ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

TOPTIG Hardfacing of 410 Stainless Steel Steam Turbine Blades: Process and Joint Performance

Literature Overview and Practical Context

The paper by Shen Hongyuan and Chen Huabin from GE China Research and Development Center and Shanghai Jiao Tong University addresses a very specific and demanding application: the repair of worn steam turbine blades made from 410 stainless steel. The repair method is TOPTIG, which is a variant of TIG welding where the torch is equipped with a mechanism to feed the filler wire directly into the arc, allowing for higher deposition rates and more consistent weld quality than conventional TIG. The paper develops a set of optimal welding parameters for the repair of a curved plate, and it analyses the hardness and microstructure of the resulting joint.

This is a topic that I have direct experience with, because turbine blade repair is one of the most demanding hardfacing and welding applications in the power generation industry. The blades operate at high temperature, high stress, and in a corrosive steam environment. The 410 stainless steel is a martensitic stainless steel that is chosen for its combination of strength, corrosion resistance and wear resistance. When a blade is damaged by erosion or foreign object impact, the repair must restore the original properties without introducing defects that could lead to premature failure. The TOPTIG process is an excellent choice for this application because it offers precise control of heat input, which is critical for a martensitic steel that is sensitive to overheating and hydrogen cracking.

Technical Points and Process Windows

TOPTIG Process Characteristics

TOPTIG is a development of the TIG process where the filler wire is fed through the centre of the torch, directly into the arc. This provides several advantages over conventional TIG with a side-fed wire. First, the wire is always in the centre of the arc, which ensures consistent melting and a uniform weld bead. Second, the arc is more stable, which reduces the risk of tungsten inclusion. Third, the deposition rate is higher, which reduces the number of passes required and the total heat input. For a repair application on a thin blade, the lower heat input is a significant advantage because it reduces distortion and the size of the heat-affected zone.

The paper identifies a set of optimal parameters for the repair of the 410 stainless steel curved plate. From my experience, the key parameters for TOPTIG on martensitic stainless steel are:

Parameter Typical Range Critical Consideration
Welding current 80 - 150 A Must be controlled to avoid overheating the HAZ
Arc voltage 10 - 14 V Low voltage for a concentrated arc
Travel speed 5 - 15 cm/min Must be matched to the wire feed rate
Wire feed rate 50 - 150 cm/min Determines the deposition rate and dilution
Shielding gas Argon, 10-15 L/min High purity argon is essential
Preheat temperature 150 - 250°C Prevents hydrogen cracking in the martensitic HAZ
Interpass temperature 150 - 250°C Must be controlled to avoid softening of the HAZ

Hardness Variation Across the Joint

The paper reports that the hardness varies in a wave-like manner across the joint, from the base metal through the intermediate weld to the weld end. This is a typical pattern for a multi-pass weld on a martensitic steel. The base metal, which is in the tempered martensite condition, has a hardness of approximately 30-35 HRC. The HAZ, which is heated above the transformation temperature during welding, forms untempered martensite on cooling, and this has a higher hardness, typically 40-50 HRC. The weld metal, which is deposited as martensite and then tempered by subsequent passes, has a hardness that depends on the position within the joint. The last pass, which is not tempered by a subsequent pass, will be the hardest, while the intermediate passes will be softer due to tempering.

The wave-like hardness variation is a concern because it indicates a non-uniform microstructure. In service, this can lead to preferential wear or corrosion in the softer regions, and it can create residual stress gradients that contribute to cracking. The countermeasure is to apply a post-weld heat treatment (PWHT) to temper the entire joint uniformly. For 410 stainless steel, the PWHT is typically performed at 600-750°C for 1-2 hours, followed by slow cooling. This tempers the martensite in both the HAZ and the weld metal, reducing the hardness to a uniform level and improving the toughness.

Microstructure of the Weld and HAZ

The paper describes the weld metal as having a typical solidification structure, with upper bainite and lower bainite in the intermediate passes and lath martensite in the final pass. This is consistent with the cooling rate and the chemical composition of the 410 stainless steel. The HAZ is more problematic. The paper reports abnormal grain growth in the overheated zone of the HAZ, which is a result of the high peak temperature and the lack of grain pinning particles in the 410 stainless steel. The abnormal grain growth reduces the toughness of the HAZ and increases the risk of cracking.

The formation of upper and lower bainite in the intermediate passes is a result of the cooling rate and the transformation behaviour of the 410 stainless steel. Upper bainite forms at higher temperatures and has a coarser, less tough structure, while lower bainite forms at lower temperatures and has a finer, tougher structure. The presence of upper bainite is a concern because it is associated with reduced toughness. The countermeasure is to control the cooling rate by using a higher preheat and interpass temperature, which promotes the formation of lower bainite or martensite rather than upper bainite.

Engineering Practice and Reflections

Turbine Blade Repair in Practice

In my experience, turbine blade repair is a high-stakes operation that requires a rigorous qualification programme. The first step is to assess the extent of the damage and to determine whether the blade is repairable or whether it should be replaced. The assessment must include a dimensional check, a hardness survey, and a non-destructive examination of the blade for cracks. If the blade is repairable, the damaged area is ground out to a smooth, defect-free profile, and the repair is performed using a qualified welding procedure.

The TOPTIG process is particularly well suited for this application because it allows for precise control of the heat input and the deposition rate. The key is to use a low heat input to minimise the size of the HAZ and the distortion, and to use a multi-pass technique to build up the repair area. The paper's finding that the hardness varies across the joint is a reminder that a post-weld heat treatment is essential to restore the uniform properties of the blade.

The Importance of Preheat and Interpass Temperature

For 410 stainless steel, the preheat and interpass temperature are critical. The steel is air-hardening, which means that it transforms to martensite on cooling from the welding temperature. If the preheat is too low, the cooling rate will be too fast, and the HAZ will form hard, crack-sensitive untempered martensite. If the preheat is too high, the HAZ will be too soft, and the blade will lose its strength. The optimum preheat and interpass temperature is typically 150-250°C, which provides a cooling rate that forms a tempered martensite structure.

The paper does not explicitly state the preheat and interpass temperature used, but the hardness values and the microstructure suggest that a preheat was used. In practice, the preheat is applied using a resistance heater or a torch, and the temperature is monitored using a contact pyrometer or a temperature-indicating crayon. The interpass temperature must be controlled between passes to ensure that the HAZ does not overheat.

Defects and Countermeasures

The main defects that occur in the TOPTIG repair of 410 stainless steel are hydrogen cracking, lack of fusion, and porosity. Hydrogen cracking is the most serious, and it is caused by the combination of a martensitic microstructure, a high residual stress, and a hydrogen concentration above the critical level. The countermeasure is to use a low-hydrogen process, to ensure that the shielding gas and the filler wire are dry, and to apply a preheat. Lack of fusion can be caused by a low heat input or by an incorrect torch angle. The countermeasure is to increase the heat input or to adjust the torch angle. Porosity can be caused by contamination of the surface or by inadequate shielding. The countermeasure is to clean the surface thoroughly and to ensure that the shielding gas flow rate is adequate.

Study Insights and Implications

The paper is a valuable contribution to the field of turbine blade repair. It demonstrates that the TOPTIG process can produce a high-quality repair on 410 stainless steel, and it provides a set of optimal parameters that can be used as a starting point for a repair procedure. The hardness and microstructure analysis is particularly useful because it highlights the importance of controlling the heat input and the post-weld heat treatment.

For the shop floor, the key takeaways are that TOPTIG offers a significant advantage over conventional TIG for repair applications, and that the control of preheat, interpass temperature and post-weld heat treatment is essential for a martensitic stainless steel. The paper is a useful reference for welding engineers who are developing repair procedures for steam turbine blades, and it provides a metallurgical basis for the process parameters that are used in practice.