Microstructure Evolution in Plasma Arc Welded Fe90 Hardfacing Layers under Different Welding Parameters
Literature Overview and Test Setup
The paper by Shi Duanhu, Zhang Wenbo, Sha Jing and Yang Feng from Xuzhou University of Technology, published in the Journal of Xuzhou Institute of Technology (Natural Science Edition) (2018, Vol. 33, No. 2, pp. 47-51), investigates the microstructure evolution of plasma arc welded hardfacing layers under different welding parameters. The work was supported by the Jiangsu Provincial Natural Science Foundation (BK20141143) and the Jiangsu Provincial University Natural Science Research Major Project (16KJA430003). The authors used plasma arc welding to deposit Fe90 alloy powder onto 16mm low carbon steel plates, and then examined the microstructure of the clad layers using optical metallography and scanning electron microscopy.
Fe90 is a well-known iron-based hardfacing alloy, typically containing around 0.9% carbon, with chromium, molybdenum, and other alloying elements. It is designed to produce a high-hardness deposit with good wear resistance, and it is commonly used for hardfacing of mining equipment, agricultural implements, and other components subject to abrasive wear. The substrate in this study is 16mm low carbon steel, which is a typical structural steel used in many industrial applications.
The key experimental variables were welding current and powder feed rate. The authors examined how these two parameters influenced the microstructure of the clad layer, including grain size, phase composition, and the distribution of carbides. This is a practical question that every welding engineer faces: how do I set the parameters to get the best balance of hardness and toughness in a hardfacing deposit?
Microstructure Interpretation and Phase Analysis
The authors found that the clad layer consisted primarily of martensite, retained austenite, and eutectic carbides. This is a classic microstructure for a high-carbon, high-alloy iron-based hardfacing alloy. The martensite provides high hardness, the retained austenite provides some toughness and ductility, and the eutectic carbides provide wear resistance. The combination of these three phases determines the overall performance of the deposit.
The microstructure showed a clear gradient across the clad layer. In the weld zone, the grains were fine and equiaxed, which is a result of rapid solidification and the high cooling rate in the weld pool. In the near-weld zone, the microstructure was primarily dendritic, with columnar grains growing from the fusion boundary. In the middle of the clad layer, the microstructure was predominantly equiaxed, with a more uniform distribution of grains and carbides. This gradient is a direct result of the thermal history of the deposit. The weld zone cools rapidly, producing fine grains. The near-weld zone experiences a slower cooling rate, allowing dendritic growth. The middle of the clad layer cools at an intermediate rate, producing a mix of dendritic and equiaxed structures.
The presence of retained austenite is interesting. In a high-carbon alloy, the transformation from austenite to martensite is not complete because the carbon content lowers the martensite start temperature (Ms) below room temperature. This means that some austenite is retained at room temperature. The retained austenite is beneficial for toughness but detrimental for hardness. The authors do not quantify the amount of retained austenite, but its presence is confirmed by the microstructural analysis.
The eutectic carbides are the key to wear resistance. In Fe90, the high carbon and chromium content promotes the formation of chromium-rich carbides, which are hard and wear-resistant. The size, shape, and distribution of these carbides determine the wear performance. Fine, uniformly distributed carbides are better than coarse, clustered carbides because they provide a more uniform hard phase and reduce the risk of carbide pull-out during abrasive wear.
Effect of Welding Current and Powder Feed Rate
The authors found that increasing the welding current caused the grain size in the clad layer to increase, and the grain distribution became more uniform. This is a logical result. Higher welding current means more heat input, which increases the size of the weld pool and slows the cooling rate. A slower cooling rate allows more time for grain growth, resulting in larger grains. The more uniform distribution at higher current is likely due to better mixing and more uniform heat distribution in the larger weld pool.
Increasing the powder feed rate caused the grain size to decrease and the microstructure to become more uniform. This is also logical. A higher powder feed rate means more powder is deposited per unit time, which absorbs more of the heat from the plasma arc. This reduces the heat input to the substrate and increases the cooling rate, resulting in finer grains. The more uniform distribution is likely due to the higher powder concentration in the weld pool, which promotes more homogeneous nucleation.
These two findings have important practical implications. If you want a fine-grained microstructure with good hardness and toughness, you should use a lower welding current and a higher powder feed rate. If you want a more uniform microstructure, you should use a higher welding current and a higher powder feed rate. The optimal combination depends on the specific application and the properties you are trying to achieve.
Engineering Practice and Process Window Considerations
In the hardfacing of pipe and fitting components, we typically use plasma arc welding or other arc welding processes to deposit a wear-resistant layer on the surface of a component. The most common applications are hardfacing of valve seats, pump impellers, and other components subject to abrasive or erosive wear. The process parameters must be carefully controlled to achieve the desired microstructure and properties.
The findings of this paper suggest that we should pay close attention to the welding current and powder feed rate when setting up a plasma arc hardfacing operation. If we set the current too high, we get a coarse-grained microstructure with lower hardness and potentially reduced wear resistance. If we set the current too low, we risk lack of fusion or poor bonding. If we set the powder feed rate too high, we may get an excessively thick deposit with poor fusion at the interface. If we set the powder feed rate too low, we get a thin deposit with high dilution and degraded properties.
In practice, we would establish the process window by performing a series of test runs, varying the current and powder feed rate, and examining the resulting microstructures and hardness profiles. We would then select the parameters that give the best combination of hardness, toughness, and wear resistance for the specific application. The paper provides a useful starting point, but the optimal parameters will depend on the specific substrate material, the powder composition, the component geometry, and the service conditions.
One additional consideration is the effect of the plasma arc on the substrate. Plasma arc welding produces a concentrated heat source with a high energy density, which can cause significant heat input to the substrate. This can lead to distortion, residual stress, and in some cases, cracking. The authors used a 16mm low carbon steel plate, which is relatively thick and can absorb a significant amount of heat without distortion. For thinner components, the heat input must be carefully controlled to avoid distortion and warping.
Summary and Reflection
This paper provides a clear and practical insight into the microstructure evolution of plasma arc welded Fe90 hardfacing layers. The finding that increasing welding current increases grain size while increasing powder feed rate decreases grain size is directly applicable to the selection of process parameters in production. The gradient microstructure, with fine grains in the weld zone, dendritic growth in the near-weld zone, and equiaxed grains in the middle, is a result of the thermal history of the deposit and should be understood by anyone involved in hardfacing operations.
For the pipe and fitting industry, the key takeaway is that the process parameters must be carefully selected to achieve the desired microstructure and properties. A fine-grained microstructure with uniformly distributed carbides is the goal, and this can be achieved by using a lower welding current and a higher powder feed rate. However, the process window is narrow, and the parameters must be validated for each specific application. I would recommend that any engineer setting up a plasma arc hardfacing operation study this paper and use the findings as a starting point for their own process development. The insights are practical, the data is clear, and the implications for production are direct and actionable.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd