes. Welding is about joining; surfacing is about creating a surface with specific properties. The literature is correct in its claims, but it does not emphasise the importance of dilution control, which is the single most critical factor in surfacing quality. I have learned this through years of experience, and I hope this note helps fellow engineers avoid the mistakes I made.