Wear Mechanism of Exhaust Fan Impellers and Anti-Wear Hardfacing
Literature Overview
Peng Zhenwei, Liu Yongsheng, Wang Li, and Wang Zongyu, writing in the Journal of Jiamusi University in 1999, analysed the wear mechanism of exhaust fan impellers in power generation plants and proposed a hardfacing solution using a special tungsten carbide electrode, designated as Te Wei 707. The paper identifies the wear mechanism as a ploughing or gouging type, caused by the impact of quartz and feldspar particles present in the low-quality coal used in the plant. The authors then describe a specific hardfacing procedure using the tungsten carbide electrode.
This paper is a classic example of a practical investigation into a specific wear problem, followed by a targeted solution. I have seen many such problems in my career, and the approach taken by the authors is exactly what I would have done: identify the wear mechanism, characterise the abrasive, select a consumable that matches the mechanism, and develop a procedure that can be applied in the field.
Core Technical Points and Interpretation
The Wear Mechanism
The paper identifies the wear mechanism as ploughing, caused by the impact of hard abrasive particles. The particles, primarily quartz and feldspar, are present in the coal and are carried through the fan at high velocity. The impeller blades are subjected to a combination of erosion and impact, resulting in a characteristic surface pattern of grooves or gouges.
| Wear Type | Mechanism | Typical Appearance |
|---|---|---|
| Ploughing | Hard particle cuts a groove | Deep, narrow grooves |
| Erosion | Particle impact removes material | Smooth, rounded surface |
| Impact | High-energy particle breaks material | Craters and cracks |
| Abrasion | Particle slides across surface | Polished or scratched surface |
The paper correctly identifies that the wear is not uniform across the impeller. The leading edge of the blade experiences the most severe wear, because it is the first to encounter the particle stream. The trailing edge and the root of the blade experience less wear. This information is critical for determining the extent of the hardfacing.
The Tungsten Carbide Electrode
The Te Wei 707 electrode is a tungsten carbide type, which is designed for extreme abrasive wear resistance. The tungsten carbide particles are embedded in a steel matrix, and the hardfacing deposit has a hardness in the range of 60 to 65 HRC. This is significantly harder than the base metal of the impeller, which is typically a low-carbon steel.
| Consumable | Hardness (HRC) | Wear Resistance | Impact Resistance |
|---|---|---|---|
| Te Wei 707 (WC) | 60-65 | Excellent | Poor |
| Martensitic stainless | 45-55 | Good | Good |
| Austenitic manganese | 20-30 | Fair | Excellent |
| Nickel-based alloy | 40-50 | Good | Fair |
The paper notes that the tungsten carbide electrode is not suitable for applications where impact is severe, because the carbide particles are brittle and can be fractured. However, in the exhaust fan impeller, the impact is relatively low, and the abrasive wear is dominant, so the tungsten carbide electrode is the right choice.
The Hardfacing Procedure
The paper describes a specific procedure for applying the hardfacing to the impeller blades. The key elements are:
| Procedure Step | Detail |
|---|---|
| Surface preparation | Grinding or machining to remove the worn layer |
| Preheating | 100-150 °C to reduce the risk of cracking |
| Welding process | Shielded metal arc welding (SMAW) |
| Electrode | Te Wei 707, 4 mm diameter |
| Current | 120-160 A, DC reverse polarity |
| Travel speed | Slow, to ensure adequate penetration |
| Interpass temperature | Keep below 200 °C |
| Post-weld treatment | Slow cooling, no stress relief required |
Integration with Engineering Practice
Why This Matters for the Pipe and Fitting Industry
Exhaust fan impellers are not directly related to pipe and fitting production, but the wear mechanism is identical to what we see in our own equipment. The fans that handle the flue gas from our reheating furnaces, the blowers that transport abrasive materials, and the pumps that handle slurries all suffer from the same type of abrasive wear. The hardfacing solution described in this paper is directly applicable to these applications.
The 5W2H Approach to Wear Problem Solving
| Question | Practical Answer |
|---|---|
| What is the problem? | Impeller blades wear out prematurely |
| Why does it happen? | Abrasive particles in the coal |
| Where does it occur? | Leading edge of the blades |
| When does it occur? | After a certain number of operating hours |
| Who is responsible? | The maintenance department |
| How to fix it? | Apply tungsten carbide hardfacing |
| How much will it cost? | Less than the cost of a new impeller |
Common Defects and Countermeasures
| Defect | Root Cause | Countermeasure |
|---|---|---|
| Cracking | High hardness, rapid cooling | Preheat, slow cooling |
| Spalling | Poor bonding | Ensure proper surface preparation |
| Distortion | Uneven heat input | Balance the welding sequence |
| Porosity | Contamination | Clean the surface thoroughly |
Key Questions and Reflections
The paper raises an important question: how much hardfacing is enough? The authors do not specify the thickness of the deposit, but in my experience, a deposit of 3 to 5 mm is typical for this type of application. A thinner deposit will wear through too quickly, while a thicker deposit will increase the risk of cracking and distortion.
Another reflection is on the economics. The cost of hardfacing an impeller is a fraction of the cost of a new impeller, and the hardfaced impeller will last longer. However, the hardfacing must be applied correctly. A poorly applied hardfacing will fail prematurely, and the cost of the failure will be higher than the cost of a new impeller.
Study Insights and Implications
The paper by Peng Zhenwei and colleagues is a valuable contribution to the practical literature on wear and hardfacing. It demonstrates a systematic approach to solving a specific wear problem: identify the mechanism, characterise the abrasive, select a consumable, and develop a procedure. This approach is applicable to a wide range of industrial wear problems.
For the pipe and fitting industry, the lessons are clear. We must understand the wear mechanism in our own equipment before we select a hardfacing consumable. A consumable that works well in one application may fail in another, because the wear mechanism is different.
Concluding Remarks
The paper is a classic example of practical engineering. The authors did not try to develop a new theory or a new material. They identified a specific problem, analysed it, and applied a known solution in a systematic way. The result was a hardfaced impeller that lasted significantly longer than the original. This is the essence of good engineering: understanding the problem, selecting the right tool, and applying it correctly. I would recommend this paper to any engineer who is faced with a similar wear problem, whether it is in a power plant, a cement plant, or a pipe mill.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd