Post-Weld Heat Treatment of K360 Steel Surfacing: Balancing Hardness and Toughness
Literature Overview and the K360 Steel Context
This 2011 paper by Deng Hanzhong and Wang Dayong from Liaoning Technical University addresses a classic trade-off in hardfacing: hardness versus toughness. K360 is a wear-resistant steel used in mining equipment, and the paper studies the repair of worn K360 components by flux-cored wire CO2 gas shielded surfacing. The authors then applied a post-weld heat treatment (tempering at approximately 400°C) and compared the microstructure, hardness, impact toughness, and abrasive wear resistance of the as-welded and heat-treated deposits. The results are clear and useful: the as-welded deposit is martensitic with carbides and has high hardness but poor toughness; the heat-treated deposit is tempered troostite with carbides and has slightly lower hardness but significantly better toughness.
Technical Points: The Microstructure-Hardness-Toughness Triangle
The paper's key contribution is in quantifying the effect of tempering on the surfacing layer. The as-welded structure is martensite plus network carbides plus blocky carbides plus a small amount of retained austenite. This structure is hard but brittle. After tempering at 400°C, the martensite transforms to tempered troostite, the retained austenite decomposes, and the carbides remain but are more uniformly distributed. The hardness drops slightly, but the impact toughness improves significantly. The wear resistance, as measured by abrasive wear testing, remains good — the heat-treated deposit achieved 1.32 times the wear resistance of the base metal, compared to 1.46 times for the as-welded deposit.
| Condition | Microstructure | Hardness | Impact Toughness | Relative Wear Resistance |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| As-welded | Martensite + network carbides + blocky carbides + retained austenite | High | Poor | 1.46x base metal |
| Tempered at 400°C | Tempered troostite + carbides | Slightly lower | Significantly better | 1.32x base metal |
Engineering Practice: The Repair Decision
The practical question for a plant engineer is whether to temper or not. The answer depends on the application. For a component that is subjected to pure abrasive wear, the as-welded deposit is better because it is harder. For a component that is subjected to impact or cyclic loading, the tempered deposit is better because it is tougher. In many mining applications, the wear mechanism is a combination of abrasion and impact, and the tempered deposit is the safer choice. The paper's data supports this: the tempered deposit retains 90% of the wear resistance of the as-welded deposit while achieving a significant improvement in toughness.
Key Questions and Reflections
The paper raises a question that I have seen debated many times: what is the optimum tempering temperature? The authors used 400°C, which is a reasonable choice for a martensitic steel. Too low a temperature and the residual stress is not relieved; too high a temperature and the hardness drops below an acceptable level. The optimum depends on the specific alloy and the service conditions. For K360 steel, 400°C appears to be a good compromise. The paper also highlights the importance of post-weld heat treatment as a means of controlling residual stress. A hardfacing deposit on a thick section will have significant residual stress, and if it is not relieved, the component may crack in service.
Study Insights and Implications
This paper is a solid example of the kind of systematic study that should be done for every hardfacing application. The authors did not just measure hardness; they measured toughness and wear resistance, and they correlated the results with the microstructure. This is the right approach. For engineers working on hardfacing repairs, the takeaway is to think about the service conditions before choosing the post-weld heat treatment. If the component will see impact, temper it. If it will see pure abrasion, maybe you can skip the temper. But always remember that residual stress is a hidden killer. A hardfacing deposit that is not tempered may look perfect on the surface and crack catastrophically in service.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd