ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Repair Welding of Cracks in 42CrMo Roller Bodies — A Practical Case Study

Failure Description and Root Cause Thinking

The paper by Sun Zuowei from Shigang Special Steel Group describes a repair that every maintenance engineer in a steel plant will recognise. A 42CrMo roller, used in a rolling or conveying line, developed a crack in the inner bore of the roller body. The roller shaft is long, and the crack is in a location that is difficult to access. The conventional approach would be to dismantle the roller from the shaft, remove the shaft, and then repair the roller body separately. But this roller has a long shaft, and dismantling it is expensive, time-consuming, and risks damaging the shaft or the bearing seats.

The root cause of the crack is not discussed in detail in the abstract, but from my experience, cracks in 42CrMo rollers typically originate from one of three sources: fatigue under cyclic loading, stress concentration at a geometric discontinuity, or hydrogen-induced cracking from a previous repair or from the manufacturing process. The crack in this case is in the inner bore, which suggests that the roller body was subjected to high contact stress or that the bore itself was a stress raiser.

Repair Strategy — Why Not Dismantle the Shaft

The key decision in this repair is whether to remove the shaft or to repair in place. The paper chose to repair in place, without removing the shaft. This is a significant decision because it affects every subsequent step of the repair. The reasons for this choice are practical:

  1. The shaft is long, and removing it requires a large press or a special pulling fixture, which may not be available or may not be safe for the shaft.
  2. The shaft may have been press-fitted into the roller, and the interference fit may be damaged by the removal process.
  3. The bearing seats and the shaft's surface finish may be damaged during removal and reinstallation.
  4. The downtime for a full dismantle is significantly longer than for an in-situ repair.

The trade-off is that an in-situ repair is more difficult to execute, because the welding must be done in a confined space, with the shaft in place, and the access for the welding torch is limited.

Groove Preparation and Crack Removal by Oxy-Fuel Cutting

The crack was removed using oxy-fuel cutting. This is a practical choice for a crack in a thick section, because oxy-fuel cutting can remove a large volume of material quickly. However, it has a significant drawback: the cut surface is oxidised and may contain a heat-affected zone with hardened or cracked material. The paper does not mention this explicitly, but from my experience, the following steps are essential after oxy-fuel cutting:

Step Purpose Method
Remove oxide and slag Ensure sound weld metal Grinding or chipping
Inspect the groove Confirm complete crack removal PT or MT after grinding
Remove any hardened layer Prevent HAZ cracking in the repair Grinding or machining
Preheating Prevent cold cracking in 42CrMo Preheat to 200–300 °C

The groove was prepared with a suitable geometry for welding. For a crack in the inner bore, the groove would typically be a U or V shape, with the root of the groove at the bottom of the crack. The groove must be wide enough to allow the welding torch to access the root, but not so wide that the welding heat input becomes excessive.

Modified CO2 Welding Carriage and Welding Procedure

The most interesting part of this paper is the modification of the CO2 welding carriage. The roller has a long shaft, and the welding position is in the inner bore. A standard CO2 welding carriage cannot reach the weld location, so the company modified the carriage to carry an extended welding torch. The modified carriage travels along the shaft, and the extended torch reaches into the bore to deposit the weld metal.

Component Modification Purpose
CO2 welding carriage Extended torch holder Reach the weld location in the bore
Welding torch Lengthened Access the groove in the inner bore
Travel mechanism Adapted to move along the shaft Smooth, consistent travel
Shielding gas CO2, with adequate flow rate Protect the weld pool

The welding procedure itself would have been a CO2 gas-shielded arc welding process, likely with a solid wire or a flux-cored wire. For 42CrMo, the welding must be done with a low-hydrogen process, and the preheat and interpass temperature must be carefully controlled. The paper does not give the exact parameters, but from my experience, the following would be typical:

Parameter Typical Range Notes
Welding current 200–300 A Depending on wire diameter
Arc voltage 24–30 V CO2 shielding
Welding speed 20–40 cm/min Adjusted for bead width
Preheat temperature 200–300 °C For 42CrMo
Interpass temperature 200–350 °C Must not exceed maximum
Post-weld heat treatment Stress relief at 550–650 °C If feasible in-situ

The use of a modified carriage is a clever engineering solution. It avoids the need to dismantle the roller, and it provides a consistent, mechanised weld deposit that is superior to manual welding in terms of quality and repeatability. The paper reports that the repair was successful and the roller met the requirements for continued service.

Quality Control and Lessons Learned

The quality control for this repair would have included:

  1. Visual inspection of the groove after crack removal.
  2. Magnetic particle or penetrant testing to confirm complete crack removal.
  3. Preheating verification using a contact pyrometer or temperature-indicating crayons.
  4. Interpass temperature monitoring during welding.
  5. Post-weld inspection, including UT or RT to confirm the absence of defects.
  6. Dimensional verification to ensure the roller meets its original tolerances.

The lesson from this case is that in-situ repair is often the right choice, even when it is technically more difficult. The cost of dismantling a large roller with a long shaft can be prohibitive, and the risk of damaging the shaft during removal is real. The modified carriage approach is a good example of engineering ingenuity solving a practical problem. I have seen similar solutions in pipe mills, where a worn forming roll is repaired in place using a portable welding carriage, avoiding the need to remove the roll from the mill stand.

Concluding Summary

This case study demonstrates that a crack in a 42CrMo roller body can be repaired in-situ without removing the shaft, using oxy-fuel cutting for crack removal and a modified CO2 welding carriage with an extended torch for the welding. The key technical points are the groove preparation, the preheating and interpass temperature control, and the mechanised welding to ensure consistent quality. The repair was successful and the roller was returned to service. The lesson for any maintenance engineer is that in-situ repair, when properly planned and executed, can be a cost-effective alternative to dismantling, and that a modified welding carriage is a practical solution for accessing confined weld locations. This is the kind of repair that saves a plant a week of downtime and a significant amount of money.