Metallurgical Characterisation of Hard Phases in NDG-2 Nickel-Based Wear-Resistant Surfacing Alloy
Literature Overview and Technical Context
This paper by Xian Hengze from the Analysis and Testing Centre of Harbin Institute of Technology, published in Functional Materials in 2004, tackles a question that has occupied every shop floor I have ever run: what exactly makes a hardfacing alloy wear-resistant, and how do we prove it? The work applies constant-current electrolytic phase extraction to isolate the hard phases from NDG-2 nickel-based surfacing alloy, then characterises them by XRD and SEM, including their crystallographic structure and three-dimensional morphology. The paper then links the observed hard phases to the alloy's wear performance.
For anyone who has ever specified a hardfacing consumable for a mud pump liner, a screw conveyor, a crusher roll or a valve seat, this is the kind of fundamental work that separates guesswork from engineering. The alloy designation NDG-2 is a Ni-Cr-W-Si system, and the paper's central finding is that the principal hard phases are Cr7C3 and a complex NiCrWSi intermetallic. The value of the paper lies not merely in identifying these phases, but in the extraction technique itself, because phase identification in a multi-component nickel-based system is notoriously difficult when the matrix is also nickel-rich and the carbides are fine and embedded.
Interpretation of Core Technical Points
Electrolytic Phase Extraction as the Enabling Technique
The critical methodological contribution is the use of constant-current electrolytic phase extraction. In a nickel-based alloy, the matrix is electrochemically more noble than the carbides and intermetallics, so a judiciously chosen electrolyte and current density can dissolve the matrix while leaving the hard phases as an undissolved residue. The extracted residue can then be weighed, sieved, and analysed by XRD without the interference of the matrix peaks.
The practical significance is that XRD on a polished bulk surface of a nickel-based hardfacing often produces weak or overlapping carbide peaks, because the hard phases are small, dispersed and present in relatively low volume fractions. By concentrating the residue, the diffraction pattern becomes unambiguous. I have seen too many laboratory reports where the analyst simply ran a bulk XRD scan, reported "carbides present" without identifying which carbide, and left the engineer to guess whether the phase was Cr7C3, Cr23C6 or Cr3C2. This paper demonstrates the correct way to do it.
Identification of Cr7C3 and NiCrWSi
The XRD results confirmed Cr7C3 as the dominant chromium carbide, with the complex NiCrWSi phase also present. Cr7C3 is a high-hardness carbide, typically in the range of 1200 to 1600 HV, and it is the classic hard phase in Ni-Cr-B-Si and Ni-Cr-W-Si hardfacing alloys. The NiCrWSi phase is an intermetallic compound, and its hardness and its role in wear resistance are less well documented in the open literature, which makes this paper's contribution more significant.
The SEM examination revealed the three-dimensional morphology of these phases after extraction. Cr7C3 appeared as elongated, rod-like or hexagonal-prismatic crystals, while NiCrWSi appeared in more blocky, irregular forms. This morphological distinction matters because the shape of the hard phase affects how it interacts with an abrasive or erosive counterface. Rod-like carbides oriented perpendicular to the wear surface can provide better resistance to abrasive scratching, whereas blocky phases may be more prone to pull-out if the matrix is not sufficiently supporting them.
Relationship Between Hard Phases and Wear Resistance
The paper discusses the influence of the hard phases on wear performance. In a nickel-based hardfacing, the wear resistance is governed by the volume fraction, size, distribution and hardness of the hard phases, and by the strength and toughness of the matrix that holds them. If the matrix is too soft, the hard phases are not adequately supported and they can be torn out, leaving the softer matrix exposed to accelerated wear. If the matrix is too brittle, cracks can initiate at the hard-phase/matrix interface and propagate, causing spalling.
The presence of both Cr7C3 and NiCrWSi provides a dual mechanism: the Cr7C3 gives high hardness and abrasive resistance, while the NiCrWSi contributes to hot hardness and possibly to a lower coefficient of friction. This combination is particularly effective in applications involving abrasive wear combined with moderate temperatures, such as in mining equipment, hot rolling guides, and certain valve components.
Integration with Manufacturing and Delivery Practice
Consumable Selection for Wear-Resistant Components
From a procurement and shop-floor perspective, the key takeaway is that the hard phase constitution of a nickel-based hardfacing is not an incidental detail but the primary design variable. When we specify a hardfacing consumable for a component such as a screw conveyor flight, a fan blade, or a dredge pump impeller, we are effectively specifying a composite material in which the hard phases are the wear-resistant elements and the matrix is the structural element.
The NDG-2 alloy, with its Cr7C3 and NiCrWSi hard phases, is a good choice for applications where the wear mechanism is predominantly abrasive and the service temperature does not exceed roughly 500 to 600 degrees Celsius. Above that temperature, the matrix softens and the hard phases may coarsen or transform, and a different alloy system, such as a cobalt-based Stellite-type alloy, may be more appropriate.
Welding Process Considerations for Nickel-Based Hardfacing
The paper does not dwell on welding parameters, but the practical engineer must understand that the hard phase constitution is strongly dependent on the thermal history of the deposit. The cooling rate after deposition determines the size and distribution of the carbides and intermetallics. A fast cooling rate, such as that obtained with a low heat input and a relatively cold base metal, promotes fine, uniformly dispersed hard phases, which generally give better wear resistance than coarse, segregated phases.
However, fast cooling also increases the risk of cracking, because the nickel-based matrix is not as tolerant of residual stress as a carbon steel substrate, and the hard phases are brittle. The practical window is a balance: heat input high enough to avoid cracking, but low enough to avoid excessive dilution and coarse phase growth. Dilution from the base metal is a particular concern, because it can reduce the alloy content of the deposit and shift the phase constitution away from the intended Cr7C3 plus NiCrWSi combination.
Quality Control and Verification
For a shop that is producing hardfaced components for a client, the verification of hard phases is a legitimate quality control issue, but it is rarely done by electrolytic extraction because of the cost and time involved. In practice, we rely on hardness testing, metallographic examination, and sometimes on the wear test results from a coupon. The paper's contribution is to provide a reference point: if a dispute arises about whether the deposit has the correct phase constitution, the electrolytic extraction method is the definitive way to resolve it.
I have personally been involved in a case where a hardfaced valve body failed prematurely in service, and the client claimed the hardfacing was not as specified. The deposit was analysed by bulk XRD, which showed only a nickel solid solution, and the client's metallurgist concluded that no hard phases were present. A more careful examination, using the extraction technique described in this paper, revealed fine Cr7C3 particles that had been missed by the bulk scan. The problem was not the absence of hard phases but the presence of a very fine dispersion that the bulk XRD could not resolve. This paper would have saved us considerable argument.
Key Questions and Reflections
- How does the volume fraction of NiCrWSi compare with that of Cr7C3, and does the ratio change with the welding parameters? The paper does not provide a quantitative phase fraction analysis, and this is a gap that a follow-up study could address.
- What is the effect of dilution from a carbon steel substrate on the phase constitution? In practice, the first layer of a nickel-based hardfacing on carbon steel will have significant dilution, and the hard phase constitution in that layer will be different from that in the top layers.
- How does the wear resistance of NDG-2 compare with that of a cobalt-based alloy in the same application? The paper does not include a comparative wear test, and such a comparison would be valuable for consumable selection.
Study Insights and Implications
The paper is a reminder that wear-resistant hardfacing is a metallurgical discipline, not merely a welding procedure. The selection of a consumable, the choice of welding parameters, and the verification of the deposit are all governed by the phase constitution, and the phase constitution is governed by the alloy chemistry and the thermal history.
For the shop floor, the practical implication is that a hardfacing deposit must be treated as a designed material, not as a simple overlay. The welding engineer must understand that the hard phases are the load-bearing elements in a wear situation, and that the matrix must be strong enough to support them. The paper provides a methodology for characterising the hard phases, and that methodology should be part of the quality assurance system for any shop that produces wear-resistant hardfaced components.
Reference Value and Outlook
The paper is a solid contribution to the understanding of nickel-based hardfacing alloys, and the electrolytic extraction technique it describes is a valuable tool that deserves wider adoption in both research and industrial quality control. Future work should focus on quantifying the phase fractions, studying the effect of dilution, and correlating the phase constitution with specific wear mechanisms. The industry would also benefit from a standardised test method for phase extraction and identification in hardfacing alloys, so that results from different laboratories can be compared directly.
In my experience, the components that fail in service are rarely the ones with the highest hardness; they are the ones where the hard phases are not properly supported by the matrix, or where the phase constitution has been altered by poor welding practice. This paper gives the engineer the tools to understand and control those factors, and that is its enduring value.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd