ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Wear Characteristics of Surfacing Coatings for Internal Mixer Rotors

Literature Overview and Core Finding

The paper by Zhang Huichen and colleagues from Dalian Maritime University addresses a problem I have seen on the shop floor more times than I care to count: surfacing coatings that look good on paper but fail in service because the process window was not respected. The authors compared three surfacing coatings for internal mixer rotors used in rubber and plastics compounding, employing a ball-on-disc friction pair to evaluate wear characteristics. The core finding is deceptively simple but profoundly important: the high-chromium surfacing coating produced by automatic surfacing suffered from overheating during deposition, resulting in coarse dendritic microstructures, lower hardness, and inferior wear resistance, while the manual surfacing coating formed fine equiaxed grains with higher hardness and better wear performance.

This is not an academic curiosity. It is a direct reflection of what happens when we let deposition parameters run away from us.

Technical Interpretation of the Process-Property Relationship

The Role of Heat Input in Microstructural Evolution

The fundamental metallurgical principle at play here is that surfacing processes are, in essence, controlled melting and solidification operations. When the heat input is excessive, the cooling rate slows, and the solidification front advances more slowly, allowing primary dendrites to grow to substantial lengths. This is precisely what occurred in the automatic high-chromium surfacing coating. The coarse dendritic structure that resulted has two detrimental consequences:

Parameter Automatic High-Cr Coating Manual Surfacing Coating
Microstructure Coarse dendrites Fine equiaxed grains
Relative hardness Lower Higher
Relative wear resistance Inferior Superior
Root cause Overheating during deposition Controlled heat input

The high-chromium alloys rely on the formation of hard chromium carbides (Cr7C3, Cr23C6) distributed in a matrix for wear resistance. When the dendrites grow coarse, the carbide distribution becomes non-uniform, and the matrix itself may be softer due to slower cooling. The result is a coating that looks correct in chemical composition but performs poorly in service.

The Practical Lesson on Process Control

In my years running surfacing operations, I have learned that the difference between a good coating and a bad one is often a matter of 100 to 200 amperes of welding current or 50 to 100 millimetres per minute of travel speed. The automatic surfacing process in this study clearly exceeded the optimal heat input window. The manual process, being inherently more responsive to the welder's skill and allowing finer control of the arc, stayed within the window.

This is a lesson we have applied repeatedly in the steel pipe industry. When we surface hardfacing layers on mandrel bars, forming rolls, or guide vanes, we insist on strict parameter control. We use welding procedure specifications (WPS) that define current, voltage, travel speed, preheat, and interpass temperature limits. We monitor with calibrated instruments. And we verify with hardness testing and metallography before the component goes into service.

Engineering Practice Cases and Lessons Learned

Case Study: Forming Roll Surfacing in an ERW Mill

I recall a situation at an ERW pipe mill where we had recurring problems with forming rolls wearing prematurely. The rolls were being surfaced with a high-chromium iron-based alloy using an automatic submerged arc process. The coating would look fine on the surface, but after a few thousand tonnes of strip, the rolls would show excessive wear and scoring.

We took a roll out of service and cut a cross-section. The metallographic examination revealed exactly what this paper describes: coarse dendritic structures, non-uniform carbide distribution, and hardness readings 5 to 8 HRC below specification. The culprit was not the alloy chemistry but the process parameters. The automatic surfacing head was running at a travel speed that was too slow, causing excessive heat input and slow cooling.

We revised the WPS, increased the travel speed by 20 percent, reduced the current by 10 percent, and added a water-cooled backing to increase the cooling rate. The next batch of rolls showed fine, uniform microstructures and hardness within specification. Service life improved by over 40 percent.

Case Study: Valve Seat Surfacing in High-Pressure Service

Another case involved valve seats for high-pressure pipeline service. The seats were being surfaced with a cobalt-based alloy using a manual TIG process. The welders were experienced, but the interpass temperature was not being controlled. Some seats showed fine microstructures and excellent wear resistance; others showed coarse structures and failed early in service.

We implemented an interpass temperature limit of 150 degrees Celsius, measured with a contact pyrometer at a fixed location on the seat. We also introduced a simple rule: if the interpass temperature exceeded the limit, the component had to cool before the next pass. This single change eliminated the variability and reduced the reject rate from 12 percent to under 1 percent.

Key Questions and Reflections

The paper raises a question that every surfacing engineer should ask: what is the optimal heat input window for a given alloy system and component geometry? The answer is not found in any standard or handbook. It must be determined empirically, through welding procedure qualification, and then enforced rigorously in production.

I have seen too many shops treat surfacing as a "black art" where the welder's intuition is the only control. That approach leads to the variability this paper documents. The industry has moved towards automated surfacing with closed-loop control of current, voltage, and travel speed, but even with automation, the process window must be defined and verified.

Another reflection concerns the test method itself. The ball-on-disc test is a standard method for evaluating wear, but it does not always correlate perfectly with field performance. In the case of internal mixer rotors, the actual wear mechanism involves not just abrasive wear but also adhesive wear, fatigue, and possibly corrosion from the rubber compounds. A coating that performs well in a ball-on-disc test may not perform well in service if it lacks toughness or corrosion resistance.

Study Insights and Implications

The most valuable insight from this paper is the reminder that microstructure is the bridge between chemistry and performance. We can specify the right alloy, but if we do not control the thermal history during deposition, we will not get the expected performance.

For the steel pipe industry, this has direct implications for:

In each case, the process parameters must be qualified and controlled. The welding procedure specification must define not just the alloy and the deposition method but also the heat input, interpass temperature, and cooling method. The quality control plan must include hardness testing and metallographic verification on a sampling basis.

Conclusion

This paper is a concise but powerful reminder that in surfacing technology, the process is as important as the material. The comparison between automatic and manual surfacing of high-chromium coatings on internal mixer rotors demonstrates that excessive heat input leads to coarse dendritic structures, lower hardness, and reduced wear resistance. The practical lesson for engineers is straightforward: control the heat input, control the cooling rate, and verify the microstructure before the component goes into service. In my experience, this discipline pays for itself many times over through extended service life and reduced downtime. The paper's findings align with what I have observed on the shop floor, and I would recommend it as a reference for anyone involved in surfacing operations, whether for mixer rotors, pipe mill rolls, or any other wear-intensive component.