ZHUOJIN-LOGOZhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd
STEEL PIPE · FITTING · WELDING  |  NOTES FROM A 30-YEAR INDUSTRY VETERAN

Total Focusing Method Ultrasonic Testing of Main Pipe Welds with Stainless Steel Cladding

The Problem of Cladding Noise

The paper addresses a common issue in nuclear and petrochemical plants: ultrasonic inspection of welds with austenitic stainless steel cladding. The cladding has a coarse, anisotropic grain structure that scatters ultrasound, creating high structural noise. This makes it difficult to detect defects in the underlying weld. The paper by Zhao et al. investigates the use of the Total Focusing Method (TFM) to improve signal-to-noise ratio (SNR).

TFM Principles and Array Optimization

TFM uses a phased array to focus at every point in the imaging region. The paper shows that increasing the number of elements from 16 to 64 improves SNR by 5.3 dB and reduces the array performance index by 35%. This is because more elements provide better focusing and averaging of the noise. The table below summarizes the results.

Number of Elements SNR Improvement (dB) Array Performance Index Reduction (%)
16 0 0
32 2.8 18
64 5.3 35

Phase Coherent Imaging Enhancement

The paper further applies Phase Coherent Imaging (PCI) to the TFM images. PCI weights the signals based on phase coherence, effectively suppressing incoherent noise. For the 64-element array, PCI improves SNR by an additional 13.19 dB and reduces the array performance index by 65%. This is a significant improvement, making defect detection much more reliable.

Shop Floor and Site Implementation

In practice, this technique is valuable for inspecting main pipe welds with cladding. However, the implementation requires a skilled operator and proper calibration. The TFM image must be interpreted carefully, as artifacts can still appear. I would recommend a procedure that includes a reference block with side-drilled holes to verify the performance. Also, the inspection must be performed after the weld is fully cooled to avoid thermal effects. The cost of TFM equipment is higher, but the improved detection capability justifies it for critical welds.

Conclusion

The study demonstrates that TFM with PCI is an effective method for inspecting cladded pipe welds. The key is to use a sufficient number of elements and apply PCI to enhance SNR. For field application, I would specify a minimum of 64 elements and require a demonstration on a mock-up. The technique can reduce the risk of missed defects, which is critical for safety-critical components. However, it requires careful validation and operator training to be effective.