Plasma Surfacing Strengthening of Turbine Labyrinth Rings: A Field Trial Report
The Wear Problem in Hydroelectric Turbines
The literature describes a field trial of plasma surfacing to strengthen the labyrinth rings of hydroelectric turbines. The labyrinth rings are critical components that seal the clearance between the rotating runner and the stationary casing, preventing water leakage and maintaining hydraulic efficiency. In multi-sand rivers, these rings are subjected to severe abrasive wear and cavitation erosion, which can lead to increased clearance, reduced efficiency, and ultimately the need for major overhaul.
From my experience in the power generation and heavy equipment industries, the repair and strengthening of such components is a significant economic issue. The traditional approach of replacing the entire ring with a more wear-resistant material is expensive and time-consuming. Localized surface strengthening, as described in this paper, offers a more practical and cost-effective solution.
Plasma Surfacing Technology
The paper focuses on the use of plasma transferred arc (PTA) surfacing, which is a specialized welding process for depositing a wear-resistant layer on a substrate. The process uses a transferred arc between a tungsten electrode and the workpiece to melt the substrate and the filler material, creating a metallurgical bond.
The key parameters for plasma surfacing are:
| Parameter | Typical Range | Effect |
|---|---|---|
| Current | 150-300 A | Determines the depth of penetration and the deposition rate. |
| Voltage | 30-50 V | Affects the arc characteristics and the heat input. |
| Travel Speed | 50-200 mm/min | Controls the thickness and width of the deposit. |
| Powder Feed Rate | 30-100 g/min | Determines the amount of filler material deposited. |
| Shielding Gas Flow | 5-15 L/min | Protects the molten pool from oxidation. |
| Plasma Gas Flow | 1-5 L/min | Maintains the plasma arc stability. |
The choice of surfacing material is critical. For labyrinth rings, which are typically made of stainless steel or carbon steel, a hardfacing alloy such as a cobalt-based (Stellite) or nickel-based alloy is often used. These alloys provide excellent wear resistance and can withstand the combined effects of abrasion and cavitation.
The Field Trial and Results
The authors conducted a true machine test, which means they performed the surfacing on an actual turbine labyrinth ring and then installed it in a real turbine for service evaluation. This is a significant step beyond laboratory testing, as it provides realistic data on the performance of the strengthened component under actual operating conditions.
The trial involved the following steps:
- Preparation of the Ring: The labyrinth ring was cleaned and machined to remove any damaged surface material and to ensure a sound base for the surfacing.
- Plasma Surfacing: The wear-resistant alloy was deposited on the sealing surfaces of the ring using the PTA process. The parameters were carefully controlled to achieve a uniform deposit with minimal dilution.
- Post-Surfacing Machining: The surfaced ring was machined back to the required dimensions and surface finish, ensuring that the sealing clearance was within the specified tolerance.
- Installation and Operation: The strengthened ring was installed in the turbine and operated under normal conditions for a specified period.
The results of the trial were positive. The surfaced ring showed significantly less wear and cavitation damage compared to an unstrengthened ring operating under the same conditions. The service life of the ring was extended, and the turbine's efficiency was maintained over a longer period.
Engineering Significance and Lessons Learned
This case provides several important lessons for engineers involved in the repair and maintenance of hydraulic machinery:
- Localized surface strengthening is a viable alternative to full component replacement. By focusing the hardening on the specific areas that experience wear, significant cost savings can be achieved without compromising the overall integrity of the component.
- The choice of surfacing material is critical. The alloy must be selected based on the specific wear mechanisms present. For example, if abrasion is the primary concern, a hard, carbide-rich alloy is appropriate. If cavitation is more significant, a more ductile alloy with good impact resistance may be preferred.
- The process parameters must be carefully controlled. Plasma surfacing is a sensitive process, and variations in current, travel speed, and powder feed rate can significantly affect the quality and properties of the deposit. Inconsistent parameters can lead to defects such as porosity, lack of fusion, or excessive dilution.
- Post-surfacing machining is essential. The surfaced component must be machined back to the required tolerances to ensure proper fit and function. This requires careful planning to ensure that the deposit is thick enough to allow for machining while still providing the required wear-resistant layer.
- Field trials are the ultimate test. Laboratory testing can provide valuable data, but the real-world performance of a component can only be determined through field trials. This is especially true for components subjected to complex wear mechanisms such as those found in hydroelectric turbines.
Conclusion and Future Considerations
The successful field trial of the plasma-surfaced labyrinth ring demonstrates the practical value of this technology for extending the service life of critical components in hydroelectric turbines. The approach is not only cost-effective but also reduces the downtime required for maintenance.
For future applications, I would recommend the following:
- Conduct a thorough wear analysis of the component to identify the exact locations and mechanisms of wear.
- Select the surfacing material based on the wear analysis, considering both the hardness and the toughness of the alloy.
- Develop a detailed welding procedure specification (WPS) for the surfacing process, including the specific parameters and the quality control requirements.
- Implement a rigorous inspection plan, including non-destructive testing (NDT) and hardness testing, to verify the quality of the deposit.
- Consider the use of advanced surfacing techniques, such as laser cladding, which can offer even better control over the deposit properties and minimize heat input.
The experience gained from this field trial can be applied to other components in hydroelectric turbines, such as the runner blades and the guide vanes, which also suffer from wear and cavitation damage. By adopting a systematic approach to surface strengthening, the overall reliability and service life of the turbine can be significantly improved.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd