Parameter Optimization for Tungsten Carbide/Ni-Based Composite Coating by PTA Hardfacing: A Practical Guide
Introduction and Context
The 2018 paper by Ying Wei and colleagues, published in Transactions of Nonferrous Metals Society of China, addresses a topic that is central to the effective use of plasma transferred arc (PTA) hardfacing: the optimization of welding parameters to minimize the degradation of tungsten carbide (WC) particles in the deposit. The paper uses an orthogonal experimental design to determine the optimal values for welding current, powder feed rate, and welding speed, and it characterizes the microstructure and microhardness of the resulting coating.
From my perspective, having spent decades working with hardfacing processes, this paper is a valuable contribution to the practical understanding of PTA hardfacing. The paper's focus on parameter optimization, and its demonstration of the importance of controlling the heat input to prevent carbide degradation, provides important insights for anyone involved in the application of WC/Ni-based composite coatings.
Core Technical Points and Interpretation
The paper describes the use of PTA hardfacing to deposit a Ni-based composite coating with a high content of tungsten carbides (Stelcar 65 composite coating). The key technical points are:
- Orthogonal Experimental Design: The paper uses an orthogonal array (L9) to design the experiments, with three factors (welding current, powder feed rate, and welding speed) and three levels for each factor. This allows the authors to determine the optimal combination of parameters with a relatively small number of experiments.
- Carbide Degradation: The paper identifies the degradation of WC particles as the primary concern. Degradation can occur in two ways:
- Dissolution: The WC particles dissolve in the molten Ni-based matrix, leading to a loss of hardness and wear resistance.
- Decarburization: The carbon in the WC reacts with oxygen in the atmosphere, forming CO or CO2, which leads to the formation of W2C or W3C and a loss of carbon.
- Optimal Parameters: The paper determines that the optimal values for welding current, powder feed rate, and welding speed are 100 A, 25 g/min, and 40 mm/min, respectively. These values produce a coating that is free of cracks and carbide degradation.
- Microstructure: The paper characterizes the microstructure of the optimal coating, showing that the WC particles are uniformly distributed in the Ni-based matrix and that there is a good bond between the particles and the matrix.
- Microhardness: The paper reports the microhardness of the optimal coating, showing that it is significantly higher than that of the substrate.
Influence of Welding Parameters on Carbide Degradation
| Parameter | Effect on Carbide Degradation | Optimal Value |
|---|---|---|
| Welding Current | Higher current increases heat input, leading to more dissolution | 100 A |
| Powder Feed Rate | Higher feed rate increases the amount of carbide in the deposit, but may lead to poor fusion | 25 g/min |
| Welding Speed | Higher speed reduces heat input, but may lead to lack of fusion | 40 mm/min |
Practical Lessons and Engineering Judgment
From a practical standpoint, the paper highlights several important considerations for anyone using PTA hardfacing:
- Heat Input Control: The heat input is the most critical factor in determining the quality of the hardfacing deposit. Too high a heat input will cause the WC particles to dissolve, reducing wear resistance. Too low a heat input will result in poor fusion and porosity.
- Powder Feed Rate: The powder feed rate must be matched to the welding current and speed to ensure that the correct amount of powder is deposited. Too high a feed rate can result in an uneven deposit and poor fusion. Too low a feed rate will result in a thin deposit that may not provide adequate wear life.
- Welding Speed: The welding speed must be controlled to ensure that the deposit is uniform and that the heat input is consistent. Too high a speed can result in a thin deposit and poor fusion. Too low a speed can result in excessive heat input and carbide degradation.
- Shielding Gas: The paper does not discuss the shielding gas in detail, but it is a critical factor in PTA hardfacing. The shielding gas must be inert to prevent oxidation of the WC particles and the Ni-based matrix. Argon is typically used.
- Preheat and Interpass Temperature: For hardfacing on high-carbon or alloy steels, preheating and controlling the interpass temperature is essential to prevent cracking. The paper does not discuss this in detail, but it is a critical factor in practice.
Key Questions and Reflections
The paper raises a question that is central to the use of PTA hardfacing: how do you determine the optimal parameters for a specific application? The paper uses an orthogonal experimental design, which is a systematic and efficient method. However, the optimal parameters determined in the laboratory may not be directly applicable to production, where the component geometry and the welding position may be different.
In my experience, the optimization of hardfacing parameters requires a combination of laboratory testing and production trials. Laboratory testing provides a relative measure of performance, but production trials are necessary to validate the parameters and to identify any issues related to the specific component geometry.
Study Insights and Implications
The paper is a valuable reference for anyone involved in the application of WC/Ni-based composite coatings. It provides a clear demonstration of the importance of parameter optimization and the use of orthogonal experimental design as a systematic method for determining the optimal parameters.
For our industry, the lessons are directly applicable. We use PTA hardfacing to protect pipe fittings and other components from wear. The principles of heat input control, powder feed rate, and welding speed are just as important in our applications as they are in the applications described in the paper.
Conclusion
The 2018 study on parameter optimization for tungsten carbide/Ni-based composite coating by PTA hardfacing is a well-executed investigation that provides valuable practical guidance for anyone using this process. The paper's use of orthogonal experimental design to determine the optimal parameters, and its demonstration of the importance of controlling heat input to prevent carbide degradation, are important contributions to the field. The reported optimal parameters (100 A, 25 g/min, 40 mm/min) provide a good starting point for anyone developing a PTA hardfacing procedure. For those of us who have spent years on the shop floor, the paper is a reminder that the quality of a hardfacing deposit is determined not by the equipment, but by the skill and knowledge of the operator in controlling the process parameters.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd