ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Repair Hardfacing of a Steam Calciner Retaining Wheel Shaft

1. Overview of the Literature

This paper from the 2010 issue of Soda Industry documents a practical repair case: a retaining wheel shaft on a steam calciner, made of 45 steel, had suffered local wear and needed to be brought back to service by hardfacing. The authors, from the repair and fabrication branch of Tangshan Sanyou Chemical, walked through the weldability analysis of 45 steel, selected a suitable filler and process window, and successfully restored the shaft. On the surface this is a small repair job, but the logic behind it is exactly the same logic we apply when we repair a worn pipe mill roller, a mandrel bar, or a heavy-duty shaft on a seamless piercing mill.

2. Why 45 Steel Is a Problem Child

45 steel is a medium-carbon structural steel with a carbon content of roughly 0.42 to 0.50 percent. That puts its carbon equivalent well above the threshold where we have to worry about cold cracking in the heat-affected zone. The hardenability is significant, and if we weld it without preheat, the HAZ will transform to martensite, which is hard, brittle and prone to hydrogen-induced cracking.

Parameter Typical value for 45 steel Practical concern
Carbon content 0.42 to 0.50 percent High hardenability, martensite formation in HAZ
Carbon equivalent (CE) Approximately 0.55 to 0.65 percent Cold cracking risk unless preheat is applied
Tensile strength 600 to 800 MPa High strength but poor weldability
Hardness after quenching 50 to 60 HRC HAZ can reach this level if uncontrolled
Preheat requirement 150 to 250 degrees Celsius Mandatory for sections above 20 mm

The key insight from the paper is that the repair was not a simple "fill the groove" exercise. The authors had to think about the thermal cycle, the restraint of the shaft, and the fact that the shaft is a rotating component that will see cyclic loading in service. A hard, cracked HAZ under a hardfacing layer is a fatigue crack waiting to propagate.

3. The Welding Process and Filler Selection

The paper describes a process that, in my experience, is the standard approach for this class of repair: manual metal arc welding with a low-hydrogen electrode, or in some cases a flux-cored wire. The authors chose to preheat the shaft, maintain interpass temperature, and apply the hardfacing in multiple passes with controlled heat input.

Process parameter Recommended window Rationale
Preheat temperature 200 to 250 degrees Celsius Reduces cooling rate, prevents martensite in HAZ
Interpass temperature 250 to 300 degrees Celsius Prevents hydrogen buildup, avoids over-tempering
Heat input 15 to 25 kJ/cm Balanced against dilution and HAZ softening
Electrode type Low-hydrogen, basic coating Minimizes diffusible hydrogen content
Post-weld treatment Stress relief at 550 to 600 degrees Celsius Reduces residual stress, tempers the HAZ

The filler selection matters a great deal. For a shaft that needs to be machined back to its original dimensions, we typically want a filler that gives a deposit hardness in the range of 25 to 35 HRC after machining, so that the surface can be turned or ground without excessive tool wear. If the shaft is a bearing journal, the surface must also have adequate fatigue strength, which means we cannot simply lay down a hard, brittle layer.

4. What the Shop Floor Actually Cares About

When I see a repair like this, the first question is not "what electrode do we use" but "what is the actual condition of the shaft before we start". The paper does not dwell on this, but in practice we always do the following:

  1. Clean the damaged area thoroughly, removing all oil, grease, rust and any previous hardfacing that may have cracked.
  2. Perform magnetic particle testing or dye penetrant testing on the area to be repaired, to confirm that the wear is not masking a pre-existing crack.
  3. Measure the shaft runout and the depth of the worn area, so we know how much build-up is needed and whether the shaft is still straight enough to be worth repairing.
  4. Check the shaft material. If we do not have a mill certificate, we should do a spark test or a portable spectrometer analysis to confirm it is indeed 45 steel and not a higher-alloy steel that would behave differently.

The paper's contribution is that it establishes a credible process window. In my own experience with similar repairs on pump shafts and mixer shafts, the most common failure mode is not the hardfacing itself, but the HAZ underneath. If the preheat is inadequate, the HAZ cracks, and the crack propagates into the shaft body during service. The repair then fails within weeks, and the shaft is scrapped.

5. Lessons Learned and Practical Reflections

The authors succeeded, and the shaft went back into service. But reading this paper from the perspective of a veteran, I see a few things that deserve emphasis:

The repair was performed on a shaft that had seen years of service. The steel has likely been tempered and may have accumulated some fatigue damage. The hardfacing process adds a new thermal cycle that can alter the properties of the base metal. This is why the post-weld heat treatment is so important: it tempers the HAZ, reduces residual stress, and restores some ductility.

The paper does not mention a post-weld non-destructive test. In my practice, I would insist on a magnetic particle test of the finished weld surface, and if the shaft is a critical component, a ultrasonic test from the outside to check for lack of fusion or cracks in the HAZ. A shaft that fails in service on a calciner will stop the entire production line, and the cost of downtime will dwarf the cost of the repair.

The choice of filler is also critical. If the hardfacing is too hard, it will be difficult to machine, and the machining process itself can introduce residual tensile stress. If it is too soft, it will wear out quickly and the repair will be a short-term fix. The paper does not give the exact filler composition, but based on the hardness range mentioned, it is likely a low-alloy steel filler with a deposit hardness in the 25 to 35 HRC range.

6. Summary

This is a competent, practical repair case that demonstrates the correct sequence: weldability analysis, preheat, controlled heat input, and post-weld treatment. The real value of the paper is not in the specific parameters, which will vary with shaft size and section thickness, but in the disciplined approach. For a repair shop, the lesson is clear: never attempt a hardfacing repair on a medium-carbon steel shaft without a documented procedure, proper preheat, and a post-weld inspection plan. The cost of a failed repair is always higher than the cost of doing it right the first time.