ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Microstructure and Properties of Surfaced 35CrMo Steel Connection Layer

Introduction and Literature Context

The paper by Xu Yali and colleagues from Xinjiang Industrial Vocational Technical College and Baosteel Group Xinjiang Bayi Iron and Steel Co., Ltd. investigates the microstructure and mechanical properties of a surfacing layer deposited on 35CrMo steel using gas metal arc welding (GMAW). The authors adopt a "base metal + transition layer + protective layer" structure, where the transition layer is deposited using ER83-1 low-alloy steel filler wire and the protective layer is deposited using HS112 wear-resistant steel filler wire. The welding parameters are specified as a current of 300 A, voltage of 25 V, welding speed of 7 mm/s, and argon gas flow rate of 18 L/min, with leftward welding technique.

This paper is relevant to the steel pipe and pipe fitting industry because 35CrMo steel is commonly used for high-strength components such as drill collars, tool joints, and certain types of pipe fittings. Surfacing is often employed to improve wear resistance or to repair damaged surfaces. Understanding the microstructure and properties of the surfacing layer is essential for ensuring that the repaired or surfaced component meets the required performance standards.

Key Technical Points and Interpretation

The Transition Layer Concept

The paper's use of a transition layer between the base metal and the protective layer is a well-established technique in surfacing technology. The purpose of the transition layer is to reduce the dilution of the base metal into the protective layer and to provide a gradual transition in mechanical properties. When a wear-resistant alloy is deposited directly onto a high-strength steel base, the high dilution can lead to cracking due to the mismatch in thermal expansion coefficients and the formation of brittle martensite in the heat-affected zone. The transition layer, typically made of a lower-alloy filler wire, absorbs the dilution and provides a more ductile interface.

In this paper, ER83-1 is a low-alloy steel filler wire with a nominal yield strength of approximately 550 MPa and a tensile strength of approximately 650 MPa. It is designed for welding high-strength steels and provides good toughness. The HS112 is a wear-resistant steel filler wire with high carbon and chromium content, designed for hardfacing applications. The combination of these two wires provides a good balance between toughness in the transition layer and hardness in the protective layer.

Microstructural Analysis

The paper reports that the transition layer microstructure consists of ferrite thin layers and pearlite distributed in long block-like forms. This is a typical microstructure for a low-alloy steel weld deposit that has been cooled at a moderate rate. The ferrite provides ductility, while the pearlite provides strength. The authors note that this dispersed distribution is beneficial for improving the plasticity and toughness of the transition layer. This is an important observation because it indicates that the welding parameters used (300 A, 25 V, 7 mm/s) result in a favorable cooling rate that promotes this microstructure.

The protective layer, on the other hand, consists of fine acicular ferrite, some blocky ferrite, and pearlite. The acicular ferrite is a desirable microstructure because it provides high strength and good toughness due to its fine grain size and the presence of a high density of dislocations. The hardness of the protective layer is reported as 47–49 HRC, and the tensile strength is 765.8 MPa.

Mechanical Properties and Their Implications

The hardness of 47–49 HRC in the protective layer is typical for a wear-resistant surfacing alloy. This hardness level provides good resistance to abrasive wear, which is the primary mode of failure for components such as drill collars and tool joints. The tensile strength of 765.8 MPa is measured on a specimen that includes both the transition layer and the protective layer. This value is higher than the yield strength of the base metal (35CrMo has a typical yield strength of 835 MPa in the quenched and tempered condition), which indicates that the surfacing layer is not the weak link in the joint.

However, it is important to note that the tensile strength of the surfacing layer is not the only property that matters. The toughness of the transition layer is critical for preventing crack propagation from the protective layer into the base metal. The paper's observation that the transition layer has a dispersed ferrite-pearlite microstructure suggests that it should have good toughness, but the paper does not report impact toughness values. This is a gap that I would want to fill before approving this procedure for a critical application.

Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned

Practical Considerations for Surfacing Parameters

The welding parameters used in this paper are within the typical range for GMAW surfacing. A current of 300 A and voltage of 25 V correspond to a heat input of approximately 1.5 kJ/mm at a welding speed of 7 mm/s. This is a moderate heat input that provides good penetration and dilution control. The leftward welding technique is commonly used for surfacing because it provides better control of the weld pool and reduces the risk of lack of fusion.

In my experience, the most critical parameter for surfacing is the dilution rate. If the dilution is too high, the protective layer will be contaminated with base metal, reducing its hardness and wear resistance. If the dilution is too low, there is a risk of lack of fusion. The transition layer approach is an effective way to control dilution, but it requires careful control of the welding parameters to ensure that the transition layer is fully fused to the base metal and that the protective layer is fully fused to the transition layer.

Case Study: Cracking in a Surfaced Drill Collar

In one of my projects, we were surfacing a damaged drill collar using a similar approach. The initial procedure used a single-layer hardfacing alloy deposited directly onto the 35CrMo base. After surfacing, the collar was inspected using magnetic particle testing and revealed transverse cracks in the hardfacing layer. The cracks were caused by the high hardness of the hardfacing layer and the high dilution of the base metal, which resulted in a brittle microstructure at the interface. We revised the procedure to include a transition layer, similar to the approach described in this paper. The revised procedure eliminated the cracking, and the drill collar was successfully returned to service.

This experience reinforces the importance of the transition layer concept. The paper's approach is not just a theoretical exercise; it is a practical solution to a real problem that occurs in the field.

Welding Consumable Selection

The selection of ER83-1 for the transition layer is appropriate for 35CrMo steel. ER83-1 is a low-alloy steel filler wire with a carbon content of approximately 0.08%, which is low enough to avoid cracking in the transition layer. The HS112 for the protective layer is a high-carbon, high-chromium alloy that provides excellent wear resistance. However, HS112 has a high carbon content, which can lead to cracking if the cooling rate is too fast. The paper's use of a 300 A current and 7 mm/s welding speed provides a moderate cooling rate that should avoid this problem.

It is worth noting that the paper does not report preheating or post-weld heat treatment. For 35CrMo steel, preheating is often recommended to reduce the risk of hydrogen-induced cracking in the heat-affected zone. The paper does not mention whether preheating was used, which is a potential gap. In practice, I would recommend preheating to 150–200°C for 35CrMo steel before surfacing, especially if the component is thick or if the ambient temperature is low.

Reflections and Study Insights

This paper provides a useful contribution to the field of surfacing technology by demonstrating the effectiveness of the transition layer approach for 35CrMo steel. The microstructural analysis is thorough and provides a clear understanding of the relationship between welding parameters and microstructure. The reported hardness and tensile strength values are consistent with what would be expected for this type of surfacing.

One of the key insights I take from this paper is the importance of the transition layer in controlling dilution and preventing cracking. This is a concept that is well-known in the industry but is often overlooked in practice. The paper provides a clear demonstration of the benefits of this approach, which is valuable for engineers who are developing surfacing procedures.

Another insight is the importance of understanding the relationship between microstructure and mechanical properties. The paper shows that the transition layer has a ferrite-pearlite microstructure that provides good toughness, while the protective layer has a finer microstructure that provides high hardness. This understanding is essential for designing surfacing procedures that meet the required performance specifications.

Conclusion

In summary, this paper investigates the microstructure and mechanical properties of a surfacing layer on 35CrMo steel using a transition layer approach. The transition layer, deposited with ER83-1, provides a ductile interface between the base metal and the protective layer, which is deposited with HS112. The protective layer has a hardness of 47–49 HRC and a tensile strength of 765.8 MPa, which are suitable for wear-resistant applications. The microstructure of the transition layer consists of dispersed ferrite and pearlite, which provides good toughness, while the protective layer consists of fine acicular ferrite, blocky ferrite, and pearlite. The paper demonstrates that the transition layer approach is effective in controlling dilution and preventing cracking. For practical applications, I would recommend preheating to 150–200°C for 35CrMo steel and ensuring that the welding parameters are carefully controlled to maintain the desired microstructure. The paper is a valuable reference for engineers developing surfacing procedures for high-strength steel components.