High-Temperature Oxidation Behaviour of Iron-Based Composite Surfacing Layers on 20G Steel
Literature Overview and Technical Context
This paper by Duan Moran from the Zhangjiakou Power Generation Branch of Datang International Power Generation Company, published in Materials Reports in 2025, investigates the high-temperature oxidation characteristics of FeCrSiMnNbB alloy composite surfacing layers deposited on 20G steel by tungsten inert gas (TIG) arc welding. The work is motivated by the severe wear conditions experienced by coal mill grinding rolls in power plants, and it seeks to understand not only the wear resistance but also the oxidation behaviour of the surfacing layer under the high temperatures generated during the grinding process.
The paper is particularly interesting because it takes a holistic approach, combining the design of the surfacing alloy with the welding process and the resulting microstructure. The alloy composition, FeCrSiMnNbB, is described as being inspired by the design rules of amorphous alloy coating systems, and the welding process uses circulating water cooling to achieve a high cooling rate. The paper reports that the surfacing layer has better high-temperature oxidation resistance than the 20G steel substrate, and that a double-layer surfacing has better oxidation resistance than a single-layer surfacing.
Interpretation of Core Technical Points
The Alloy Design Philosophy
The FeCrSiMnNbB alloy is a high-chromium iron-based alloy with additions of silicon, manganese, niobium, and boron. The high chromium content provides the basis for oxidation resistance, because it promotes the formation of a protective chromium oxide scale. The silicon addition also contributes to oxidation resistance, because silicon oxide can form a protective layer at the scale/metal interface. The boron addition promotes the formation of hard borides, which contribute to wear resistance, and it also acts as a fluxing agent during welding, improving the wetting of the substrate.
The niobium addition is interesting. Niobium is a strong carbide former, and it can promote the formation of fine, stable carbides that contribute to wear resistance. It can also refine the grain structure, which is beneficial for both wear resistance and oxidation resistance, because a finer grain size promotes the formation of a more uniform and adherent oxide scale.
The paper describes the alloy as being designed according to the principles of amorphous alloy coating systems. Amorphous alloys are characterised by a high glass-forming ability, which is achieved by a combination of elements with different atomic sizes and negative heats of mixing. The FeCrSiMnNbB system has these characteristics, and the high cooling rate achieved by the water-cooled welding process can promote the formation of a partially amorphous or nanocrystalline structure.
The Effect of Cooling Rate on Microstructure
The paper highlights the importance of the cooling rate in determining the microstructure of the surfacing layer. The circulating water cooling during the welding process increases the cooling rate of the molten pool, which suppresses grain growth and promotes the formation of fine grains and nanocrystalline phases. The paper reports that this high cooling rate promotes the spontaneous formation of nanophases, which contribute to both the wear resistance and the oxidation resistance.
This is a critical insight. In a conventional surfacing process, the cooling rate is relatively slow, and the microstructure is coarse, with large grains and coarse carbides. The high cooling rate achieved by the water-cooled TIG process produces a much finer microstructure, which has a higher hardness and a better combination of wear resistance and oxidation resistance.
The Effect of Multi-Pass Surfacing on Dilution
The paper also addresses the effect of multi-pass surfacing on the dilution rate. In a multi-pass surfacing, the first layer is diluted by the base metal, and its composition is different from that of the subsequent layers. The second layer, deposited on top of the first layer, is diluted by the first layer, which has a composition closer to the intended alloy composition. Therefore, the second layer has a lower dilution rate and a composition closer to the nominal alloy composition.
The paper reports that the double-layer surfacing has better oxidation resistance than the single-layer surfacing, and this is attributed to the lower dilution rate of the second layer. The lower dilution means a higher concentration of chromium and other alloying elements, which promotes the formation of a more protective oxide scale.
Oxidation Mechanism and Kinetics
The paper uses the oxidation weight gain kinetics curves, along with SEM-EDS, XRD, and optical microscopy, to characterise the oxidation behaviour. The oxidation weight gain curves show that the surfacing layer has a lower oxidation rate than the 20G steel, and that the double-layer surfacing has a lower oxidation rate than the single-layer surfacing.
The SEM-EDS and XRD analysis would reveal the composition and structure of the oxide scale. A protective chromium oxide scale, Cr2O3, is expected to form on the surfacing layer, while a less protective iron oxide scale, which is more porous and less adherent, would form on the 20G steel. The presence of silicon in the alloy would also promote the formation of a silica layer at the scale/metal interface, which can further reduce the oxidation rate.
Integration with Manufacturing and Delivery Practice
The Application Context: Coal Mill Grinding Rolls
The application context is the coal mill grinding roll, which is a critical component in a power plant. The grinding roll operates in a severe abrasive wear environment, and the grinding process generates significant heat, which can cause the surface temperature of the roll to reach several hundred degrees Celsius. The combination of abrasive wear and high temperature creates a demanding service condition that requires a surfacing material with both high wear resistance and high-temperature oxidation resistance.
The paper's approach, using a FeCrSiMnNbB alloy deposited by water-cooled TIG welding, is a practical solution to this problem. The water-cooled welding process is not new, but its application to the surfacing of grinding rolls is an innovative approach that addresses the need for a high cooling rate to achieve a fine microstructure.
The Practical Challenges of Water-Cooled TIG Surfacing
The water-cooled TIG surfacing process has several practical challenges. The water cooling must be applied in a way that does not interfere with the welding process, and it must be controlled to achieve the desired cooling rate without causing excessive thermal stress or cracking. The water cooling also increases the risk of hydrogen-induced cracking, because the water can introduce hydrogen into the weld zone, and the high cooling rate can trap the hydrogen in the microstructure.
In practice, the water cooling is typically applied to the back side of the substrate or through a copper backing plate, rather than directly to the weld pool. This allows the cooling to be controlled without introducing hydrogen into the weld zone.
The Economic and Operational Considerations
The economic viability of the water-cooled TIG surfacing process depends on the cost of the consumable, the cost of the welding process, and the service life of the surfaced component. The FeCrSiMnNbB alloy is a relatively low-cost iron-based alloy, compared with nickel-based or cobalt-based alloys, and the TIG process is a well-established and reliable welding process. The increased service life of the grinding roll, due to the improved wear resistance and oxidation resistance, would need to justify the additional cost of the water-cooling system.
From an operational perspective, the water-cooled TIG surfacing process is more complex than a conventional surfacing process, and it requires a higher level of operator skill. The welding procedure must be carefully developed and qualified, and the process parameters must be closely monitored during production.
Key Questions and Reflections
- How does the oxidation resistance of the FeCrSiMnNbB surfacing layer compare with that of a conventional high-chromium iron-based surfacing alloy? The paper does not provide a direct comparison, but the high cooling rate and the alloy design are expected to provide an improvement.
- What is the effect of the water cooling rate on the residual stress in the surfacing layer? The high cooling rate could increase the residual stress, which could lead to cracking or spalling in service.
- How does the wear resistance of the surfacing layer change after high-temperature oxidation? The oxide scale could act as a solid lubricant, reducing the wear rate, or it could spall and accelerate the wear.
Study Insights and Implications
The paper is a valuable contribution to the field of surfacing technology, because it demonstrates the importance of the cooling rate in determining the microstructure and properties of a surfacing layer. The use of water-cooled TIG welding to achieve a high cooling rate is an innovative approach that could be applied to other surfacing applications.
For the shop floor, the practical implication is that the cooling rate is a critical process parameter that must be controlled to achieve the desired microstructure and properties. The paper provides a basis for developing a welding procedure specification for the water-cooled TIG surfacing of grinding rolls, and it highlights the importance of multi-pass surfacing in achieving the desired composition and properties.
Reference Value and Outlook
The paper is a recent contribution, published in 2025, and it reflects the current state of the art in surfacing technology. The use of amorphous alloy design principles in the development of surfacing alloys is a promising approach that could lead to new consumables with improved properties.
Future work should focus on the long-term performance of the surfacing layer in actual service conditions, including the combined effects of wear and oxidation. The paper provides a good foundation for such work, and it should be followed by field trials on actual grinding rolls.
The paper is a reminder that the properties of a surfacing layer are not determined solely by the alloy composition, but also by the welding process and the resulting microstructure. The cooling rate is a critical parameter that is often overlooked, and this paper demonstrates its importance in a clear and convincing way.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd