Microstructure and Properties of 310 Stainless Steel CMT Surfacing on Q235 Steel
Core Technical Points from the Literature
The paper by Liu Yang and Liu Aiguo presents a practical study on the use of the Cold Metal Transfer (CMT) welding process to apply a 310 stainless steel (H12Cr26Ni21Si) surfacing layer onto a Q235 carbon steel substrate. The CMT process is a modified MIG/MAG welding process that is characterized by a very low heat input and a controlled metal transfer.
The authors used specific welding parameters: a welding current of 108 A, a welding voltage of 15.8 V, a weaving width of 12 mm, a weaving speed of 23 mm/s, a welding speed of 2 mm/s, and an overlap of 7 mm. These parameters resulted in a surface layer that was well-formed, dense, and free of defects.
The key findings are:
- The microstructure of the surfacing layer consists of austenitic dendrites and equiaxed grains.
- The main elements in the surfacing layer are Ni, Cr, and Fe.
- The hardness of the surfacing layer is higher than that of the base metal.
- The shear strength of the bond interface between the surfacing layer and the base metal is greater than 405 MPa.
Engineering Practice and Lessons Learned
This paper is a good example of how process selection can solve a metallurgical problem. The CMT process is specifically designed to minimize heat input. This is critical when surfacing a stainless steel onto a carbon steel, because the high heat input of a conventional MIG or TIG process can cause significant dilution.
Dilution is the mixing of the base metal into the weld metal. When you surface a stainless steel onto a carbon steel, the carbon from the base metal can be diluted into the stainless steel layer. This can lead to the formation of chromium carbides, which deplete the chromium from the matrix and reduce the corrosion resistance. This is a serious problem, especially in applications where the component will be exposed to a corrosive environment.
The CMT process, with its low heat input, minimizes dilution. This ensures that the stainless steel layer retains its intended chemical composition and its corrosion resistance. The authors found that the main elements in the surfacing layer were Ni, Cr, and Fe, which is consistent with the composition of the 310 stainless steel filler metal. This indicates that the dilution was minimal.
The shear strength of the bond interface is another critical parameter. A shear strength of greater than 405 MPa is a good result. It indicates that the bond between the stainless steel layer and the carbon steel substrate is strong and reliable. This is essential for ensuring that the surfacing layer does not spall or delaminate in service.
Standards and Specifications: Where the Gaps Are
The CMT process is a relatively new addition to the welding industry, and it is not explicitly covered in many standards. However, the general requirements for welding procedure qualification still apply.
| Standard / Specification | Relevance | Practical Application |
|---|---|---|
| ASME BPVC Section IX | Welding procedure qualification | Requires qualification of the specific process, base metal, and filler metal combination. |
| AWS D1.1 | Structural welding code | Provides general requirements for welding quality and inspection. |
| ASTM A240 / A480 | Specification for stainless steel plate | Defines the chemical composition and mechanical properties of the 310 stainless steel. |
The key point is that the welding procedure must be qualified, and the qualification testing must include a metallographic examination and mechanical testing. The metallographic examination should confirm that the surfacing layer is free of defects and that the microstructure is acceptable. The mechanical testing should confirm that the bond strength meets the requirements.
Key Questions and Reflections
- What is the maximum allowable dilution? This is a critical question. The dilution must be low enough to maintain the corrosion resistance of the stainless steel layer. In my experience, a dilution of less than 10% is generally acceptable for this type of application.
- What is the effect of the weaving pattern? The authors used a weaving width of 12 mm and a weaving speed of 23 mm/s. This weaving pattern helps to ensure a uniform thickness and a smooth surface. However, it also affects the heat input and the dilution. The weaving parameters must be carefully controlled.
- What is the role of the overlap? The overlap of 7 mm ensures that the adjacent beads are properly fused. If the overlap is too small, there may be a lack of fusion between the beads. If the overlap is too large, it may lead to excessive heat input and dilution.
Study Insights and Implications for Practice
This paper demonstrates the benefits of using the CMT process for stainless steel surfacing. The low heat input is a significant advantage, as it minimizes dilution and preserves the corrosion resistance of the stainless steel layer. This is a critical consideration for applications where the component will be exposed to a corrosive environment.
For the fabricator, this paper provides a clear set of process parameters that can be used to achieve a high-quality stainless steel surfacing layer. The parameters are specific to the CMT process and the 310 stainless steel filler metal, but they provide a good starting point for process development.
For the engineer, this paper highlights the importance of considering the dilution when selecting a surfacing process. The CMT process is an excellent choice for this application, but it is not the only option. Other low-heat-input processes, such as laser cladding or plasma transferred arc (PTA) surfacing, can also be used. The selection of the process should be based on the specific requirements of the application, including the corrosion resistance, the bond strength, and the cost.
Conclusion and Outlook
The research by Liu Yang and Liu Aiguo provides a valuable contribution to the field of stainless steel surfacing. The CMT process, with its low heat input, is an excellent choice for applying a 310 stainless steel layer onto a carbon steel substrate. The resulting surfacing layer has a good microstructure, a high hardness, and a strong bond with the base metal. This paper provides a clear set of process parameters that can be used to achieve a high-quality result. The industry should continue to explore the use of CMT and other low-heat-input processes for surfacing applications, as they offer significant advantages in terms of dilution control and weld quality. The key is to select the right process for the specific application and to qualify the procedure thoroughly.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd