Surfacing Welding of Sintering Blower Fan Blades
Literature Overview and Practical Context
The 1989 paper by Zhao Jiancang on surfacing welding of sintering blower fan blades addresses a problem that is still with us today: the rapid erosive wear of fan blades handling sinter off-gas. In a sintering plant, the blower fan is the heart of the system, pulling combustion gases through the sinter bed, and the dust-laden gas stream at high velocity and elevated temperature acts like a sandblaster on the blade surfaces. The paper, published in Fan Technology (风机技术), describes a surfacing approach that extends blade life, and the practical value of this work lies not in the novelty of the process but in the systematic selection of a wear-resistant alloy and the disciplined execution of the welding procedure. From my own experience with sinter plant fans in China and Southeast Asia, I can tell you that a fan blade failure is not a small event: it means a full plant stop, an expensive outage, and the loss of production measured in days, not hours. The economic argument for surfacing rather than replacing blades is straightforward when the fan is large and the downtime cost is high, but the technical argument requires careful consideration of the wear mechanism, the base metal, and the practical constraints of on-site or in-shop repair.
Core Technical Points
Wear Mechanism and Alloy Selection
The fundamental issue in a sintering blower fan is erosion by abrasive particles, primarily iron ore fines, coke breeze, and returned sinter fines, at gas velocities that can exceed 60 m/s. The wear pattern on a fan blade is not uniform: the leading edge and the tip region suffer the highest impact angle, while the blade face experiences more of a sliding abrasion. This is critical because the optimal alloy for high-impact erosion is not the same as the optimal alloy for sliding abrasion. The paper describes a surfacing alloy that balances hardness with toughness, and this is exactly where many shop floor attempts fail. A very hard alloy with high carbide content will resist sliding abrasion but will chip and spall under high-angle impact, and the spalled particles then accelerate the erosion of the adjacent surface. The practical approach, which I have seen work well, is to use a martensitic or martensitic-carbide alloy with a hardness in the range of HRC 50 to 58, which provides a good compromise between wear resistance and impact toughness for the mixed wear regime typical of sinter gas streams.
Surfacing Process and Procedure
The paper focuses on manual metal arc welding (SMAW) with a hardfacing electrode, which is the most practical method for field repair and for blades that cannot be easily rotated. The key process parameters that determine success are:
| Parameter | Practical Range | Comment |
|---|---|---|
| Preheating temperature | 150 to 250 °C | Reduces cracking risk in the HAZ and in the deposit |
| Interpass temperature | 250 to 300 °C maximum | Prevents overheating and loss of alloying elements |
| Welding current | 120 to 180 A for a 4 mm electrode | Depends on electrode diameter and position |
| Arc voltage | 22 to 28 V | Keep short arc to minimize dilution |
| Travel speed | 15 to 25 cm/min | Avoid excessive heat input |
| Bead overlap | 40 to 50 % of bead width | Ensures uniform deposit and minimizes dilution |
| Number of layers | 2 to 3 layers | First layer dilutes with base metal, subsequent layers reach target hardness |
The dilution issue is the most common cause of field failure. The first layer of surfacing will typically have 20 to 30 % dilution from the base metal, which can drop the hardness by 10 to 15 HRC points. If the welder only applies one layer, the effective wear resistance is significantly lower than the electrode datasheet suggests. The paper correctly implies that a minimum of two layers is required, and in practice I have specified three layers for critical fan blades where the base metal is a low-alloy steel with a high carbon equivalent. The dilution also affects the carbon and alloy content: if the base metal is a plain carbon steel with 0.20 % carbon, the first layer will pick up carbon and increase hardness, but if the base metal is a low-alloy steel, the first layer may crack due to the combination of dilution and residual stress.
Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned
Case Study: Sinter Plant Fan Blade Repair in a Chinese Steel Plant
In a project I was involved with in the early 2000s, a sintering blower fan with blades made of 16Mn steel was failing every three to four months due to erosion. The plant had tried replacing the blades with a higher-grade steel, but the cost of the blade set and the downtime for installation was prohibitive. We specified a surfacing procedure using a martensitic hardfacing electrode with a nominal hardness of HRC 55, applied in three layers on the leading edge and two layers on the blade face. The preheating was done with a gas torch to 200 °C, and the interpass temperature was controlled with a contact pyrometer. The critical detail was the bead sequence: we applied the first layer with a weaving technique to ensure complete fusion with the base metal, then the second and third layers with a straight stringer bead technique to minimize dilution and maximize deposit efficiency. The fan ran for over fourteen months before the next repair, and the wear pattern was uniform, indicating that the surfacing layer was performing as designed. The lesson was not that the electrode was special, but that the procedure was disciplined.
Common Defects and Countermeasures
The paper, being from 1989, does not discuss modern NDT methods, but the defects that occur in surfacing welding are timeless. The most common problems I have encountered are:
- Cracking in the deposit: This is usually caused by insufficient preheating, excessive hardness in the first layer, or a base metal with a high carbon equivalent. The countermeasure is to increase preheating to 200 to 250 °C, use a more ductile first layer, and apply the hardfacing in a buttering technique.
- Spalling at the edge of the deposit: This occurs when the bead overlap is too small, creating a notch effect at the toe of the weld. The countermeasure is to increase the overlap to at least 40 % and to grind the toes smooth after welding.
- Porosity: This is usually caused by moisture in the electrode, or by welding over rust or oil. The countermeasure is to bake the electrodes at 300 to 350 °C for one hour and to clean the blade surface with grinding before welding.
- Distortion of the blade: This is a serious problem for large fan blades, because the blade profile directly affects the fan efficiency. The countermeasure is to use a balanced welding sequence, welding alternate beads on opposite sides of the blade, and to limit the interpass temperature.
Quality Control and Inspection
For a surfacing application, the quality control requirements are different from those for a structural weld. The key checks are:
| Inspection Method | Acceptance Criteria | Practical Note |
|---|---|---|
| Visual inspection | No cracks, no spalling, uniform bead profile | Use a magnifying glass for edge inspection |
| Hardness testing | HRC 50 to 58 on the final layer | Test at three points per blade, at least 2 mm below the surface |
| Dye penetrant testing | No linear indications | Essential for detecting surface cracks that will propagate in service |
| Ultrasonic testing | No lack of fusion in the deposit | Useful for thick deposits, but less common for thin blades |
| Dimensional check | Blade profile within 2 mm of original | Critical for maintaining fan efficiency |
The hardness testing is the most important acceptance criterion, but it must be done correctly. A portable hardness tester with a Leeb probe is the standard tool, but the reading is affected by the surface condition and the mass of the blade. For thin blades, the hardness reading can be artificially high due to the backing effect, so I have always specified that the hardness test be performed on a sample piece welded with the same procedure, rather than on the blade itself. This is a detail that many quality plans miss, and it has caused more than one dispute between the fabricator and the client.
Study Insights and Reflections
Reading this paper again, with the benefit of thirty years of experience, I am struck by how much of the practical wisdom is embedded in the process parameters rather than in the alloy selection. The alloy is important, but the real determinant of success is the discipline of the welder and the supervision of the procedure. I have seen a good electrode fail because the welder applied a single layer, and I have seen a mediocre electrode perform well because the welder followed a strict three-layer procedure with proper preheating. The paper's contribution is to document a practical approach that works, and the lesson for the modern engineer is that surfacing welding is not a "weld and forget" operation. It requires a procedure qualification, a welder qualification, and a quality control plan that addresses the specific wear mechanism. For the sintering plant engineer, the message is clear: if you are going to extend the life of your fan blades by surfacing, you need to understand the wear mechanism, select the alloy accordingly, and then enforce the procedure with the same rigor as you would for a pressure-retaining weld. The payoff is measured in months of additional service life, which translates directly into plant availability and profitability.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd