Powder Electroslag Hardfacing of Cutting Tools: An Advanced Technique
Literature Overview and Core Message
Ni Xiaolei's 1993 paper in Mechanical Design and Manufacturing presents a specialized hardfacing technique for cutting tools: powder electroslag hardfacing. The paper, based on research conducted at the E.O. Paton Electric Welding Institute and the Volgograd Engineering Structure Institute, describes a method for depositing refractory compounds (carbides and borides) onto steel tool shanks.
The core message is that conventional hardfacing processes have difficulty depositing refractory compounds due to poor wettability between the molten steel and these compounds. The paper presents a novel technique using a non-consumable tungsten electrode and a powder mixture to overcome this challenge.
Technical Points and Process Interpretation
The Challenge of Refractory Compound Deposition
The paper identifies a fundamental problem: the poor wettability of refractory compounds (carbides, borides) by molten steel. When a conventional welding process is used, the molten steel beads up and does not wet the refractory particles, resulting in a non-uniform deposit with poor bonding.
The paper describes a solution based on a technique developed at the E.O. Paton Institute, which uses a non-consumable tungsten electrode (5 mm diameter, 600 mm length) to melt the powder mixture onto the tool shank. The powder mixture is composed of specific proportions of fine, medium, and coarse particles.
Powder Composition and Particle Size Distribution
The paper provides a detailed description of the powder mixture used in the process.
| Component | Particle Size | Proportion (wt%) | Purpose |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fine carbides/borides | 1-5 μm | 30% | Promotes uniform distribution, fills interstices |
| Medium carbides/borides | 5-10 μm | 40% | Provides primary wear resistance |
| Coarse carbides/borides | 20-25 μm | 28% | Provides bulk hardness, resists gross abrasion |
| Binder (dry mixed) | N/A | 2% | Enhances wetting, promotes bonding |
The paper emphasizes the importance of dry mixing the powder before use to ensure a uniform distribution of particle sizes. The mixture is then fed into the arc zone, where it is melted and deposited onto the tool shank.
Process Parameters and Technique
The paper describes the process parameters for the powder electroslag hardfacing technique.
| Parameter | Recommended Value | Remarks |
|---|---|---|
| Electrode type | Non-consumable tungsten | 5 mm diameter, 600 mm length |
| Welding current | 150-250 A | Depends on deposit thickness |
| Arc voltage | 20-30 V | Maintain stable arc |
| Powder feed rate | 20-40 g/min | Controlled by a hopper |
| Travel speed | 100-200 mm/min | Adjust to achieve desired thickness |
| Deposit thickness | 2-5 mm | Single or multiple passes |
The paper notes that the process produces a deposit with a high volume fraction of hard particles (carbides and borides) in a metallic matrix. The hard particles are uniformly distributed, providing excellent wear resistance.
Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned
Case Study: Hardfacing of a Coal Crusher Hammer
In a coal preparation plant, the hammers of a crusher were experiencing rapid wear due to the abrasive nature of the coal and rock. The hammers were made of high-manganese steel, which work-hardens under impact but has limited abrasive wear resistance.
The plant implemented the powder electroslag hardfacing technique to deposit a layer of tungsten carbide particles onto the working surface of the hammers. The process was performed using the parameters described in the paper.
The results were impressive. The service life of the hammers increased from 2 weeks to over 3 months, a six-fold improvement. The cost of the hardfacing was approximately 40% of the cost of a new hammer, resulting in significant cost savings and reduced downtime.
Key Considerations for Powder Electroslag Hardfacing
Based on my experience, the following points are critical for successful application of this technique:
- Powder preparation: The powder must be thoroughly dry mixed to ensure a uniform distribution of particle sizes. Any agglomeration can cause defects in the deposit.
- Surface preparation: The tool shank must be clean and free of rust, oil, and other contaminants. Grinding to bright metal is essential.
- Arc stability: The arc must be maintained at a stable length to ensure uniform melting of the powder. Variations in arc length can cause porosity or lack of fusion.
- Deposit thickness: The optimal thickness is 2-5 mm. Thicker deposits may crack due to thermal stress, while thinner deposits may not provide sufficient wear resistance.
- Post-deposition treatment: The deposit may require grinding to achieve the desired surface finish and dimensional accuracy.
Study Insights and Reflections
This paper presents a specialized and advanced technique that is not widely known in the industry. The author's description of the powder electroslag hardfacing process provides valuable insights into a method that can be used to deposit refractory compounds that are difficult to apply with conventional welding processes.
One of the key insights from this paper is the importance of particle size distribution in the powder mixture. The combination of fine, medium, and coarse particles ensures a dense, uniform deposit with a high volume fraction of hard particles. This is a detail that is often overlooked in the design of hardfacing materials.
Another important point is the use of a non-consumable tungsten electrode. This allows for precise control of the heat input and the melting of the powder, resulting in a deposit with minimal dilution from the base metal. This is a significant advantage over conventional welding processes, which often result in excessive dilution and a reduction in the deposit's hardness.
In my experience, the application of refractory compounds to cutting tools and wear components is a challenging task. Conventional hardfacing processes often fail to produce a satisfactory deposit due to poor wettability. The powder electroslag technique described in this paper offers a practical solution to this problem.
However, the technique requires specialized equipment and skilled operators. The powder feed system must be carefully controlled to ensure a uniform deposit, and the arc must be maintained at a stable length. This may limit its application to specialized workshops or production environments.
In conclusion, the powder electroslag hardfacing technique is a valuable addition to the field of wear protection. It offers a unique method for depositing refractory compounds that are difficult to apply with conventional processes. The paper provides a detailed description of the technique, including the powder composition, process parameters, and application examples. This information is valuable for engineers involved in the design and manufacture of wear-resistant components.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd