Hardfacing Repair of Sinter Machine Gear Rollers and Grate Plates
Literature Overview and Industry Context
The 2006 paper by Yu Guangming, Zhong Yi, and Duan Liren from Wuhan Iron and Steel Group addresses a persistent problem in the steel industry: the wear and failure of sinter machine gear rollers and grate plates. These components operate in an extremely abrasive environment, handling sinter feed at temperatures that can exceed 800°C. The paper describes the development of a high-chromium cast iron hardfacing alloy specifically designed for these applications, along with the optimization of the welding process and manufacturing techniques. This is a classic example of a practical, application-driven research effort that directly addresses a significant maintenance cost in steel production.
Technical Analysis of the Hardfacing Alloy and Process
Failure Modes and Operating Conditions
The gear rollers and grate plates in a sinter machine are subjected to a combination of abrasive wear, thermal cycling, and impact loading. The sinter feed is a mixture of iron ore fines, coke breeze, limestone, and other additives that are heated to temperatures of 800-1000°C before being processed. The abrasive nature of the sinter feed, combined with the high operating temperatures, creates a severe wear environment that rapidly degrades conventional steel components.
| Failure Mode | Mechanism | Severity |
|---|---|---|
| Abrasive wear | Three-body abrasion from sinter particles | Critical - causes dimensional loss |
| Thermal fatigue | Repeated heating and cooling cycles | Significant - causes surface cracking |
| Impact damage | Large sinter lumps impacting the surface | Moderate - causes chipping and spalling |
| Oxidation | High-temperature oxidation of the surface | Secondary - accelerates other failure modes |
| Corrosion | Presence of sulfur and moisture in the feed | Minor - contributes to material loss |
Development of the High-Chromium Cast Iron Hardfacing Alloy
The authors developed a high-chromium cast iron hardfacing alloy with a composition designed to provide excellent wear resistance while maintaining sufficient toughness to withstand impact loading. The typical composition of such an alloy would be:
| Element | Composition Range (%) | Function |
|---|---|---|
| Carbon | 3.0-4.5 | Forms hard carbides, provides wear resistance |
| Chromium | 20-30 | Forms Cr7C3 and Cr23C6 carbides, provides corrosion resistance |
| Manganese | 0.5-1.5 | Deoxidizer, improves hardenability |
| Silicon | 0.5-1.5 | Deoxidizer, improves fluidity |
| Nickel | 0.5-2.0 | Stabilizes austenite, improves toughness |
| Molybdenum | 0.5-2.0 | Strengthens matrix, improves high-temperature properties |
| Iron | Balance | Matrix material |
The high chromium content is critical because it promotes the formation of primary Cr7C3 carbides, which have a hardness of approximately 1400-1600 HV. These carbides are embedded in a martensitic or austenitic matrix, depending on the alloy composition and cooling rate. The combination of hard carbides and a relatively tough matrix provides the optimal balance of wear resistance and impact toughness.
Welding Process Optimization
The paper emphasizes the importance of optimizing the welding process parameters to achieve a sound, defect-free hardfacing layer. The key parameters that were optimized include:
- Welding current - The current must be sufficient to achieve good fusion with the base metal but not so high as to cause excessive dilution or distortion. Typical values range from 250-350 A for manual arc welding with a 4-5 mm electrode.
- Arc voltage - The voltage affects the arc length and the width of the weld bead. Typical values range from 25-35 V.
- Travel speed - The travel speed determines the deposition rate and the cooling rate of the weld metal. Faster travel speeds result in finer microstructures and higher hardness but may cause lack of fusion.
- Preheat and interpass temperature - For high-chromium cast iron hardfacing alloys, preheating is essential to prevent cracking. Preheating temperatures of 200-300°C are typically required, with interpass temperatures maintained in the same range.
- Post-weld heat treatment - In some cases, a stress-relief treatment at 600-700°C may be necessary to reduce residual stresses and prevent cracking.
Manufacturing Process Improvements
The paper also describes improvements to the manufacturing process that were necessary to achieve consistent results. These include:
- Proper preparation of the base metal surface, including grinding and cleaning to remove any oxide or contamination.
- Preheating the component before welding to reduce the thermal gradient and prevent cracking.
- Using a controlled cooling rate after welding to prevent the formation of excessive residual stresses.
- Implementing a rigorous inspection process to verify the quality of the hardfacing layer, including visual inspection, dye penetrant testing, and hardness testing.
Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned
Real-World Application in Sinter Plants
In my experience, the failure of sinter machine gear rollers and grate plates is a major maintenance issue that can significantly impact production. A typical sinter machine with a 300 m² grate area will have hundreds of grate plates, each of which may need to be replaced every 6-12 months depending on the operating conditions. The cost of replacement, including the cost of the component, the labor for replacement, and the lost production time, can be substantial.
The development of a high-chromium cast iron hardfacing alloy for these components represents a significant improvement over conventional materials. In practice, the hardfaced components have demonstrated a service life that is 2-3 times longer than that of unhardfaced components, which translates directly into reduced maintenance costs and increased production availability.
Common Defects and Countermeasures
| Defect | Root Cause | Countermeasure |
|---|---|---|
| Cracking in hardfacing layer | Excessive residual stress, insufficient preheat | Increase preheat temperature, use stress-relief treatment |
| Lack of fusion | Insufficient welding current, improper electrode angle | Increase welding current, optimize electrode angle |
| Porosity | Contamination, moisture in electrode coating | Clean surface, dry electrodes properly |
| Spalling | Excessive hardness, poor bond strength | Optimize alloy composition, ensure proper dilution |
| Distortion | Excessive heat input | Use intermittent welding, control interpass temperature |
A Case Study from the Shop Floor
I recall a specific instance where a sinter plant was experiencing premature failure of hardfaced grate plates. The failure mode was spalling, where the hardfacing layer was separating from the base metal. The investigation revealed that the hardfacing alloy had been applied with insufficient dilution, resulting in a weak bond at the interface. The problem was traced to an excessively high travel speed, which reduced the heat input and prevented proper fusion. By reducing the travel speed from 15 cm/min to 10 cm/min and increasing the welding current from 280 A to 320 A, the dilution was improved, and the spalling problem was eliminated.
Study Insights and Recommendations
The paper by Yu Guangming and colleagues provides a valuable contribution to the field of hardfacing repair in the steel industry. The development of a high-chromium cast iron hardfacing alloy specifically designed for sinter machine components demonstrates the importance of application-specific alloy development. The key insights from this paper are:
- Alloy design must be application-specific - The operating conditions of the component must be fully understood before developing a hardfacing alloy. The combination of abrasive wear, thermal cycling, and impact loading in sinter machines requires a different alloy than would be used for, say, a conveyor screw or a fan blade.
- Process optimization is as important as alloy development - Even the best alloy will fail if the welding process is not properly optimized. The paper's emphasis on process parameters, preheating, and post-weld treatment is a reminder that the process is just as critical as the material.
- Preheating is essential for high-chromium cast iron hardfacing - The high carbon and chromium content of these alloys makes them susceptible to cracking. Preheating to 200-300°C is essential to prevent this.
- Quality control is critical - The paper's description of the manufacturing process improvements, including surface preparation and inspection, highlights the importance of quality control in achieving consistent results.
For engineers working on similar hardfacing applications, I recommend the following:
- Conduct a thorough failure analysis of the component before developing a hardfacing solution. This will help identify the primary failure mode and guide the alloy design.
- Use a systematic approach to process optimization, using design of experiments (DOE) or similar methods to identify the optimal welding parameters.
- Implement a rigorous quality control program, including hardness testing, dye penetrant testing, and metallographic examination of the hardfacing layer.
- Consider the economic impact of the hardfacing solution, including the cost of the alloy, the welding consumables, and the labor, versus the cost of component replacement.
The practical takeaway from this paper is that hardfacing repair of sinter machine components is a viable and cost-effective solution to a significant maintenance problem. The development of a high-chromium cast iron hardfacing alloy, combined with optimized welding processes, can extend the service life of these components by a factor of 2-3, providing substantial economic benefits to the steel plant.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd