ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Tubular Composite Hardfacing Electrodes with Tungsten Carbide: A Veteran's Assessment

Introduction and Context

The 2007 paper by Wang Weimin and colleagues, published in Cemented Carbide, describes the development of a tubular composite hardfacing electrode containing tungsten carbide (WC) particles in an Fe-C alloy matrix. The electrode is designed for use in hardfacing oil drilling tools, where severe abrasive wear and impact are common. The authors report that the new electrode performs as well as, or better than, similar products from abroad, and that it significantly improves the service life of drilling tools compared to traditional tubular electrodes with cast tungsten carbide.

From my perspective, this paper is a classic example of product development driven by a specific industrial need. The oil and gas industry has always been a major consumer of hardfacing materials, and the demand for improved performance has driven the development of new and better products. The paper's focus on the design and manufacturing of the electrode, as well as its performance testing, provides valuable insights into the key factors that determine the quality of a hardfacing deposit.

Core Technical Points and Interpretation

The paper describes the design and manufacture of a tubular electrode that contains a mixture of cast tungsten carbide (CTC) and sintered tungsten carbide (STC) particles in a Fe-C alloy matrix. The electrode is made by rolling a steel strip into a tube, filling it with the carbide particles and alloy powders, and then closing the tube.

The key technical points are:

  1. Selection of Hard Phase: The paper compares cast tungsten carbide (CTC) and sintered tungsten carbide (STC). CTC is hard and wear-resistant but brittle. STC is tougher but slightly less hard. By mixing the two, the authors achieve a balance of wear resistance and toughness.
  2. Matrix Alloy Design: The Fe-C alloy matrix is designed to have a hardness that is sufficient to support the carbide particles without being so hard that it becomes brittle. The matrix also must have good wetting with the carbide particles to ensure a strong bond.
  3. Manufacturing Process: The manufacturing process must ensure that the carbide particles are uniformly distributed within the tube and that the tube is properly sealed to prevent the loss of powder during welding. The paper describes the steps of rolling, filling, and closing the tube, and emphasizes the importance of quality control during each step.
  4. Welding Performance: The electrode is designed for use with a conventional arc welding process, such as gas metal arc welding (GMAW) or flux cored arc welding (FCAW). The welding parameters must be carefully controlled to ensure that the carbide particles are not burned or dissolved in the weld pool.

Comparison of Carbide Types

Property Cast Tungsten Carbide (CTC) Sintered Tungsten Carbide (STC)
Hardness (HV) 2400 - 3000 1600 - 2200
Toughness Low Moderate
Shape Irregular, angular Spherical, rounded
Bond with Matrix Moderate Good
Wear Resistance Excellent Good
Impact Resistance Poor Moderate

The paper's key innovation is the use of a mixture of CTC and STC. This allows the hardfacing layer to combine the high wear resistance of CTC with the toughness of STC. The result is a deposit that can withstand both abrasive wear and impact, which is essential for drilling tools.

Practical Lessons and Engineering Judgment

From a practical standpoint, the paper highlights several important considerations for anyone using hardfacing electrodes:

  1. Welding Parameter Control: The welding parameters, particularly current and voltage, have a significant effect on the quality of the hardfacing deposit. Too high a current will cause the carbide particles to dissolve, reducing wear resistance. Too low a current will result in poor fusion and porosity.
  2. Deposit Thickness: The thickness of the hardfacing layer must be sufficient to provide adequate wear life, but not so thick that it causes cracking or distortion. The paper suggests that a deposit thickness of 3-5 mm is typically appropriate.
  3. Preheat and Interpass Temperature: For hardfacing on high-carbon or alloy steels, preheating and controlling the interpass temperature is essential to prevent cracking. The paper does not discuss this in detail, but it is a critical factor in practice.
  4. Quality Control: The quality of the hardfacing deposit must be verified using hardness testing, metallographic examination, and, in some cases, non-destructive testing (NDT). The paper describes the testing of the deposit's microstructure and hardness, which is a good practice.

Key Questions and Reflections

The paper raises a question that is central to the use of hardfacing materials: how do you define "improved service life"? The paper reports that the new electrode improves the service life of drilling tools, but it does not provide a quantitative measure of the improvement. In my experience, the evaluation of hardfacing materials requires a combination of laboratory testing and field trials. Laboratory tests, such as the dry sand/rubber wheel abrasion test, provide a relative measure of wear resistance. Field trials provide the ultimate proof of performance, but they are expensive and time-consuming.

Study Insights and Implications

The paper is a valuable reference for anyone involved in the development or use of hardfacing materials. It demonstrates that the design of the electrode, including the selection of the hard phase and the matrix alloy, is critical to the performance of the hardfacing deposit.

For our industry, the lessons are directly applicable. We use hardfacing electrodes to protect pipe fittings and other components from wear. The principles of carbide selection, matrix design, and welding parameter control are just as important in our applications as they are in oil drilling tools.

Conclusion

The 2007 study on tubular composite hardfacing electrodes with tungsten carbide is a well-executed example of product development driven by an industrial need. The paper's key contribution is the design of a composite electrode that combines the wear resistance of cast tungsten carbide with the toughness of sintered tungsten carbide. The reported performance, which matches or exceeds that of foreign products, is a testament to the effectiveness of the design. For those of us who have spent years on the shop floor, the paper is a reminder that the best hardfacing material is not the one with the highest hardness, but the one that is best suited to the specific conditions of the application.