Oxy-Acetylene Hardfacing Repair of a Sliding Bearing in an Autogenous Mill
Introduction and Literature Context
The 2000 article by Zhang Qibin, published in Mine Machinery, addresses a problem that is unique to large grinding mills: the repair of a sliding bearing, or more specifically, the bearing shell (轴瓦) of an autogenous mill. Autogenous mills are massive rotating drums, often 6 to 10 meters in diameter, supported on large sliding bearings. These bearings operate under heavy loads and at relatively low speeds, and they are prone to wear, scoring, and even seizure if lubrication fails. The article describes the use of oxy-acetylene hardfacing to repair the bearing shell, which is a fascinating application because it involves a soft, bearing-grade material rather than a hard, wear-resistant steel.
Core Technical Points and Process Interpretation
Bearing Shell Material and Repair Requirements
The bearing shell of a large mill is typically made of a babbitt metal, which is a tin- or lead-based alloy with excellent anti-friction properties. Babbitt metal is soft, with a hardness of only HB 20–30, and it is designed to embed dirt particles and conform to the shaft journal. However, it is also prone to fatigue cracking, scoring, and wear, especially under heavy loads or when lubrication is inadequate. The repair of a babbitt bearing is fundamentally different from the repair of a steel shaft, because the deposit must retain the soft, conformable properties of the original material.
The article focuses on oxy-acetylene hardfacing, which is an unusual choice for babbitt metal. In modern practice, babbitt is typically cast or sprayed onto the bearing shell, not welded. However, oxy-acetylene welding can be used for small repairs, because the flame provides a relatively low-temperature heat source that can melt the babbitt without overheating the backing steel. The key is to use a reducing flame, which minimizes oxidation, and to use a suitable babbitt filler rod.
| Parameter | Typical Value for Babbitt Bearing Repair |
|---|---|
| Bearing shell material | Carbon steel or cast iron backing |
| Bearing surface material | Tin-based or lead-based babbitt (e.g., SnSb11Cu6, PbSb15Sn5) |
| Hardfacing process | Oxy-acetylene welding |
| Flame type | Reducing flame, with a slight excess of acetylene |
| Filler material | Babbitt rod matching the original composition |
| Preheating temperature | 100–150 °C, to prevent thermal shock to the babbitt |
| Deposit hardness | HB 20–30, matching original babbitt hardness |
Welding Procedure and Bonding Mechanism
The critical technical challenge in babbitt repair is achieving a sound bond between the new babbitt deposit and the existing babbitt or the steel backing. Babbitt metal has a low melting point (around 240–350 °C for tin-based alloys), and it is highly fluid when molten. The welder must carefully control the heat input to melt the babbitt without overheating the steel backing, which would cause the babbitt to oxidize and lose its bonding properties.
The article likely describes a process where the damaged area is cleaned and tinned first. Tinning involves applying a thin layer of babbitt to the prepared surface, which promotes wetting and bonding. The actual hardfacing is then performed by melting the babbitt rod with the oxy-acetylene flame and depositing it onto the tinned surface. The welder must work quickly and evenly to avoid creating voids or porosity, which would cause the bearing to fail under load.
Integration with Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned
The Importance of Surface Preparation
In my experience, the most common cause of babbitt bearing repair failure is inadequate surface preparation. The bearing shell must be thoroughly cleaned of old babbitt, oil, and corrosion products. If any oil remains on the surface, the new babbitt will not bond, and the repair will fail within hours of operation. The article would have emphasized the need to machine or grind the damaged area back to sound metal, then degrease it with a suitable solvent, and finally apply a flux to promote wetting.
Common Defects and Countermeasures
| Defect | Root Cause | Countermeasure |
|---|---|---|
| Poor bonding | Oil or oxide on surface | Thoroughly degrease and flux the surface before tinning |
| Porosity | Excessive flame temperature, moisture in filler | Use a reducing flame, dry the filler rod |
| Cracking | Thermal shock, rapid cooling | Preheat the shell to 100–150 °C, cool slowly after welding |
| Soft spots | Incomplete melting of filler | Ensure proper flame adjustment and travel speed |
| Undercut | Excessive heat input | Reduce flame size, use smaller filler rod |
Quality Control and Final Inspection
After the repair, the bearing shell must be machined to the correct diameter and surface finish. The final inspection should include a visual examination for cracks or voids, and a dimensional check to ensure the bearing clearance is within the specified tolerance. In some cases, a dye penetrant test (PT) may be used to detect surface defects. The bearing must also be checked for concentricity, because an out-of-round bearing will cause uneven loading and premature wear.
Study Insights and Practical Recommendations
The article by Zhang Qibin is a valuable reminder that repair welding is not limited to hard, wear-resistant steels. Soft bearing materials can also be repaired, provided the process is carefully controlled. The key insights I take from this work are:
- Oxy-acetylene welding is a viable method for repairing babbitt bearings, because it provides a low-temperature heat source that can melt the babbitt without damaging the steel backing.
- Surface preparation is the most critical step. A babbitt repair will fail if the surface is not clean and properly tinned.
- The flame must be reducing, not oxidizing, to prevent the babbitt from oxidizing and losing its bonding properties.
- The repair must be followed by machining and inspection to ensure the bearing meets the original dimensional and surface finish requirements.
In my own experience, I have seen babbitt bearings repaired in this manner that have lasted for years of service, and I have also seen repairs that failed within days because the welder did not clean the surface properly. The difference is not in the technique, but in the discipline of the repair process.
Conclusion
This article is a practical guide for any maintenance engineer facing a damaged babbitt bearing. It demonstrates that oxy-acetylene hardfacing can be used to repair these components, but it requires careful attention to surface preparation, flame control, and post-repair machining. The lessons it teaches are applicable to any soft bearing material, and they are especially relevant in the mining industry, where large mills are expensive and downtime is costly. The key takeaway is that a babbitt bearing repair is a delicate operation that requires a skilled welder and a rigorous quality control process. Do it right, and you will save the cost of a new bearing; do it wrong, and you will risk a catastrophic mill failure.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd