Metallurgical Understanding of Stainless Steel Overlay Disbonding
The Disbonding Phenomenon in Service
Stainless steel overlay cladding is used extensively in pressure vessels and reactors that handle hydrogen at high temperature and pressure, particularly in hydroprocessing units in refineries. The purpose of the overlay is to provide corrosion resistance while the base metal provides the strength and the low cost. The problem is that after a period of service, the overlay can separate from the base metal, a phenomenon known as disbonding or stripping. This is a catastrophic failure mode because it exposes the carbon steel base metal to the hydrogen environment, which can lead to hydrogen embrittlement and a sudden, violent rupture of the vessel. The paper by Xu Ying and colleagues from Shanghai Jiao Tong University and East China University of Science and Technology is a classic study of the metallurgical factors that drive this failure. They used electrolytic hydrogen charging to simulate the hydrogen uptake that occurs in service, and they examined the microstructure and the composition of the transition zone before and after post-weld heat treatment.
Role of Carbon and Chromium Migration
The authors found that after post-weld heat treatment, there was significant migration of carbon and chromium in the transition zone. This is a well-known phenomenon in dissimilar metal welds and claddings. During the heat treatment, carbon from the base metal diffuses into the stainless steel overlay, where it reacts with chromium to form chromium carbides. This leaves a zone in the base metal adjacent to the interface that is depleted of carbon, known as a decarburized zone, and a zone in the overlay that is enriched with carbides, known as a carburized zone. The carbides are hard and brittle, and they create a plane of weakness at the interface. When hydrogen enters the steel, it accumulates at this interface, and the combination of the brittle carbide layer, the hydrogen pressure, and the residual stress from welding and heat treatment leads to a crack that propagates along the interface. The authors showed that in the region where hydrogen-induced disbonding cracks were observed, there was a sharp change in the carbon and alloy element distribution, which confirms that the carbide precipitation and the resulting compositional gradient are the root cause of the problem.
Hydrogen, Defects, and Stress Interaction
The study also highlighted the role of microstructural defects and stress in the disbonding process. The authors noted that carbide precipitates, phase transformation products, vacancies, and dislocations all interact with the hydrogen and the stress field to create the conditions for crack initiation and growth. Hydrogen atoms are small and they diffuse readily through the steel, but they tend to accumulate at traps such as dislocations, grain boundaries, and carbide interfaces. When the hydrogen concentration reaches a critical level, the pressure inside the traps can exceed the local fracture strength, and a microcrack forms. The residual stress from welding and post-weld heat treatment adds to the driving force, and once a crack initiates at the interface, it propagates along the carbide-rich zone because that is the path of least resistance. The table below summarises the key factors that contribute to disbonding and the practical measures that can be taken to mitigate it.
| Contributing Factor | Mechanism | Mitigation Measure |
|---|---|---|
| Carbon migration | Carbon diffuses from base metal to overlay during PWHT, forming carbides. | Use a low carbon base metal or a nickel-based buffer layer. |
| Chromium carbide precipitation | Chromium in overlay reacts with carbon to form brittle carbides at the interface. | Control PWHT temperature and time to minimise carbide formation. |
| Hydrogen accumulation | Hydrogen diffuses into the steel and accumulates at the interface. | Reduce hydrogen input during welding; use low-hydrogen consumables. |
| Residual stress | Welding and PWHT create tensile stress at the interface. | Optimise the welding sequence and use a stress-relief heat treatment. |
| Dislocation and vacancy traps | Microstructural defects provide sites for hydrogen concentration. | Refine the grain size and reduce the number of defects in the overlay. |
Practical Prevention in Fabrication
For the fabrication shop, the lessons from this study are clear and actionable. The first is that post-weld heat treatment is a double-edged sword. It relieves residual stress, which is good, but it also promotes carbon migration and carbide precipitation, which is bad. The solution is to control the PWHT parameters carefully, using the lowest temperature and the shortest time that will achieve the required stress relief. In some cases, a nickel-based buffer layer is applied between the carbon steel base and the stainless steel overlay. The nickel layer has a low carbon solubility, so it acts as a barrier that prevents carbon from diffusing into the stainless steel, and it also has a coefficient of thermal expansion that is intermediate between the two steels, which reduces the thermal stress at the interface. The second lesson is that hydrogen control is essential. The welding consumables must be low hydrogen, the welding area must be clean and dry, and the hydrogen must be allowed to diffuse out of the steel before the vessel is put into service. A post-weld hydrogen removal heat treatment, typically at a temperature of 200 to 300 degrees Celsius for several hours, can be very effective. The third lesson is that the quality of the interface is not something that can be inspected after the fact. You cannot see a disbonding crack with the naked eye, and even ultrasonic testing may not detect it if the crack is tight and parallel to the interface. The only way to ensure a sound bond is to control the welding process, the consumables, and the heat treatment so that the interface is clean, free of carbides, and free of hydrogen. This study is a landmark contribution to the understanding of disbonding, and it is required reading for any engineer involved in the fabrication of hydrogen service vessels.
Zhuojin Pipe Fitting Co., Ltd