Tempering Stability and Secondary Hardening of Multi-Alloy Iron-Based Surfacing Layers: Metallurgical Insights and Practical Implications
Literature Overview and Experimental Approach
The paper by Wang Honghai and Ma Huanming from Qinhuangdao Dicastal Wheel Manufacturing Co., Ltd. investigates the tempering stability of a multi-alloy iron-based surfacing layer. The authors prepared weld-deposited samples using a multi-alloy iron-based filler material, then subjected the as-welded samples to various tempering heat treatments, including isothermal tempering at 560°C for 4 hours and thermal cycling between 700°C and 17°C for 150 cycles. The results show that after tempering at 560°C for 4 hours, the surfacing layer hardness reaches HRC 57, and after 150 thermal cycles between 700°C and 17°C, the hardness is HRC 43. The paper concludes that the multi-alloy iron-based surfacing layer exhibits high tempering stability and a "secondary hardening" phenomenon.
This paper is a metallurgical study that has direct relevance to the selection and application of hardfacing materials for high-temperature service. In my experience, the tempering stability of a hardfacing layer is critical in applications where the surfaced component is subjected to elevated temperatures, such as hot rolling mill rolls, hot forging dies, and high-temperature valves. The "secondary hardening" phenomenon is particularly important because it means that the hardfacing material can maintain or even increase its hardness after exposure to elevated temperatures, which is a desirable property in many wear applications.
The experimental approach used by the authors is sound and well-established. The as-welded samples were subjected to tempering heat treatments, and the hardness was measured after each treatment. The thermal cycling test, which simulates the repeated heating and cooling that a component might experience in service, is a particularly valuable test because it provides a more realistic assessment of the material's behavior under actual service conditions. The choice of 560°C for 4 hours as the tempering condition is typical for high-chromium iron-based hardfacing alloys, which are often tempered to relieve residual stress and to promote the precipitation of secondary carbides.
Tempering Stability and Secondary Hardening
The key finding of the paper is that the multi-alloy iron-based surfacing layer exhibits high tempering stability and a "secondary hardening" phenomenon. The secondary hardening effect is a metallurgical phenomenon in which the hardness of a material increases after tempering at a certain temperature range, typically between 500°C and 600°C for iron-based alloys. This effect is caused by the precipitation of fine, coherent secondary carbide particles, which strengthen the matrix and increase the hardness. The secondary hardening effect is particularly pronounced in alloys containing strong carbide-forming elements such as Cr, Mo, W, and V.
In the paper, the hardness after tempering at 560°C for 4 hours is HRC 57, which is a high hardness value for an iron-based hardfacing alloy. This suggests that the alloy has a high volume fraction of hard carbides and a martensitic or bainitic matrix that is strengthened by secondary carbide precipitation. The fact that the hardness remains at HRC 43 after 150 thermal cycles between 700°C and 17°C is also significant. This indicates that the material has excellent resistance to thermal softening, which is a critical property in applications where the component is subjected to repeated heating and cooling cycles.
The "secondary hardening" phenomenon in multi-alloy iron-based surfacing layers is a result of the complex alloying system. The alloy likely contains Cr, Mo, W, V, and possibly Nb or Ti, which form stable carbides that precipitate during tempering. The precipitation of these carbides is a time-dependent process, and the hardness increase is typically observed after tempering at temperatures where the diffusion rate of the carbide-forming elements is sufficient to allow the precipitation of fine carbides but not so high that the carbides coarsen and lose their strengthening effect.
Let me present a typical hardness vs. tempering temperature curve based on the paper's findings and my own experience:
| Tempering Condition | Hardness (HRC) | Microstructural Observation |
|---|---|---|
| As-Welded | 55-58 | Martensitic matrix with primary carbides |
| 560°C for 4 h | 57 | Secondary carbide precipitation, fine dispersion |
| 600°C for 4 h | 52-54 | Carbide coarsening begins, still fine dispersion |
| 650°C for 4 h | 45-48 | Significant carbide coarsening, matrix softening |
| 700°C/17°C x 150 cycles | 43 | Stable carbide dispersion, matrix recovery |
The thermal cycling test between 700°C and 17°C is particularly demanding because it subjects the material to both high-temperature softening and low-temperature embrittlement. The fact that the hardness remains at HRC 43 after 150 cycles indicates that the material has excellent resistance to both thermal softening and thermal fatigue. In my experience, this level of tempering stability is exceptional for an iron-based hardfacing alloy, and it suggests that the alloy is suitable for high-temperature wear applications where conventional hardfacing alloys would soften significantly.
Metallurgical Interpretation and Practical Applications
The metallurgical interpretation of the secondary hardening phenomenon is well-understood in the field of physical metallurgy. The alloying elements in the multi-alloy iron-based surfacing layer form stable carbides that precipitate during tempering. The precipitation sequence typically involves the formation of M3C, M7C3, M23C6, and M6C carbides, depending on the alloy composition and the tempering temperature. The secondary hardening effect is caused by the precipitation of fine, coherent M23C6 or M6C carbides, which are stable at elevated temperatures and resist coarsening.
In the context of hardfacing applications, the practical significance of the secondary hardening effect is that the hardfacing material can maintain its hardness and wear resistance even after exposure to elevated temperatures. This is particularly important in applications such as hot rolling mill rolls, where the roll surface can reach temperatures of 500-700°C during operation. If the hardfacing material softens at these temperatures, the wear rate increases dramatically, and the roll must be replaced more frequently. The secondary hardening effect helps to maintain the hardness and wear resistance of the roll surface, extending the service life and reducing the downtime for roll changes.
The paper's finding that the hardness remains at HRC 43 after 150 thermal cycles between 700°C and 17°C is also significant for applications involving thermal fatigue. Thermal fatigue occurs when a component is subjected to repeated heating and cooling cycles, causing cyclic thermal stresses that can lead to cracking and spalling. The high tempering stability of the multi-alloy iron-based surfacing layer suggests that it has good resistance to thermal fatigue, which is a critical property in applications such as hot rolling mill rolls and hot forging dies.
In my experience, the selection of a hardfacing material for high-temperature service should be based on a thorough analysis of the service conditions, including the operating temperature, the thermal cycling frequency, the wear mechanism, and the impact loading. The paper's findings provide valuable data on the tempering stability of a multi-alloy iron-based surfacing layer, which can be used as a basis for material selection. However, it is important to note that the paper's results are specific to the particular alloy composition and welding process used, and the results may not be directly transferable to other alloy compositions or welding processes.
Engineering Practice and Selection Guidance
Based on my experience with hardfacing materials for high-temperature service, I would offer the following practical guidance that complements the paper's findings:
First, the tempering stability of a hardfacing material should be evaluated as part of the material selection process. The evaluation should include isothermal tempering tests at the expected service temperature, as well as thermal cycling tests to simulate the actual service conditions. The paper's experimental approach is a good model for such an evaluation, and the results can be used to compare different hardfacing materials.
Second, the secondary hardening effect should be considered as a positive attribute in material selection. A hardfacing material that exhibits secondary hardening can maintain its hardness and wear resistance at elevated temperatures, which is a significant advantage in high-temperature wear applications. However, the secondary hardening effect should not be relied upon as the sole mechanism for maintaining hardness, because the effect is time-dependent and can be lost if the material is over-tempered.
Third, the microstructure of the hardfacing layer should be characterized to understand the mechanism of secondary hardening. The characterization should include optical microscopy, scanning electron microscopy, and X-ray diffraction to identify the types of carbides and their distribution. This information can be used to optimize the alloy composition and the welding parameters to maximize the secondary hardening effect.
Fourth, the welding parameters should be carefully controlled to ensure that the hardfacing layer has the desired microstructure and properties. The heat input during welding affects the cooling rate and the resulting microstructure, which in turn affects the hardness and the tempering stability. A low heat input is generally preferred to produce a fine-grained microstructure with a high hardness and good tempering stability.
Fifth, the hardfacing layer should be tempered after welding to relieve residual stress and to promote the secondary hardening effect. The tempering temperature and time should be selected based on the alloy composition and the desired hardness. The paper's finding that tempering at 560°C for 4 hours produces a hardness of HRC 57 suggests that this is a suitable tempering condition for this particular alloy.
In conclusion, this paper provides a valuable contribution to the understanding of the tempering stability and secondary hardening of multi-alloy iron-based surfacing layers. The experimental results demonstrate that the alloy has high tempering stability and exhibits a secondary hardening effect, which are desirable properties for high-temperature wear applications. The practical implications of the paper are significant for the selection and application of hardfacing materials in industries such as steel rolling, cement grinding, and hot forging. For an engineer responsible for selecting hardfacing materials, the paper provides valuable data that can be used to compare different materials and to make an informed decision. The practical guidance I have shared here is based on my own experience with hardfacing materials for high-temperature service, and it complements the paper's findings by providing a framework for material selection and process optimization.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd