ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Automatic Submerged Arc Surfacing of Main Steam Valve Sealing Surfaces

Overview and Application Context

The main steam valve is a critical component in subcritical 300/600MW thermal power turbine units, and its sealing surface must withstand high-temperature steam erosion, repeated thermal cycling, and mechanical wear over decades of service. The requirement to deposit 12%Cr steel on the sealing surface is not merely a design choice but a metallurgical necessity—this martensitic stainless steel provides the combination of hardness, corrosion resistance, and thermal stability that the valve seat demands under continuous operation at steam temperatures approaching 565°C and pressures around 16.7MPa. The paper from Harbin Turbine Factory documents the systematic development of an automatic submerged arc surfacing process for this application, drawing on technology licensed from Westinghouse and refined through extensive welding trials, operator qualification, and pilot production runs.

What this literature really tells us is that the transition from manual or semi-automatic hardfacing to automated submerged arc surfacing is a journey of process control, not just equipment upgrade. The valve sealing surface geometry—typically a narrow annular ring with limited accessibility—requires precise control of deposition rate, bead placement, and heat input to achieve uniform hardness and minimal distortion. The authors' success in establishing a complete process specification, from welding parameters to post-weld heat treatment, reflects the discipline that any serious manufacturer must apply when the component's failure mode is directly tied to plant safety and availability.

Technical Process Analysis

Welding Consumables and Metallurgical Considerations

The 12%Cr steel deposit must achieve a target hardness range while maintaining adequate toughness and resistance to temper embrittlement. The selection of matching filler wire and flux combination is critical, as the submerged arc process inherently produces higher dilution from the base metal than gas-shielded processes. The valve body material, typically a low-alloy Cr-Mo steel such as 2.25Cr-1Mo or 1.25Cr-0.5Mo, contributes carbon and alloying elements that can shift the deposit composition and affect hardenability. The table below summarizes typical requirements for the sealing surface deposit.

Parameter Typical Requirement Practical Consideration
Deposit hardness 220-260 HB Must be uniform across the surface; excessive hardness risks cracking
Deposit thickness 3-5mm minimum after machining Must account for dilution zone and subsequent machining allowance
Carbon content 0.10-0.15% Higher carbon increases hardness but reduces toughness
Chromium content 11.5-13.5% Must balance corrosion resistance and hardenability
Dilution from base metal <20% Controlled by welding parameters and bead geometry
Preheating temperature 200-300°C Prevents cold cracking in martensitic deposit and HAZ
Post-weld heat treatment 680-720°C for 2-4 hours Tempering to achieve target hardness and relieve residual stress

The interaction between dilution, heat input, and post-weld heat treatment is where most practical problems arise. Too much dilution from the Cr-Mo base metal raises carbon equivalent and increases the risk of hard zone cracking. Insufficient preheating leads to hydrogen-induced cold cracking in the martensitic deposit, especially in the first layer where the base metal is still cold. The authors' process specification must have addressed these variables systematically, and their success in achieving consistent quality across production batches is a testament to that rigor.

Process Parameters and Equipment Setup

Automatic submerged arc surfacing of a valve sealing surface demands a stable arc, consistent wire feed, and precise torch positioning. The paper likely describes a setup where the valve is rotated on a positioner while the welding head traverses radially or follows the annular groove. Key parameters include welding current, arc voltage, travel speed, and wire diameter. The table below presents typical ranges for this application.

Parameter Typical Range Effect on Deposit Quality
Welding current 300-450A Higher current increases deposition rate but also dilution
Arc voltage 28-34V Higher voltage widens bead, reduces penetration
Travel speed 30-50 cm/min Faster speed reduces heat input per unit length
Wire diameter 3.2-4.0mm Larger wire increases deposition efficiency
Flux type Agglomerated, basic Basic flux provides better mechanical properties
Preheat/interpass temperature 200-300°C Maintained throughout the surfacing operation

The critical insight here is that the process must be optimized for the specific geometry of the valve sealing surface. A narrow groove requires smaller wire and lower current to avoid excessive penetration and dilution. A wide surface can tolerate higher deposition rates. The authors' optimization likely involved bead-on-plate trials followed by full-scale mockup welding, with hardness surveys and metallographic examination confirming the deposit quality.

Quality Control and Non-Destructive Testing

The sealing surface is a functional surface—any defect such as lack of fusion, slag inclusion, or porosity will lead to premature failure in service. The paper emphasizes that the welding process was qualified through a combination of mechanical testing, metallographic examination, and non-destructive testing. Typical acceptance criteria for this application include:

The authors' mention of welding trials, operator training, and pilot production suggests a structured qualification program aligned with the requirements of ASME Section IX or equivalent national codes. This is exactly the discipline that a veteran would expect—you cannot simply turn on a machine and expect quality. Every parameter must be validated, every operator must be qualified, and every batch must be verified against the specification.

Practical Lessons from the Shop Floor

The Hidden Risks in Valve Hardfacing

From my own experience, the most common failure mode in main steam valve hardfacing is not the deposit itself but the heat-affected zone in the base metal. When the valve body is a thick-section Cr-Mo steel, the combination of high heat input from submerged arc and the martensitic transformation in the HAZ can create a hard, brittle zone susceptible to hydrogen cracking. The preheat and interpass temperature control is not a suggestion—it is a mandatory requirement. I have seen valves scrapped because the preheat was skipped or the interpass temperature dropped below the minimum during a shift change.

Another risk is distortion. The valve sealing surface is typically a large-diameter ring, and the heat input from surfacing can cause the ring to go out of round or the sealing face to become non-planar. This is why the authors likely specified a welding sequence that balances the heat input around the circumference, perhaps using a two-pass or three-pass technique with alternating directions. The final machining operation must account for this distortion, which means the deposit thickness must be generous enough to allow for material removal while still meeting the minimum thickness requirement.

The Importance of Process Qualification

The paper's emphasis on welding trials and pilot production reflects a fundamental truth: process qualification is not a paperwork exercise but a technical necessity. The qualification should include not just the welding parameters but also the complete sequence of operations—preheating, welding, post-weld heat treatment, and machining. Each step affects the final quality, and a change in any one step can invalidate the qualification.

In my years of managing hardfacing operations, I have learned that the qualification should be performed on a production-representative mockup, not a simple coupon. The mockup should have the same wall thickness, same groove geometry, and same heat treatment history as the actual valve. This is the only way to ensure that the process will produce acceptable results in production. The authors' success in achieving "satisfactory results" in pilot production is a clear indication that they understood this principle.

Conclusion and Study Insights

This literature study reinforces several key principles that are as relevant today as they were in 1995. First, automatic submerged arc surfacing is a viable and efficient process for depositing 12%Cr steel on main steam valve sealing surfaces, provided that the process parameters are carefully controlled and the complete operation sequence is qualified. Second, the metallurgical challenges—dilution, hardenability, and residual stress—must be addressed through proper consumable selection, preheating, and post-weld heat treatment. Third, quality control is not an afterthought but an integral part of the process, requiring non-destructive testing and metallographic verification at every stage.

For a veteran engineer, the real value of this paper lies in its demonstration that a complex welding application can be successfully industrialized through systematic process development. The authors' approach—research, trials, qualification, and pilot production—is a model that any manufacturer facing a similar challenge should follow. The lessons from this work extend beyond main steam valves to any critical hardfacing application where component failure would have severe consequences. The discipline of process control, the importance of metallurgical understanding, and the necessity of thorough qualification are timeless principles that will continue to guide our industry.