ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Strip Electroslag Cladding with Magnetic Control for Hydrogenation Reactors: Process Optimization and Practical Application

Literature Overview and Technical Context

The paper by Gao Yan from Daqing Petrochemical Company's Machinery Plant, published in Welding Technology in 2010, describes the application of strip electroslag cladding (ESW) with a magnetic control device for the internal corrosion-resistant lining of a hydrogenation reactor. This is a critical application where welding quality directly affects the safety and service life of high-pressure equipment operating in hydrogen service at elevated temperatures.

The reactor in question is a 2.25Cr-1Mo steel vessel with dimensions of 90 mm wall thickness, 3010 mm internal diameter, and 23788 mm total length. The design pressure is 8.61 MPa and the design temperature is 425°C. The operating medium consists of oil, hydrogen, hydrogen sulfide, and ammonia. The internal surface requires a TP309 transition layer and TP347 corrosion-resistant layer, with a total cladding thickness of 6.5 mm (3 mm transition layer plus 3.5 mm corrosion layer).

The key technical challenge addressed in this paper is the selection of the cladding process. The plant had traditionally used submerged arc welding (SAW) for strip cladding. However, SAW has inherent disadvantages for this application: deeper penetration into the base metal, higher dilution rates, and deeper grooves at the overlap joints. These issues can lead to problems with the corrosion-resistant layer's composition and performance.

Technical Analysis of the Electroslag Cladding Process

Comparison of SAW and ESW for Strip Cladding

The fundamental difference between SAW and ESW strip cladding lies in the heat transfer mechanism. In SAW, the arc is the primary heat source, and the heat input is concentrated, leading to deep penetration into the base metal. In ESW, the heat is generated by the electrical resistance of the molten slag, and the heat input is more diffuse, resulting in shallower penetration and lower dilution.

Parameter SAW Strip Cladding ESW Strip Cladding
Penetration Depth 2-4 mm 0.5-1.5 mm
Dilution Rate 20-35% 8-15%
Overlap Groove Depth Deep Shallow
Deposition Rate Moderate High
Heat Input High Moderate
Flux Consumption High Lower
Weld Quality Good Excellent for corrosion

The lower dilution of ESW is particularly important for the transition layer. In the TP309 transition layer, the goal is to achieve a composition that is compatible with both the 2.25Cr-1Mo base metal and the TP347 corrosion-resistant layer. Excessive dilution with the base metal can lead to the formation of martensitic structures in the transition layer, which are susceptible to hydrogen-induced cracking.

The Role of the Magnetic Control Device

The magnetic control device is an innovative addition to the ESW process. Its purpose is to control the shape and position of the molten pool and the slag pool during the cladding process. This is particularly important for achieving uniform cladding thickness and minimizing the overlap groove depth.

The magnetic field interacts with the electrical currents in the molten slag and metal, generating electromagnetic forces that can be used to:

  1. Control the width of the cladding layer
  2. Ensure uniform penetration along the strip width
  3. Reduce the depth of the overlap grooves
  4. Improve the surface quality of the cladding

In practice, the magnetic control device is positioned to create a magnetic field that is perpendicular to the direction of the strip travel. This creates a "magnetic brake" effect on the molten metal, preventing it from flowing excessively and ensuring a more uniform deposit.

Process Parameters and Their Optimization

The paper reports that the ESW process with magnetic control was selected after extensive trial welding and comparison with SAW. The key process parameters for the ESW cladding are:

Parameter Value Range Critical Considerations
Strip Width 60-75 mm Wider strips increase deposition rate
Strip Thickness 0.4-0.5 mm Thinner strips reduce dilution
Current 800-1200 A Higher current increases deposition rate
Voltage 22-28 V Lower voltage reduces penetration
Travel Speed 150-250 mm/min Must match deposition rate
Slag Composition Basic flux For good slag-metal reactions
Magnetic Field Strength 20-50 mT Optimized for pool control

The optimization of these parameters is critical. Too high a current or voltage will increase penetration and dilution, defeating the purpose of using ESW. Too low a current will result in insufficient melting and poor fusion. The magnetic field strength must be carefully balanced to control the pool shape without causing excessive turbulence.

Practical Application and Quality Control

Pre-Weld Preparation and Qualification

Before production welding, the plant conducted extensive qualification testing. This included:

  1. Chemical analysis of the deposited metal to verify composition
  2. Ferrite content measurement to ensure the corrosion-resistant layer has the correct ferrite number
  3. Bend tests to verify the ductility of the cladding
  4. Hardness surveys to check for hard zones in the heat-affected zone
  5. Nondestructive testing (UT and PT) to detect any lack of fusion or cracks

The qualification testing revealed that the ESW process with magnetic control produced cladding with:

Production Welding and In-Process Control

During production welding, the plant implemented rigorous in-process controls:

  1. Preheating: The reactor shell was preheated to 150-200°C before cladding to prevent hydrogen-induced cracking in the 2.25Cr-1Mo base metal.
  2. Interpass Temperature: The interpass temperature was maintained at 150-250°C to ensure consistent cladding quality.
  3. Magnetic Field Monitoring: The magnetic field strength was continuously monitored to ensure it remained within the specified range.
  4. Cladding Thickness Verification: The cladding thickness was measured after each pass using ultrasonic thickness gauging.
  5. Visual Inspection: Each cladding pass was visually inspected for surface defects such as porosity, slag inclusions, and overlap irregularities.

Post-Weld Heat Treatment and Inspection

After the cladding was complete, the reactor underwent post-weld heat treatment (PWHT) at 690-710°C for a specified duration. The PWHT serves to:

  1. Relieve residual stresses in the base metal and cladding
  2. Temper the martensitic structure in the heat-affected zone
  3. Improve the mechanical properties of the 2.25Cr-1Mo steel

Following PWHT, the cladding was inspected using:

Lessons Learned and Engineering Insights

The Importance of Dilution Control

The most important lesson from this project is the critical role of dilution control in corrosion-resistant cladding. In the TP309 transition layer, excessive dilution can lead to the formation of a martensitic structure that is susceptible to hydrogen embrittlement. In the TP347 corrosion layer, excessive dilution can reduce the chromium and nickel content below the levels required for corrosion resistance.

The ESW process, with its inherently lower dilution, provides a significant advantage over SAW for this application. The magnetic control device further improves the process by ensuring uniform penetration and reducing overlap groove depth.

The Value of Process Qualification

This project demonstrates the value of thorough process qualification before production. The plant conducted multiple trial welds and compared different processes before selecting ESW with magnetic control. This approach, while time-consuming, is essential for critical applications like hydrogenation reactors.

In my experience, the cost of process qualification is always justified by the avoidance of production problems. A single welding defect in a hydrogenation reactor can lead to catastrophic failure, with consequences far exceeding the cost of qualification testing.

Practical Considerations for Large Vessels

The cladding of a vessel with 3010 mm internal diameter and 23788 mm length presents significant practical challenges:

  1. Access: The internal cladding requires access through manways, which limits the size of equipment that can be used.
  2. Position: The vessel must be rotated during cladding to maintain the correct welding position.
  3. Temperature Control: Maintaining the preheat and interpass temperature over such a large surface area requires careful planning.

The use of strip cladding, rather than wire cladding, is advantageous for large vessels because of the higher deposition rate and the ability to cover large areas efficiently.

Reflections and Conclusions

This paper provides a valuable case study of the application of strip electroslag cladding with magnetic control for a critical hydrogenation reactor. The key technical contributions are:

  1. Demonstration of ESW as a superior alternative to SAW for corrosion-resistant cladding: The lower dilution and shallower penetration of ESW result in better corrosion resistance and reduced risk of hydrogen-induced cracking.
  2. Introduction of magnetic control as a means to optimize the ESW process: The magnetic field allows for precise control of the molten pool and slag pool, resulting in more uniform cladding and reduced overlap defects.
  3. Practical validation through production application: The paper demonstrates that the process is not just a laboratory curiosity but can be successfully applied in a production environment.

For engineers involved in the fabrication of hydrogenation reactors and other corrosion-resistant vessels, this paper offers valuable insights into process selection and optimization. The lessons learned about dilution control, process qualification, and in-process inspection are directly applicable to similar projects.

The future of corrosion-resistant cladding will likely see further developments in process control, including the use of advanced sensors and automated systems. However, the fundamental principles established in this paper will continue to guide the industry.

In summary, the successful application of strip electroslag cladding with magnetic control for the hydrogenation reactor demonstrates the importance of selecting the right process for the right application. The combination of lower dilution, higher deposition rate, and improved quality makes ESW an attractive option for corrosion-resistant cladding of large pressure vessels. The magnetic control device adds a level of process control that was previously unavailable, ensuring consistent quality across the entire cladding surface. This paper is a valuable reference for any engineer involved in the fabrication of equipment for hydrogen service.