ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Tubular Wire Submerged Arc Surfacing for Nonwoven Hot Rolls

Process Overview and Industry Context

When I first saw this 1998 paper from the Shanghai Textile Machinery Research Institute, I had to smile. The authors were proposing something we in the steel pipe and roll manufacturing world had been doing for decades, and they were applying it to a sector that desperately needed it. The nonwoven fabric industry uses large heated rolls to bond and calendar nonwoven webs, and those rolls take a beating. Surface wear, scoring, and thermal fatigue are constant problems, and the traditional answer was to buy new rolls or send them out for expensive grinding and re-chroming.

The paper argues that tubular wire submerged arc surfacing, a mature technology in steel and roll manufacturing, can be applied to repair and even manufacture these hot rolls. The logic is sound. Tubular wire, sometimes called flux-cored wire, combines the advantages of solid wire and coated electrodes. The flux inside the tube provides alloying elements, deoxidizers, and slag formers, while the outer steel sheath melts and deposits as the weld metal. In submerged arc surfacing, the arc is buried under a blanket of granular flux, which protects the molten pool from atmospheric contamination, slows cooling, and produces a smooth, dense deposit.

Technical Parameters and Process Windows

From my years running hardfacing lines, I can tell you that the success of this process depends on getting several variables right simultaneously. The paper touches on this, but let me expand from practical experience.

Parameter Typical Range Practical Notes
Welding current 300–600 A Higher current increases deposition rate but also dilution
Arc voltage 28–36 V Too low gives poor fusion; too high gives excessive flux consumption
Travel speed 20–40 cm/min Must match current to control bead width and build-up
Wire diameter 2.4–4.0 mm Larger wire for higher deposition rates
Flux type Agglomerated or fused Agglomerated fluxes allow more alloy transfer
Preheat temperature 100–250 °C Critical for thick rolls to prevent cracking
Interpass temperature 200–300 °C Must be controlled to maintain hardness and prevent distortion
Dilution 10–30% Lower dilution preserves the hardfacing alloy composition

The key insight that the paper correctly identifies is that dilution is the enemy. When you deposit a hardfacing alloy onto a carbon steel roll, the base metal melts and mixes with the deposit. If dilution is too high, the hardfacing alloy becomes diluted with soft steel, and you lose hardness and wear resistance. The trick is to use multiple passes, with the first pass acting as a buffer layer, and to keep the current and travel speed balanced so that penetration is shallow but fusion is sound.

Practical Application and Economics

The authors make a strong economic case, and I agree with them. A new hot roll for a nonwoven line can cost tens of thousands of dollars, and delivery times can stretch for months. Repair by submerged arc surfacing, followed by machining and grinding, can be done in a fraction of the time and at a fraction of the cost. I have seen this work on steel mill rolls, and the same principles apply.

However, there are practical pitfalls that the paper does not fully address. First, the roll surface must be properly prepared. Any cracks, fatigue damage, or contamination must be removed by machining before surfacing. Second, the roll must be rotated during welding to maintain a uniform deposit. This requires a roll turning lathe or a positioner, which not every shop has. Third, the heat input must be carefully controlled to prevent distortion. A long roll, say 2–3 meters, will bow if you put too much heat on one side. The answer is to weld in a sequence that balances the heat, often using two welding heads on opposite sides, or by welding alternating bands.

Quality Control and Lessons Learned

I have seen hardfaced rolls fail in service because the deposit cracked. The usual causes are high hardness combined with high residual stress, or a hardfacing alloy that is too brittle for the thermal cycling the roll experiences. The paper mentions that the process can improve quality and extend service life, but it does not discuss the need for post-weld heat treatment or stress relief.

From my experience, I would recommend the following:

  1. Always preheat the roll, especially if it is large or if the hardfacing alloy has high carbon content.
  2. Control the interpass temperature. If it gets too hot, the deposit will be soft; if it gets too cold, you risk cracking.
  3. Use a buffer layer of a softer, more ductile alloy before applying the hard wear-resistant alloy. This reduces the thermal and mechanical mismatch between the base metal and the hardfacing.
  4. After welding, perform a stress relief treatment, typically at 550–650 °C, followed by slow cooling.
  5. Inspect the deposit using magnetic particle or ultrasonic testing to detect cracks or lack of fusion.
  6. Machine the deposit with carbide tooling, and be prepared for a slow, expensive machining process. Hardfacing alloys are designed to resist wear, and they will resist your cutting tools too.

Study Insights and Implications

This paper is a good example of technology transfer from one industry to another. The nonwoven industry, like many others, often reinvents the wheel when it could borrow proven solutions from steel, mining, or cement industries. The authors deserve credit for making the connection.

For engineers in the steel pipe and fitting world, this paper is a reminder that hardfacing is not just for rolls and mill parts. We use hardfacing on pipe fittings, particularly on elbows and tees in abrasive service, and on the sealing surfaces of valves. The same principles of dilution control, preheat, and stress relief apply. If you are specifying hardfaced components, you need to understand the process limitations and the quality control requirements.

In summary, this paper is a practical, if brief, introduction to applying tubular wire submerged arc surfacing to nonwoven hot rolls. It correctly identifies the economic and quality benefits, but it leaves out the process details that determine success or failure. Those details are exactly where the experienced engineer earns their keep. The process is proven, the economics are sound, and the technology is available. The challenge is in the execution, and that is where I would focus my attention.