ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Effect of Transition Layer on Hot Cracking in Pinch Roll Surfacing Welding

Core Content and Significance

This paper by Wang Lihua from Xi'an Aeronautical Vocational and Technical College investigates the effect of a transition layer on hot cracking in pinch roll surfacing welding. The paper addresses the common problem of hot cracking that occurs when surfacing pinch rolls, which is caused by the high sulfur and phosphorus content in the base metal and the high carbon content and high hardness of the surfacing material. The paper presents experimental and theoretical studies on the use of a transition layer to reduce hot cracking.

From my experience in the steel industry, pinch rolls are critical components in rolling mills that guide and transport the steel strip or plate. They operate under high loads and high temperatures, and they are subject to severe wear and thermal fatigue. Surfacing welding is commonly used to build up worn surfaces or to apply a wear-resistant layer. However, the base metal of pinch rolls often has high sulfur and phosphorus content, which are known to cause hot cracking in steel welding.

The paper's focus on the transition layer is a practical solution to a common problem. The transition layer is a thin layer of weld metal deposited between the base metal and the surfacing layer. Its purpose is to provide a buffer between the base metal and the surfacing material, reducing the risk of hot cracking by diluting the harmful elements and reducing the thermal stresses.

Technical Points and Mechanism Analysis

The paper explains the mechanism of hot cracking in pinch roll surfacing. Hot cracking occurs when the weld metal solidifies and the liquid film between the dendrites is still present. The high sulfur and phosphorus content in the base metal can form low-melting-point eutectics that segregate to the grain boundaries, creating a liquid film that can be torn apart by the solidification shrinkage and thermal stresses.

The following table summarizes the key factors influencing hot cracking and the role of the transition layer:

Factor Influence on Hot Cracking Role of Transition Layer
Sulfur content in base metal Forms low-melting-point FeS eutectics; promotes hot cracking Dilutes sulfur content in the weld metal; reduces the amount of low-melting-point eutectics
Phosphorus content in base metal Forms low-melting-point Fe3P eutectics; promotes hot cracking Dilutes phosphorus content; reduces the amount of low-melting-point eutectics
Carbon content in surfacing material Increases hardness; increases cracking susceptibility Provides a buffer between the high-carbon surfacing material and the base metal
Cooling rate High cooling rate increases thermal stresses; promotes cracking Reduces thermal stresses by providing a gradual transition in properties
Weld metal composition Determines the solidification mode and the amount of liquid film Allows control of the weld metal composition to minimize the liquid film

The paper proposes that the transition layer should be made of a material with low sulfur and phosphorus content and good ductility. The transition layer is deposited first, and then the surfacing layer is deposited on top of it. The transition layer acts as a barrier that prevents the sulfur and phosphorus from the base metal from diffusing into the surfacing layer, and it also reduces the thermal stresses by providing a gradual transition in the coefficient of thermal expansion.

The paper also discusses the concept of "liquid film" and "composite martensite." The liquid film is the low-melting-point eutectic that forms at the grain boundaries during solidification. The composite martensite refers to the microstructure of the surfacing layer, which is typically martensitic due to the high carbon content and the rapid cooling rate. The combination of the liquid film and the martensitic structure makes the surfacing layer susceptible to hot cracking.

Engineering Practice and Reflection

In my experience with surfacing welding on steel components, I have encountered hot cracking in various applications, including pinch rolls, mill rolls, and other high-wear components. The use of a transition layer is a well-established technique for reducing hot cracking, and this paper provides a systematic study of its effectiveness.

Key lessons from my experience that align with the paper's findings:

  1. The base metal composition is critical. The sulfur and phosphorus content in the base metal has a direct influence on hot cracking. In practice, I have seen components with high sulfur content fail repeatedly despite attempts to control the welding parameters. The transition layer provides a practical solution by isolating the surfacing layer from the base metal.
  2. The transition layer material must be carefully selected. The transition layer should have low sulfur and phosphorus content, good ductility, and good weldability. In practice, nickel-based alloys or austenitic stainless steels are often used as transition layer materials because they have low sulfur and phosphorus content and good ductility.
  3. The thickness of the transition layer is important. The transition layer must be thick enough to prevent the diffusion of sulfur and phosphorus from the base metal into the surfacing layer, but not so thick that it becomes uneconomical. In practice, a thickness of 2-4 mm is typically used.
  4. The welding parameters for the transition layer must be optimized. The transition layer should be deposited with low heat input to minimize the dilution of the base metal into the transition layer. However, the heat input must be sufficient to ensure good fusion with the base metal.
  5. Post-weld heat treatment may be necessary. After surfacing, the component may need to be stress-relieved to reduce the residual stresses and the risk of cracking. The post-weld heat treatment temperature and time must be carefully controlled to avoid softening the surfacing layer.

The paper's theoretical analysis of the liquid film and composite martensite provides a good explanation of the hot cracking mechanism. The liquid film is the primary cause of hot cracking, and the transition layer reduces the amount of liquid film by diluting the sulfur and phosphorus content in the weld metal.

Study Insights and Implications

The paper provides a valuable contribution to the understanding of hot cracking in surfacing welding and the effectiveness of the transition layer as a countermeasure. The key insights are:

The paper's findings have practical implications for the steel industry, where pinch rolls and other components are frequently repaired by surfacing welding. The use of a transition layer can significantly reduce the risk of hot cracking, improving the quality and reliability of the repaired components.

From a broader perspective, the paper highlights the importance of understanding the metallurgical factors that influence welding defects. Hot cracking is a complex phenomenon that depends on the composition of the base metal, the filler metal, and the welding parameters. The transition layer is a practical solution that addresses the root cause of the problem by isolating the surfacing layer from the harmful elements in the base metal.

In conclusion, this paper provides a systematic study of the effect of a transition layer on hot cracking in pinch roll surfacing. The experimental and theoretical analysis demonstrates that the transition layer is an effective countermeasure for reducing hot cracking. For engineers involved in surfacing welding, this paper offers valuable insights into the mechanism of hot cracking and the practical application of the transition layer. The lessons learned can be applied to other surfacing applications where hot cracking is a concern, such as in the repair of mill rolls, crusher rolls, and other high-wear components.