ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Application of Hardfacing Technology in the Repair of Coal Mine Fully Mechanized Mining Equipment

Introduction and Literature Context

The 2007 article by Zhang Xinhua and Li Jing, published in Mine Machinery, addresses a practical problem that is common in the coal mining industry: the repair of worn components in fully mechanized mining equipment. The article focuses on the repair of scraper conveyor chutes (溜槽), which are subject to severe abrasive wear from coal and rock. The authors describe their experience with a large modern mine with an annual production capacity of 1.5 million tons, where two fully mechanized mining faces are equipped with scraper conveyors. After one service cycle, the chutes suffer severe localized wear, and the mine faces the choice of scrapping them or repairing them.

Core Technical Points and Process Interpretation

The Economic Case for Repair

The article's opening statement is a classic example of the economic logic behind repair welding. The chutes are expensive, and after one service cycle, they are worn but not completely destroyed. The authors state that they have tried various materials and processes to repair the chutes, but the results were unsatisfactory. This is a common problem in the mining industry, where the wear pattern is often localized. For example, the chute sections that are directly under the coal feed point wear much faster than the sections further down the conveyor. The key to a successful repair is to identify the wear pattern and apply a hardfacing material that matches the wear mechanism.

Hardfacing Material Selection for Abrasive Wear

The choice of hardfacing material for a scraper conveyor chute is critical. The wear mechanism is primarily abrasive, caused by the sliding of coal and rock over the chute surface. The hardfacing material must be hard enough to resist abrasion, but it must also have sufficient toughness to withstand impact from large rocks. The most common choice for this application is a chromium carbide hardfacing alloy, which provides excellent abrasion resistance.

Parameter Typical Value for Chute Hardfacing
Base material Hardox 400/450 or similar wear-resistant steel
Hardfacing material Chromium carbide alloy (e.g., AWS EFeCr-A1, EFeCr-A2)
Hardfacing process Flux-cored arc welding (FCAW) or submerged arc welding (SAW)
Deposit hardness HRC 55–65
Deposit thickness 3–5 mm, depending on wear depth
Preheating temperature 100–150 °C for thicker sections
Interpass temperature 200–250 °C, to avoid excessive heat input

Welding Procedure and Wear Pattern Analysis

The article emphasizes that the repair must be based on a thorough analysis of the wear pattern. In a scraper conveyor, the chute sections that are directly under the coal feed point experience the most severe wear. The repair strategy should be to build up the worn areas with a hardfacing material, and then to apply a final layer of a chromium carbide alloy to provide the wear-resistant surface. The welder must use a weaving technique to ensure uniform coverage and to avoid excessive dilution of the hardfacing material into the base metal.

Integration with Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned

The Importance of Process Control

The article's mention of unsatisfactory results with previous repair attempts is a valuable lesson. In my experience, the most common cause of hardfacing repair failure is inadequate process control. The welder may use the wrong consumable, the wrong welding parameters, or may not preheat the component properly. The result is a deposit that is either too soft (and wears out quickly) or too brittle (and cracks under impact). The article's authors likely learned this lesson the hard way, and their article is a guide to doing it right.

Common Defects and Countermeasures

Defect Root Cause Countermeasure
Cracking in the deposit High hardness, excessive heat input Use preheat, reduce heat input, use a more ductile hardfacing alloy
Spalling Poor bonding, high residual stress Ensure proper surface preparation, use a buffer layer if necessary
Porosity Moisture in flux-cored wire Dry the wire, use a shielding gas with low dew point
Excessive dilution High heat input, incorrect travel speed Reduce heat input, increase travel speed
Uneven deposit Poor technique, incorrect weaving Use a consistent weaving pattern, maintain a constant travel speed

Quality Control and Final Inspection

For a scraper conveyor chute, the final inspection should include a visual examination for cracks, a hardness survey across the deposit, and a dimensional check to ensure the chute is not distorted. In some cases, a dye penetrant test (PT) may be used to detect surface cracks. The chute must also be checked for flatness, because a distorted chute will not fit properly in the conveyor and may cause chain jamming.

Study Insights and Practical Recommendations

The article by Zhang Xinhua and Li Jing is a practical guide for any maintenance engineer in the coal mining industry. It demonstrates that hardfacing repair is a viable option for scraper conveyor chutes, but it requires careful attention to material selection, welding procedure, and quality control. The key insights I take from this work are:

  1. The economic case for repair is strong. A scraper conveyor chute is expensive, and a hardfacing repair can extend its service life by several months at a fraction of the cost of a new chute.
  2. The wear pattern must be analyzed before selecting a repair strategy. The hardfacing material and deposit thickness should be matched to the wear mechanism.
  3. Chromium carbide hardfacing alloys are the best choice for abrasive wear in coal mining applications. They provide excellent abrasion resistance and can be applied with standard welding equipment.
  4. Process control is critical. The welder must use the correct consumable, welding parameters, and preheat temperature to achieve a sound deposit.

In my own experience, I have seen scraper conveyor chutes repaired in this manner that have lasted for several more service cycles. I have also seen repairs that failed because the welder used a hardfacing alloy that was too brittle, and the deposit cracked under impact. The difference is in the selection of the hardfacing material and the control of the welding process.

Conclusion

This article is a valuable contribution to the field of hardfacing repair in the coal mining industry. It demonstrates that scraper conveyor chutes can be repaired effectively using chromium carbide hardfacing alloys, provided that the wear pattern is analyzed and the welding process is controlled. The economic benefits are significant, because the repair cost is a fraction of the replacement cost, and the downtime is minimized. The key takeaway is that a successful hardfacing repair requires a systematic approach: analyze the wear pattern, select the appropriate hardfacing material, control the welding process, and inspect the finished repair. This article provides a practical guide for any maintenance engineer facing the challenge of repairing worn mining equipment.