ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

EBSD Analysis of Microstructure of EQ309L Stainless Steel Strip Cladding on Q345R Base Metal

Literature Overview and Practical Context

The paper by Zhao Fei and colleagues from Taiyuan University of Science and Technology addresses a topic that is critical in the fabrication of pressure vessels and reactors: the strip cladding of stainless steel on carbon steel. The authors used electron backscatter diffraction (EBSD) to characterize the microstructure of the EQ309L cladding, the Q345R base metal, and the interface between them. The results provide valuable insights into the grain structure, the transition zone, and the texture of the cladding.

This is a topic that I have dealt with extensively in the fabrication of pipe fittings and pressure vessel components. The Q345R base metal is a common pressure vessel steel, and the EQ309L cladding is used to provide corrosion resistance. The interface between the two is critical because it determines the integrity of the cladding. If the interface is weak, the cladding can delaminate, leading to catastrophic failure.

Microstructural Analysis and Interpretation

The authors used EBSD to characterize the microstructure in three regions: the EQ309L side, the Q345R side, and the interface. The results show that the Q345R base metal has a banded grain structure, which is a result of the rolling process. The average grain size in the overheated coarse-grain region is 30-40 μm, while in the fine-grain region it is 10-20 μm. This is a significant difference, and it reflects the thermal history of the base metal during the cladding process.

Region Average Grain Size Microstructural Features
Q345R Coarse-Grain Region 30-40 μm Banded grains, significant distortion
Q345R Fine-Grain Region 10-20 μm Equiaxed grains, less distortion
Transition Zone Not specified bcc structure, 35-40 μm from fusion line
EQ309L Cladding Coarse, columnar Strong texture, dendritic growth

The transition zone is particularly interesting. The authors report that it extends 35-40 μm from the fusion line into the cladding, and it has a body-centered cubic (bcc) structure. This is the region where dilution occurs, and the composition changes from the carbon steel to the stainless steel. The bcc structure is a result of the high dilution of the carbon steel, which stabilizes the ferrite phase.

The EQ309L cladding has a coarse columnar grain structure with a strong texture. This is typical of a weld deposit, where the grains grow epitaxially from the fusion line. The texture is a result of the directional solidification, which favors certain crystallographic orientations.

Dilution Control and Its Practical Implications

The most important practical implication of this paper is the control of dilution. In strip cladding, the dilution is a function of the welding parameters, the strip width, and the composition of the flux. The authors do not provide the welding parameters, but the microstructure suggests that the dilution is relatively high, as evidenced by the bcc structure in the transition zone.

In my experience, the dilution in strip cladding is typically 10-20%. The first layer of cladding will have a higher dilution than subsequent layers. This is why it is common to deposit two or more layers. The first layer provides a transition, and the second layer provides the required corrosion resistance.

The bcc structure in the transition zone is a concern because it can be susceptible to hydrogen-induced cracking. The carbon steel base metal has a higher carbon content than the stainless steel cladding, and the transition zone can have a martensitic structure if the cooling rate is too high. This is a classic problem in dissimilar metal welding.

The authors do not discuss this, but I would recommend that the following measures be taken:

  1. Preheat the base metal to reduce the cooling rate and prevent martensite formation.
  2. Use a low-hydrogen flux to minimize the hydrogen content in the weld.
  3. Control the heat input to ensure adequate mixing but not excessive dilution.
  4. Post-weld heat treatment to relieve residual stresses.

Texture and Its Effect on Corrosion Resistance

The strong texture in the EQ309L cladding is another important finding. The texture is a result of the directional solidification, and it can affect the corrosion resistance. In a textured material, the corrosion rate can vary with orientation. The authors do not discuss this, but it is a potential concern.

In my experience, the texture in a weld deposit is not usually a problem for corrosion resistance, as long as the composition is correct. However, if the texture is very strong, it can lead to localized corrosion. This is more of a concern in a wrought product than in a weld deposit.

The columnar grain structure is also a concern because it can be susceptible to solidification cracking. The grains grow from the fusion line, and the boundaries between them are weak. If the welding parameters are not correct, the grains can grow in a way that promotes cracking.

Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned

This paper provides valuable data on the microstructure of a strip cladding. The EBSD technique is a powerful tool for characterizing the grain structure and texture. The results show that the cladding has a complex microstructure with a transition zone, a columnar grain structure, and a strong texture.

For the practicing engineer, the key takeaways are:

  1. The dilution in strip cladding is significant, and it creates a transition zone with a bcc structure.
  2. The grain structure in the cladding is columnar, with a strong texture.
  3. The base metal has a banded grain structure, which is a result of the rolling process.

I would recommend that this paper be used as a reference for anyone involved in strip cladding. The data on grain size and texture is useful for understanding the properties of the cladding. However, I would also recommend that the study be extended to include the mechanical properties of the cladding, such as the tensile strength and impact toughness. The microstructure is important, but the mechanical properties are what determine the performance of the cladding in service.

Study Insights and Recommendations

The use of EBSD for the analysis of strip cladding is a valuable contribution to the field. The technique provides detailed information on the grain structure and texture that is not available from conventional microscopy. The results show that the cladding has a complex microstructure with a transition zone, a columnar grain structure, and a strong texture.

However, I would caution that the paper only reports on one set of welding parameters. The microstructure of a strip cladding is highly dependent on the welding parameters, and a different set of parameters could result in a different microstructure. A parametric study would be more useful for practical applications.

I would also recommend that the study be extended to include the mechanical properties of the cladding. The microstructure is important, but the mechanical properties are what determine the performance of the cladding in service. The tensile strength, impact toughness, and hardness of the cladding should be measured.

Conclusion

The EBSD analysis of the EQ309L stainless steel strip cladding on Q345R base metal provides valuable insights into the microstructure of the cladding. The results show that the cladding has a columnar grain structure with a strong texture, and that there is a transition zone with a bcc structure. The base metal has a banded grain structure, which is a result of the rolling process. These findings are important for understanding the properties of the cladding and for optimizing the welding parameters. For the practicing engineer, this paper is a useful reference for anyone involved in strip cladding. I would recommend that the study be extended to include the mechanical properties of the cladding and a parametric study of the welding parameters. The cost of a failed cladding is not just the cost of the repair; it is the cost of downtime, lost production, and the risk of catastrophic failure. A thorough understanding of the microstructure and properties of the cladding is the only way to ensure success.