ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Hardfacing of Sintered Ore Crusher Toothed Rollers: Material Selection and Weldability Considerations

1. Literature Overview and Core Technical Question

This 2003 paper by Zhang Baochen, Liu Xin, and Wang Zhiqiang from Handan Iron and Steel Group and CITIC Heavy Machinery addresses a critical maintenance problem in sinter plants: the wear of toothed rollers in hot ore crushers. The authors describe the hardfacing of these rollers with wear-resistant weld deposits, focusing on the selection of welding consumables and the development of a suitable welding procedure.

The paper is particularly relevant to my experience because it deals with a component that operates under severe conditions: high temperature, abrasive ore, and impact loading. The toothed rollers in a sinter hot ore crusher must withstand both abrasive wear and impact fracture, which places conflicting demands on the hardfacing material. A material that is too hard will resist abrasion but will crack under impact; a material that is too tough will resist impact but will wear rapidly.

The paper's key technical points can be summarized as follows:

Parameter Typical Value or Consideration
Base material Cast steel or forged steel roller body
Hardfacing process Manual metal arc welding (SMAW) or flux-cored arc welding (FCAW)
Hardfacing alloy Martensitic stainless steel or high-chromium iron
Deposit hardness HRC 50-60 depending on service conditions
Preheat temperature 200-350°C to prevent cracking
Interpass temperature 250-400°C to maintain consistent deposit properties
Post-weld treatment Stress relief at 400-600°C for large rollers

2. Metallurgical Interpretation and Process Windows

The paper's central metallurgical insight is that the hardfacing material must be selected based on the specific wear mechanism. In a sinter hot ore crusher, the primary wear mechanism is abrasive wear from the ore particles, but there is also a significant impact component from the crushing action. The authors therefore recommend a material that combines high hardness with sufficient toughness to resist impact fracture.

The paper discusses the use of different hardfacing consumables, including:

  1. Martensitic stainless steel electrodes: These provide a deposit with hardness in the range of HRC 45-55, with good toughness and moderate wear resistance. They are suitable for applications where impact resistance is important.
  2. High-chromium iron electrodes: These provide a deposit with hardness in the range of HRC 55-65, with excellent abrasive wear resistance but lower toughness. They are suitable for applications where abrasion is the primary wear mechanism.
  3. Composite electrodes with tungsten carbide particles: These provide a deposit with very high hardness and excellent abrasive wear resistance, but they are expensive and difficult to deposit.

The authors emphasize that the selection of the hardfacing material must be based on the specific service conditions. For a sinter hot ore crusher, where both abrasion and impact are present, a martensitic stainless steel deposit with a hardness of HRC 50-55 is often the best choice.

The paper also discusses the welding procedure, emphasizing the importance of preheat and interpass temperature control. The toothed rollers are large components, and the welding process generates significant heat input. Without adequate preheat, the rapid cooling of the deposit can cause cracking. Without interpass temperature control, the deposit can overheat, causing grain growth and reduced toughness.

3. Engineering Practice and Lessons from the Field

The paper's focus on sinter hot ore crusher toothed rollers is directly relevant to my experience in the steel pipe industry. While we do not manufacture these rollers, we do face similar challenges in hardfacing of components that must withstand severe wear and impact — particularly in pipe forming rolls and other components in the production line.

One lesson I have learned over the years is that the preparation of the component before hardfacing is critical. The toothed roller must be thoroughly cleaned of any oil, grease, or oxide before welding. In addition, any cracks or defects in the base material must be repaired before hardfacing, as these defects can propagate through the deposit during service.

Another lesson is that the welding procedure must be carefully developed and qualified. The paper's authors describe the development of a welding procedure, but I would emphasize that this procedure must be qualified according to the relevant standards, such as ASME Section IX or ISO 15614. This involves welding test coupons, performing mechanical tests, and verifying that the deposit meets the required hardness and toughness.

In my experience, the most common failure modes for hardfaced toothed rollers are:

  1. Cracking of the deposit: This occurs when the deposit is too hard and brittle, or when the preheat and interpass temperatures are insufficient.
  2. Spalling of the deposit: This occurs when the deposit separates from the substrate, often due to inadequate fusion or excessive residual stress.
  3. Excessive wear of the teeth: This occurs when the deposit hardness is too low, often due to excessive dilution or incorrect alloy selection.

The paper's authors address these issues through material selection and process control, but I would add that the welding procedure must be qualified before production welding. This involves welding test coupons, performing hardness tests, and verifying that the deposit meets the required properties.

4. Reflections and Study Insights

This paper, while focused on a specific application, reinforces several principles that I have found to be essential in hardfacing applications:

First, the material selection must be based on the specific wear mechanism. A material that is too hard will crack under impact; a material that is too tough will wear prematurely. The sweet spot is a material that combines sufficient hardness with adequate toughness.

Second, the welding procedure must be developed and qualified. This involves selecting the correct consumables, establishing the correct preheat and interpass temperatures, and verifying that the deposit meets the required properties.

Third, the quality of the hardfaced component depends on the preparation and the welding procedure. A poorly prepared surface will result in poor fusion and premature failure. A poorly developed welding procedure will result in cracking or spalling.

In my own practice, I have seen hardfacing operations that extended the service life of a component by three to five times, at a cost of only 30-50% of the replacement cost. This is a significant economic benefit, but it requires careful process control and quality assurance.

5. Conclusion

This paper on hardfacing of sinter hot ore crusher toothed rollers is a practical contribution to the field of surface engineering. Its authors correctly identify the key factors that determine the success of a hardfacing operation: material selection, welding procedure development, and process control. The paper's emphasis on matching the hardfacing material to the specific wear mechanism is particularly valuable.

For engineers in the steel pipe and pipe fitting industry, the lessons from this paper apply directly to hardfacing of forming rolls, guide rolls, and other wear-resistant components. The principles of material selection, preheat, interpass temperature control, and post-weld treatment are universal, and the importance of procedure qualification cannot be overstated.

I would recommend this paper to any engineer who is considering hardfacing as a means to extend the service life of a component. The paper is practical and focused, and it contains the essential principles that must be understood before attempting a hardfacing operation. In the end, the success of a hardfacing operation depends on the engineer's understanding of the metallurgy, the process, and the service conditions.