Development of HYDCrMo Submerged Arc Hardfacing Flux-Cored Wire
Literature Overview and Context
This paper by Yu Shengfu and colleagues from Huazhong University of Science and Technology and Wuhan Iron Anchor Group describes the development of a martensitic stainless steel type HYDCrMo submerged arc hardfacing flux-cored wire. The work was supported by the Hubei Province Science and Technology Research Project. The authors report that the hardfaced layer has a microstructure of martensite with a small amount of retained austenite, and fine carbide particles are dispersed on the martensite matrix. The bond strength of the hardfaced layer was determined to be high. The wire, when used with HJ260 flux, exhibits good welding process performance. After post-weld tempering heat treatment, the hardness of the hardfaced layer is 51 to 53 HRC, with a hardness non-uniformity of ±1.5 HRC.
Interpretation of Technical Points
The development of a flux-cored wire for submerged arc hardfacing is a significant contribution because it addresses the need for a high-deposition-rate process that can produce a hard, wear-resistant layer with good toughness. The martensitic stainless steel composition is a good choice for applications that require both wear resistance and corrosion resistance, such as the hardfacing of rolls for the steel industry and the repair of components in the mining and cement industries. The microstructure of martensite with dispersed carbides is the key to achieving a good combination of hardness and toughness. The presence of a small amount of retained austenite is beneficial because it provides some ductility and helps to prevent the formation of cracks during the hardfacing process. The fine carbide particles contribute to the wear resistance by providing hard second-phase particles in the matrix.
The hardness of 51 to 53 HRC after tempering is a typical value for a martensitic stainless steel hardfacing. The hardness non-uniformity of ±1.5 HRC is an excellent result, indicating that the flux-cored wire produces a very consistent deposit. This is important for applications where the hardfaced surface will be machined, as a uniform hardness will result in a more consistent machining operation and a better surface finish.
Process and Standards Analysis
The use of HJ260 flux with the HYDCrMo wire is a critical aspect of the development. The flux must be matched to the wire composition to ensure that the weld metal has the desired chemistry and that the process is stable. HJ260 is a fused flux with a high basicity, which is suitable for welding stainless steels. The good welding process performance reported by the authors is a result of the proper matching of the flux and the wire. The post-weld tempering heat treatment is essential to achieve the final hardness of 51 to 53 HRC. In the as-welded condition, the hardfaced layer would be harder and more brittle, and it would be prone to cracking. The tempering treatment reduces the hardness slightly but improves the toughness and reduces the residual stresses.
The submerged arc process is a high-deposition-rate process, which makes it suitable for the hardfacing of large components. However, the process is characterized by a high heat input, which can lead to a large heat-affected zone in the base metal and to a higher dilution of the hardfacing alloy with the base metal. The dilution must be controlled to ensure that the hardfaced layer has the desired properties. The paper does not explicitly state the dilution level, but it is a critical parameter in the submerged arc hardfacing process.
Integration with Engineering Practice
In the regeneration of machine parts, the use of a flux-cored wire for submerged arc hardfacing offers several advantages over solid wires. The flux-cored wire can contain alloying elements that are difficult to incorporate into a solid wire, and it can also contain deoxidizers and slag formers that improve the weld quality. The high deposition rate of the submerged arc process makes it economical for the hardfacing of large areas. The paper's finding that the bond strength is high is a critical result, as it confirms that the hardfaced layer will not spall or delaminate in service.
In my experience, the hardfacing of rolls for the steel industry is a demanding application. The rolls are subjected to high loads and high temperatures, and the hardfaced layer must have a combination of wear resistance, toughness, and resistance to thermal fatigue. The HYDCrMo wire, with its martensitic stainless steel composition, is a good candidate for this application. The hardness of 51 to 53 HRC is in the range that is typically used for this type of application.
Key Questions and Reflections
One question that the paper does not fully address is the wear resistance of the hardfaced layer in different types of wear conditions. The paper focuses on the hardness and the microstructure, but it does not present the results of abrasive wear tests or impact wear tests. In practice, the wear resistance is a function of the hardness, the microstructure, and the type of wear mechanism. A martensitic stainless steel with dispersed carbides will have good abrasive wear resistance, but its impact wear resistance may be limited by the brittleness of the martensite.
Another question is the effect of the post-weld tempering temperature on the properties of the hardfaced layer. The paper reports a tempering treatment that results in a hardness of 51 to 53 HRC, but it does not present the effect of different tempering temperatures on the hardness and the toughness. In practice, the tempering temperature must be carefully controlled to achieve the desired balance of properties.
Study Insights and Implications
The development of the HYDCrMo flux-cored wire is a significant contribution to the field of hardfacing. The wire offers a combination of high hardness, good toughness, and good process performance. The use of a flux-cored wire allows for the incorporation of alloying elements that would be difficult to include in a solid wire, and the submerged arc process provides a high deposition rate. The paper is a good example of the development of a new welding consumable that is tailored to a specific application.
Reference Value and Outlook
This paper is a valuable reference for engineers involved in the development and application of hardfacing consumables. The composition and the properties of the HYDCrMo wire can be used as a starting point for the development of new wires for specific applications. The paper also highlights the importance of the flux-wire combination in the submerged arc hardfacing process. In the future, I expect to see more development of flux-cored wires for hardfacing, with a focus on improving the wear resistance and the toughness of the deposits. The paper is a reminder that the development of a new welding consumable is a complex process that requires a thorough understanding of the metallurgy, the process, and the application.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd