Repair Surfacing of Medium-Speed Coal Mill Grinding Rollers: A Veteran's Assessment
Why Grinding Rollers Fail and Why Repair Beats Replacement
The medium-speed coal mill is one of the workhorses of a power plant, and the grinding roller is its most abused component. The roller surface sees a combination of abrasive wear from coal and pyrites, impact from large coal lumps, and thermal cycling from the hot gas stream. The result is a predictable failure mode: the surface wears down, the profile changes, and the mill's grinding efficiency drops. When the roller is worn beyond a certain point, the mill cannot maintain its output, and the plant faces a choice — replace the roller or repair it.
The economics are not subtle. A new grinding roller is a major capital item, often with a long lead time. A repair, using a high-chromium high-carbon flux-cored wire, can be done on site or in a local workshop, typically in a fraction of the time and cost. The study from 1999 makes this point clearly, and the logic has not changed in the decades since. What has changed is the quality of the consumables and the process control available.
The study used a specially formulated high-chromium high-carbon flux-cored wire. This is the right choice for coal mill rollers, because the service condition is abrasive wear with some impact. High chromium gives you hard carbides; high carbon gives you a martensitic matrix that holds those carbides in place. The combination produces a surface that resists gouging and scratching, which is exactly what coal grinding demands.
The Repair Process: What the Shop Floor Actually Does
The study describes the process in general terms, but the practical details are where the success or failure is determined. Based on my experience with hardfacing repairs on similar components, the process follows a clear sequence:
| Process Step | Critical Parameter | Typical Range | Failure Mode if Ignored |
|---|---|---|---|
| Surface preparation | Remove all cracked and fatigued material | Grind to sound metal | Cracks propagate through new overlay |
| Preheating | Roller temperature before welding | 150–250 °C for high-chromium wire | Hydrogen cracking in the HAZ |
| Interpass temperature | Maintain between passes | 200–300 °C | Overheating causes grain growth and loss of hardness |
| Welding technique | Stringer beads, not weave | 3–5 mm bead width | Excessive dilution and distortion |
| Post-weld cooling | Slow cooling in still air | No forced cooling | Cracking from thermal shock |
| Post-weld inspection | Hardness and crack detection | 55–62 HRC typical | Overlay fails in service |
The preheat is not optional. High-chromium hardfacing wire produces a deposit that is essentially a high-alloy tool steel. It is hard, and it is prone to hydrogen cracking if the substrate is cold. The study does not emphasize this enough, in my view. I have seen rollers crack during repair because the welder skipped the preheat, thinking that the roller was already hot from the mill operation. That is a dangerous assumption. The roller may be hot on the surface, but the core is still cold, and the thermal gradient can be worse than a cold start.
The welding technique matters more than most people think. Stringer beads, laid in a controlled pattern, give you a uniform overlay with consistent dilution. Weave beads give you a wider deposit but also more dilution and more residual stress. For a grinding roller, the surface profile matters — you are rebuilding a specific geometry, and the weld pattern determines whether you achieve it.
Field Performance and the Real Lesson
The study reports that the repaired rollers performed well in field service, with a significant increase in service life. This is the kind of result that makes a repair program worthwhile, but it comes with a caveat: the repair is only as good as the process control behind it. I have seen repair programs fail because the workshop treated the roller like any other weldment, ignoring the special requirements of hardfacing.
The critical insight is that a repaired roller is not a new roller. It is a composite — a new hardfacing layer on a worn substrate that has already seen fatigue and thermal cycling. The substrate may have microcracks that are not visible to the naked eye. The repair process must account for this by removing a sufficient depth of material before welding. The study's approach of using a specially formulated wire is correct, but the surface preparation is equally important.
In my experience, the most common cause of repair failure is not the consumable. It is inadequate surface preparation. If the old hardfacing is not completely removed, the new layer will not bond properly, and the repair will spall off in service. The study does not dwell on this, but it is the practical lesson that matters.
Concluding Reflection
This is a practical, results-oriented study that demonstrates the value of repair surfacing for a critical power plant component. The technical content is sound, and the field results are encouraging. For a practicing engineer, the takeaway is clear: repair is a viable alternative to replacement, provided you use the right consumable and the right process. The high-chromium high-carbon flux-cored wire is the right choice for coal mill rollers, and the process must include proper preheat, controlled interpass temperature, and thorough surface preparation. The study is a useful reference, but it is not a complete process specification. The engineer must fill in the details from experience, and that is where the real value lies. In the field, I have seen repair programs save plants millions of dollars and weeks of downtime. I have also seen them fail spectacularly when the process was rushed. The difference is always process discipline, and this study is a reminder of that.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd